Mathematically ACIN's claimed vig hits are equally as suspicious, far more successful than he should be, and we don't know about any of his other actions or goals or talent, plus his votes have never been stellar. If you could somehow get Visorslash, the remaining South Park, to cough up who his faction rivals are finally that would be great.
It is a little frustrating that Kage has like three roleblock items, three defender items, and a couple vigilante items and obviously can't use all of them. I don't know what's been passed onto between you three (Kage, Roman, BL) though.
As for something else related, think I counted right, and looking at some items:
dcmort was an Innocent vigilante
BRay was an Innocent vigilante
Psychonaut was an Innocent vigilante
Bow-wow-wow was an Innocent vigilante
Death is Yonder was an Innocent vigilante
Ironside was an Innocent vigilante
Blackadder2 was an Innocent vigilante
YLC was an Innocent vigilante
Jolt was a neutral vigilante, he got voted an item rather than one of his own but presumably had another talent/ability on that
Among living players:
mythmonster/khaan had a vigilante item, Renata stole it
Backwards Logic has a hidden talent for vigilante-ing
Romanic has a vigilante item
Beefy is a vigilante, ability-based presumably
ACIN has a vigilante item
It might be worth numbering off many of the items that we know of in other categories, considering there seem to be around 10 or so each of vigilante, roleblock, bulletproof, retaliatory, and scan items obviously at 1 per faction, then a few of the more unusual bus driver and defender items not counting rare, unique, or chaotic items.
When I went and made this list actually surprised at how many items in total have come up, especially vigilantes as that's mostly not even counting unknown people who also had hidden talents for vigging.
I think the vigilante setup is the most interesting of all though. So, now, what were the dead chaotics?
-Diamondeye was a scanner
-God Emperor was a reviver, seems to have passed on items to a partner before his lynch so harder to say what his cover role did
-Seon also didn't live long enough to really tell what his cover role was "supposed to do", maybe self-defense as he had a retaliatory item
-Chaotix was a lover plus he had a retaliatory item, maybe self-defense theme again.
As for other serial killers/neutrals:
-Renata was a thief and protector
-ARPThis was a busdriver and silencer
-Blackadder was bulletproof
-Beskar was bulletproof
(Jolt was also bulletproof as one of his own items)
None of the chaotics have been found with a roleblock (we also have a lot of dead Innocent roleblockers we could list, and really we already know who that points back to being suspicious) or a vigilante item or talent as far as I could see. That simply doesn't sit right at all considering roleblock and vigilante are two of the most common items. And considering that it makes sense the chaotics are less likely to have, say, a bulletproof (all neutrals did in retrospect which is interesting) and it would really be expected they would have those other types of items and abilities.
So it's interesting that the pattern of vig items does not seem at all balanced between factions nor the Innocents and non-Innocents in general. I think it's doubtful that none of the chaotics had a vigilante cover role, especially considering who we have left, and roleblocking is also a possibility to look over.
Beefy and khaan both seem to check out as Innocent vigs and the chaotic on that team wasn't one of the chaotics who was commonly killing, besides the dead players now that continues to make more sense to me.
I have to question why there seem to have been four vigilantes on the Evil Mafia faction - YLC, Roman, ACIN, and BL with a hidden talent, if you supposed they are all Innocent, the same personal goal to "use their item" for at least a couple and so on. Combined with the lack of cover for any chaotics or serial killer, and Jolt is maybe questionable, do we believe that all the vigilantes have been Innocent the entire time? For that matter I have to wonder, as almost all of the above people's items except what Renata ran off with, have been voted to this group of Innocents, why we haven't been having more near 100% successes at the various actions possible. BL, have you been doing something silly like letting nearly 100% worth of vigilante items go entirely to waste while you are scanning as also an item-based ability?
Bookmarks