Quote Originally Posted by Husar View Post
Well, for Fragony it is certainly not that way as you can see above, and since Kad used to defend Fragony a lot, I can see how it is easily confusing. And what is so informative about saying that the people who believe in the caliphate believe in the caliphate and act as the caliphate wishes? If they didn't then they wouldn't believe in the caliphate. Fragony does at least have some sort of message, even if it's wrong, maybe that led Hax to take it that way because otherwise it's not really saying a lot. Not to forget that Kad talks about a muslim perspective and then goes on talking about an ISIS-follower perspective if your interpretation is correct. Fragony clearly claims that ISIS has the only true muslim perspective and therefore all muslims should follow ISIS or they are not true muslims. Except that Fragony thinks ISIS follow Islam and muslims don't so he doesn't really think that, he instead thinks that all followers of Islam should follow ISIS and Muslims follow.....I don't know....muslimism, the religion of musli??
Well, I don't think Kad was trying to be profound, he was just saying ISIS has a sort of internal logic and he likes the idea of all the Muslim fundies being in one basket, as that makes it easier to know who they are and take them out.

I can't really fault that if you think killing all Muslim fundamentalists is the way to go, and I'm not sure it isn't.

Fragony, now Fragony is really quite brilliant and subtle and his underlying argument is entirely lucid and coherent, even when he isn't.

It comes down to this - what makes one a follower of Islam? Fragony believes the answer is following the Koran, and he's correct that doing so brings you much closer to ISIS than a moderate Western Muslim.