Mafia IX: Triumph of the Mafia [Concluded]

[Kagemusha]

Thanks GH! Sasaki your skills at mafia detecting are becoming dangerously good.

[TinCow]

Thanks GH! Sasaki your skills at mafia detecting are becoming dangerously good.

Indeed, though I give most of the credit to Renata for nabbing Chaotix.

[Renata]

Woot we won! No thanks to me.

I will just slink off extremely embarrassed now. :)

[Subotan]

And I would have gotten away with it, if it hadn't been for those meddling townies.

Seriously though, super game.

[Renata]

Oh geez I did get Chaotix. Yippee!!! High fives all around!

[Askthepizzaguy]

That's awesome. I also correctly voted both of them. Pretty sweet.

Sorry, Methos and Sasaki! had to give it a shot. I'm just glad I abandoned that whole premise and listened to Sasaki.

[Chaotix]

Good game, all!

We thought for a moment that Subotan might get a free ride all the way to the end, until you managed to realize that he existed last round.

EDIT: Also, once GH has his own commentary up, I'll post all of the PM-strategizing that Subotan and I did thoughout the course of the game.

[seireikhaan]

Good game, all!

We thought for a moment that Subotan might get a free ride all the way to the end, until you managed to realize that he existed last round.

EDIT: Also, once GH has his own commentary up, I'll post all of the PM-strategizing that Subotan and I did thoughout the course of the game.

Oh goodie, I was hoping you were mafia. Most excellent.

Kudos to Sasaki for correctly ID'ing Subotan.

Thanks for the great game as usual, GH.

[White_eyes:D]

Sasaki strikes again....Good game everyone(I knew Reenk was not guilty of that write-up, it just didn't have his originality to it)

Peg my playstyle perfectly though

[Renata]

GH's write-up on your lynch made the whole GAME, as far as I'm concerned, 'Khaan. An instant classic. :)

Thanks, GH.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Awesome!

I think Subo would have got off scott free if it weren't for our pm exchange in the Shadow Fort. He acted like he had no idea who reenk was and didn't know who the noble was and had me running in circles for a day or so before I put the loose ends together.

So his very genuine/careless tone and sincere sounding defenses left me unmoved.

[Secura]

Good job guys. :3

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Also, I think it's hilarious that khaan's random wagon strategy hit mafia on day 2. And then Chaotix got himself lynched by overreacting to the threat.

[Renata]

And then Subotan did NOT vote Methos to tie it up at the end -- and he could have; he was DNV that day and Chaotix only got lynched by one vote. What a crazy day! And the vast majority of us had no clue it was happening.

[GeneralHankerchief]

EDIT: Also, once GH has his own commentary up, I'll post all of the PM-strategizing that Subotan and I did thoughout the course of the game.

By all means, post away. Don't wait for me.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Also, I think it's hilarious that khaan's random wagon strategy hit mafia on day 2. And then Chaotix got himself lynched by overreacting to the threat.

This is why I obey master Khaan, and was sorely disappointed in all of you who killed him!

j/k

[Subotan]

Awesome!

I think Subo would have got off scott free if it weren't for our pm exchange in the Shadow Fort. He acted like he had no idea who reenk was and didn't know who the noble was and had me running in circles for a day or so before I put the loose ends together.

So his very genuine/careless tone and sincere sounding defenses left me unmoved.

Gah, foiled by metagaming My approach to you and the whole town in Shadow Fort was exactly how you described it, "running rings around you" in a bid to buy both myself and Reenk time.

You still have loose ends to tie up regarding what we did in that game btw.

So his very genuine/careless tone and sincere sounding defenses left me unmoved.

I panicked when I came online on my dad's iPhone to find twenty posts of evidence highlighting my crimes. The brinkmanship which I resorted to earlier would have failed me in that situation, and I overreacted

Woot we won! No thanks to me.

