Bioshock 2

[naut]

Bioshock blows STALKER out of the water on any single level.

Where?

Originality. On par.
Atmosphere. No, about par there.
Graphics. Yes, obviously.
Storyline. On par.
Interface. On par, they both have their intricacies and annoyances.
Level design. No.

For me STALKER is awesome. For it's ridiculousness and its flaws that are a symptom of pushing the limits. Bioshock is a little, safe for my tastes. But, each to their own.

If Bioshock 2 is an improvement and a fresh view of the game then yes it'll be awesome.