I think we are all naturally inclined to believe in God, however this sense is repressed as people come to learn scientific/whatever arguments against theism.
Well, y'know perhaps because people like some form of hope, and perhaps a form of non-existent hope. But y'know, if it works for you, I'm not gonna bother you about it.

God told me I'm right.
The same logic could be used for "the fairies told me I'm right". The only difference is the fact that you have more believers on your side than I have on my side.