The Revenge of Inishmore! [Concluded]

**ULC** · 04-17-2010, 19:51

Originally Posted by Chaotix

No, not really. I was joking.

Not nice.

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

This is false. Anyone can talk privately in this game, and you always have a few people you think are innocent. The ability to prevent a mislynch is absolutely huge.

But we aren't going to kill you, because one of your mason partners will claim before you are lynched, right?

No it isn't a bad claim for mafia.

unvote, vote:YLC

Sasaki, your specifically targeting me, using some of the weirdest logic yet. First of all, the ability to prevent a mislynch is NOT huge, it's a stupid maneuver that nets the mafia two clean targets. Your point that anyone can talk privately is bogus, you know it - Mason's know for sure they are innocent, while simply chatting with another person or thinking that they are innocent is not the same thing, far from it.

And it is a bad claim for a mafioso, and you know it, especially based upon your logic. No one is going to save me from the lynch, especially not my mason partners, whom I will tell specifically not to say anything, because they are not going to risk their lives. As long as they are alive, they can work together, and act as a block.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 04-17-2010, 20:04

Originally Posted by Renata

Three dead and one missing might make me less inclined to call YLC on his lack of confirmation than I would otherwise be -- except that it makes his overnight survival even less explicable. Am I really supposed to believe the mafia bypassed killing a claimed mason in favor of several seemingly random targets just so we'd lynch him today? Why? So they gain one mislynch? By the odds we are probably going to mislynch in any case. I don't buy that.

Right--and why would they think they could get us to mislynch him when his mason partners could just claim?

Originally Posted by YLC

Sasaki, your specifically targeting me, using some of the weirdest logic yet. First of all, the ability to prevent a mislynch is NOT huge, it's a stupid maneuver that nets the mafia two clean targets.

At three kills a night, a mislynch means 4 dead townies.

Your point that anyone can talk privately is bogus, you know it - Mason's know for sure they are innocent, while simply chatting with another person or thinking that they are innocent is not the same thing, far from it.

It's a minor difference at best. How do you think pro town networks get started?

And it is a bad claim for a mafioso, and you know it, especially based upon your logic. No one is going to save me from the lynch, especially not my mason partners, whom I will tell specifically not to say anything, because they are not going to risk their lives. As long as they are alive, they can work together, and act as a block.

My logic, which, if it wasn't being argued by me wouldn't have been strongly argued. I don't think it's come up before in a .org game.

You would let yourself be mislynched so that one of your partners isn't killed? This sounds more like an excuse for no one claiming to be your partner, sorry.