I will just slink off extremely embarrassed now. :)

Well you called me "COLD", which is probably the greatest compliment I've ever seen in a mafia game, so my complete duping of you will be forgiven

(I knew Reenk was not guilty of that write-up, it just didn't have his originality to it)

I was late with those orders, and I had to think of a weapon in a few seconds. I'd just seen a documentary on snapping turtles, so

And then Subotan did NOT vote Methos to tie it up at the end -- and he could have; he was DNV that day and Chaotix only got lynched by one vote. What a crazy day! And the vast majority of us had no clue it was happening.

I also could have voted for Sasaki to keep myself alive on the last day. But I doubt that would have affected the outcome of the lynch. However, I am kicking myself over the failure to save Chaotix

[White_eyes:D]

I was late with those orders, and I had to think of a weapon in a few seconds. I'd just seen a documentary on snapping turtles, so

Yeah, had it not been for those "snapping turtles" I would have hounded Reenk even after I died

[Thermal]

Well done Sasaki! =)

Brilliant game and brilliant write ups, the idea of a cow and lemur fighting was fairly amusing in itself.

Were the write ups the genius from subotan & choatix themselves then or was our dear host making them?

[Subotan]

We were thinking of the weapons, whilst GH incorporated them into his own write-ups.

The Final Battle was all his though

[Askthepizzaguy]

One person I was not suspicious of all game was Reenk Roink. It was quite clear to me those write-ups were not his doing, and his voting pattern indicated usual Reenkness.

[Thermal]

One person I was not suspicious of all game was Reenk Roink. It was quite clear to me those write-ups were not his doing, and his voting pattern indicated usual Reenkness.

And me, no one was suspicious of me

[Askthepizzaguy]

The only really suspect thing you ever did was latch onto that Pizza WIFOM in the writeups.



Bad Mercury! Bad! No biscuit.

[Thermal]

The only really suspect thing you ever did was latch onto that Pizza WIFOM in the writeups.



Bad Mercury! Bad! No biscuit.

But they told me you were guilty!

Bad write ups! Bad!

I want a biscuit

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Nice game. Excellent write ups!
My first mafia game where I wasn't killed or lynched!!

And... I told you so.. That I wasn't mafia!!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Yeah, the weapons got a bit ridiculous at the end. I think I gave subtle hints to my mafia colleagues saying as much when I had the "door-to-door" mafioso (always Subotan's personality, btw) ask out loud how you manage to kill someone with a cheese grater and the a round later when he told his target that he had come to beat them to death with a rolling pin.

Bessie provided a nice outlet for my frustration though. I deliberately left her fate ambiguous at the end just in case someone decides to bring her back one day.

[Beefy187]

Heh I got it completely wrong
Thanks for the good challenge Subo and Chaotix
And big thanks to GH for hosting this

Another big thanks to towns brains. We wouldn't have won without you lads

[Thermal]

Bessie provided a nice outlet for my frustration though. I deliberately left her fate ambiguous at the end just in case someone decides to bring her back one day.

Perhaps bessie is closer than we think

looks at beefy*

[Chaotix]

Yeah, the weapons got a bit ridiculous at the end. I think I gave subtle hints to my mafia colleagues saying as much when I had the "door-to-door" mafioso (always Subotan's personality, btw) ask out loud how you manage to kill someone with a cheese grater and the a round later when he told his target that he had come to beat them to death with a rolling pin.

Bessie provided a nice outlet for my frustration though. I deliberately left her fate ambiguous at the end just in case someone decides to bring her back one day.

Apologies for that. Both were my ideas.

I thought of the cheese grater and rolling pin as more "pizza" tools. Particularly with the cheese grater I had an image in my mind of the target's face being graphically grated off. The rolling pin kill was pretty much exactly what I expected, though.

I'll get those PMs structured into a nice post now...

EDIT: Pic of a cheese grater. Those holes are sharp! Imagine having that thing scraped across your face.

[Askthepizzaguy]

It was you behind all that rampant Pizza WIFOM?

I'm going to get you back for that someday. I don't know when or how, but I've got your number my friend. You're going down!