The Revenge of Inishmore! [Concluded]

[Thermal]

Chaotix might have messed with us a bit, but that wasn't mafia behavior, bad choice.

[Beefy187]

FoS: Thermal Mercury

[Subotan]

Chaotix might have messed with us a bit, but that wasn't mafia behavior, bad choice.

It looked like mafia behaviour to me

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Sasaki's argument started to appeal. I'd've changed to YLC had I been on earlier.

[Thermal]

It looked like mafia behaviour to me

Would mafia say they investigated someone, then change there story and say there joking, it attracts attention like mad, attention no mafia guy needs, so whilst it was bad behavior, it doesn't make it mafia behavior, think about it.

[Diamondeye]

Thermal is correct.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

There are times when mafiosi behave "over the top" as a sort of reverse-english ploy to be anonymous. I admit that is the exception, not the rule.

[Renata]

Bandwagon continued:

fos: chaotix

He could of got a potentially innocent guy killed just to have a bit of fun. Not the kind of stunt I'd expect mafia to pull of though, he would at least stick to the story, right?

vote: split

following what renata says about his activity, gives us another lynch option.

Is anyone else having trouble with the quote feature?

From post #208.

(snip me questioning the vote, and whether he thinks Chaotix is scum)

I believe his tactic is scummy, not necessarily that he's scum. Stupid question regarding Chaotix, as I voted ACIN (or AVSM) in the Star Wars game because he was going after high post count.

Masons, I think, are better in the end-game assuming they survive. OTOH, claiming mason early in a game does seem a bit like "cover" for some other role. Unfortunately, it's hard to judge whether that role is town, mafia, or neutral. I recall pever's "neutrals" had some real impact in version one.

Joke detective claims are less useful than faked detective claims -- and possibly more annoying.

Vote: Chaotix

fos: chaotix

Faking results even as a joke is poor townie behaviour.

Vote White Eyes

He hasn't posted yet and we are nearing the end of the second day.

Vote:Chaotix

That's not nice

[Renata]

Okay, so that's votes from Csargo, Secura, Zack, Methos, Seamus and Subotan; and FOS'es from Diamondeye, Thermal Mercury and Captain Blackadder.

I'm curious why Reenk is voting for TM, because I find his post the most suspicious of the lot. Not only was it a FOS and not a vote (serving to help the bandwagon along while keeping his hands clean(er) in the even that Chaotix wound up lynched, while voting for a random lurker), but it's internally contradictory:

He could of got a potentially innocent guy killed just to have a bit of fun. Not the kind of stunt I'd expect mafia to pull of though, he would at least stick to the story, right?

If you don't expect mafia to pull the stunt, then you don't FOS him as being Mafia. You might *vote* him for anti-town behavior (given the number of people voting for Chaotix and the reasons given, it's a sure thing at least one townie did just that), but you don't say you're *suspicious* of him.

vote: Thermal Mercury

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Vote:GH

Me miss mooo to!

[Thermal]

Okay, so that's votes from Csargo, Secura, Zack, Methos, Seamus and Subotan; and FOS'es from Diamondeye, Thermal Mercury and Captain Blackadder.

I'm curious why Reenk is voting for TM, because I find his post the most suspicious of the lot. Not only was it a FOS and not a vote (serving to help the bandwagon along while keeping his hands clean(er) in the even that Chaotix wound up lynched, while voting for a random lurker), but it's internally contradictory:


If you don't expect mafia to pull the stunt, then you don't FOS him as being Mafia. You might *vote* him for anti-town behavior (given the number of people voting for Chaotix and the reasons given, it's a sure thing at least one townie did just that), but you don't say you're *suspicious* of him.

vote: Thermal Mercury

You begin saying those who voted for Chaotix are the most suspicious, then you pick me out for FoS'ing him, even after his lynch I expressed my dislike of it for reasons already mentioned. I'll remind you that FoS = Finger of suspicion, Because he did a suspicious thing, but as I already said, not a mafia thing. I think your reasoning is fairly vague at best.

[Renata]

You begin saying those who voted for Chaotix are the most suspicious, then you pick me out for FoS'ing him, even after his lynch I expressed my dislike of it for reasons already mentioned. I'll remind you that FoS = Finger of suspicion, Because he did a suspicious thing, but as I already said, not a mafia thing. I think your reasoning is fairly vague at best.

You can think that all you like. Tell me what "suspicious" is supposed to mean in the context of a game like this, if not that you think that Chaotix might be mafia (or other anti-town role).

Pointing out that you turned around and criticized a lynch you'd been a part of doesn't exactly help your case.

[Niklas]

This game is totally making my head spin. Take that as a compliment, pevergreen.

I will vote: AVSM. His out-of-context "Wait, we got PMs?" just screams WIFOM.

[Thermal]

Pointing out that you turned around and criticized a lynch you'd been a part of doesn't exactly help your case.

I wasn't part of it, by the time I made my comments he already received a runaway bandwagon and I was no part of that, I simply acknowledged his 'unusual' behavior (another way of putting it) with a FoS, as a few others did, to show I didn't approve of his posts, more or less.

How you come to the conclusion that I wanted him lynched when even in the post I FoS'd him I said it was a bad idea, is beyond me.


-----

In other news, GH looked to be at the bane of a mafia target, I think hes innocent.