Pirate Ship Mafia III [Concluded]

[Zack]

It makes perfect sense to lie about s block if spaceman is french, so that's a null point

[Lissa]

spaceman is defending you but you're not defending him at all, which makes me think you are the head honcho and thus a higher priority.

Him being scum/me being town is a scenario that exists logically

Him being town/me being scum is a scenario that is far less likely logically so it'd make some sense for him to push the idea of both of us being town instead of that

anyway he's hardly defending me

[Lissa]

It makes perfect sense to lie about s block if spaceman is french, so that's a null point

it doesn't really to me, but I'm obviously biased, so that's a null point, ya. my point is, if they blocked me because I was one of the people trying to kill spaceman that's hardly random/reasonless.

[Zack]

Sure but you weren't blocked so it's immaterial

[Zack]

I can see you lying about a block to go do your thing and it being unrelated to spaceman.

I just don't see you being blocked, I don't think you're ever town, while space might be

[Double A]

I've come to the conclusion that I'm actually terrible at large games with a lot of power roles because I can't get any reads.

[Ituralde]

Ah it be difficult with so many people goin around at nights. Then there be talk about this third party? Makes me wonder what happened to the first and second party on this ship. Surely the storm last night don't count as no party.

I have no tally, but I agree that between Lissa and spaceman98 the latter looks more suspiciouiousious... French!
But then I had me eyes on Lissa for a while now.

Really hope the Captains investigation of the other murders turns up something useful and the First Mate scans some highly suspicious people tonight. I hope this provides some new leads. Right now there's too many explanations for a lot of behaviours.

[Sprig]

I've come to the conclusion that I'm actually terrible at large games with a lot of power roles because I can't get any reads.

Don't be so hard on yourself, I voiced my objection at the time. But you have the hat!


Unvote;el Barto; vote Lissa. Lissa over spaceman makes the most sense.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Why? Gold's pretty useless at this point. The top brass has been in place for the last few rounds, and the only way to keep up with them would be to steal.

Well?

Helloooooooo?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Also myself and Pizza are basically the only people who know lissa here before this game

Oh and Jim

But two of us couldn't have done anything and I highly doubt pizza did

So there is literally no reason for her to be blocked save stopping a kill

I wouldn't have messed with Lissa that early. On my honor.

[Visor]

I wouldn't have messed with Lissa that early. On my honor.

yeah i doubt you would've.

Whatddya think? The block makes little sense unless they're both french or spaceman is IMO.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yeah, spaceman's been rubbing me the wrong way for days, and I've had no opinion of Lissa but no objection to her being a suspect.

Admittedly, I'm not as focused on the roleblock thing because I've been distracted by the shiny (gold) and the pretty () but I think the folks who are looking at it closely know what they're doing.

I know this sounds weird but I don't really follow the roleblock thing. I understand it's basically an accusation that the roleblock was invented, so that way they could explain why a vig group didn't work?

And there's been nights with no reported roleblocks?

That smells a lot more like a lie than the truth. I can't suggest any other alternative. String em up, walk em off the plank.

They should have bribed me. I'd have been bribed. I promise you that much!

[Askthepizzaguy]

I could have looked scummy for you and then left the ship just as the vigs came for me.

For the right price, I'd have assembled secret vig groups for you. Oh, my talents have gone to utter waste. No one wants them.

It's fine. I can make my own gold and watch the French flag burn. It's all the same to me!

[NotJimRV]

Not to detract from the current spaceman wagon, but could this be rephrased into a manner I can better understand?

Bsmith killed, then I stole, then Bsmith scans as innocent?

The two tracks were on the night before - the scan was done last night.

Sorry laddies, hit a giant burnout patch and been not much for thinking recently. But looking at the thread for now I think I'll go with

vote: spaceman

[GeneralHankerchief]

Voting closed.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Day 4

Even though many of the crewmen of the Presence seemed tired out after the previous day's arguments and then the massive storm that evening, it seemed as if today's arguments re-invigorated them. There was a general consensus that this discussion was good and piratical, what with Sprig's blatant murder attempt on Askthepizzaguy being mentioned and then summarily dismissed as irrelevant, gold changing hands for the amusing purpose of having one person vote for themselves, and then, the main focus of the day, the accusations being centered around spaceman98 and Lissa.

"I be tellin' ye," Lissa protested for seemingly the millionth time. "I tried to kill him the first night, but couldn't! Somebody stopped me!?"

"You were thrown in the brig?"

"No, somebody just stopped me!"

"That's it? Ye weren't offered a strong swig o' rum and then passed out? Weren't distracted by any figure callin' hisself Sexy Jeff? Weren't knocked upside the head with a heavy object?"

"Nay! Somebody just stopped me!"

Everybody moaned. "Well, that be anticlimactic. Also, I'm not sure if I be buyin' it, since apparently this strangest of actions only be happenin' to you."

"Oh come on!" Lissa protested. This was the most unfair thing ever. Her protests were in vain, though, as more and more people joined in on the chorus against her. Among these voices was spaceman himself, who had received a ton of votes earlier in the day but now, with the outcome in doubt, apparently grew enough confidence to make his voice heard. "Yeah!" he said. "Lissa's totally suspicious! And, uh, I'm not at all! Vote for her, laddies, she's got that French stink all over her!"

"That be grog and the sea, same as the rest of us," said another sailor, "not perfume. An' what are ye doing, anyway? She may have been blocked, but she was tryin' to kill *you* by all accounts that night. Actin' on insider information, eh?"

"Are you seriously suggesting that my wanting to live is now a trait of the Frenchman and his hirelings, and just them?"

"Uh..." the other sailor paused for a minute. ".............yes?"

"I hate everything," spaceman said. He didn't utter another word for the rest of the day, not even when he was ordered to walk the plank.

After that was over, Captain Double A took to address the crew. "Right laddies, that's another one down. Startin' tomorrow morning, I'll be startin' to have results on those who we've already lost. That'll be sure to aid our continuin' investigation, but let's also hope that there be no further cause for investigatin' in the first place. See you all in the morning."

Day 4 tally:
spaceman98: 9 (Askthepizzaguy, Visorslash, Montmorency, Gaius Scribonius Curio, johnhughthom, Lissa, autolycus, Ishmael, NotJimRV)
Lissa: 8 (Ituralde, BSmith, Zack, Choxorn, Golden1Knight, Csargo, spaceman98, Sprig)
Sprig: 1 (landlubber)
Visorslash: 1 (Andres)
El Barto: 1 (El Barto)
Askthepizzaguy: 1 (TheFlax)

Abstained: 1 (Double A)
Didn't vote: none!

It is now Night 4. Please send in your orders. Night 4 will conclude on Wednesday, October 7th, at 16:00 US Eastern Time.



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Attacked: spaceman98 (n1), Askthepizzaguy (n1, n3), Csargo (n2), Andres (n3)

Killed: TFT (n1), seireikhaan (n2), Ice (n3)

Mutinied: Kagemusha (d2)

Abandoned Ship: Ironside (n2)

Walked the plank: Xiahou (d3), spaceman98 (d4)

Souls aboard: (21)
Andres
Askthepizzaguy
autolycus
BSmith
Choxorn
Csargo
Double A
El Barto
Gaius Scribonius Curio
Golden1Knight
Ishmael
Ituralde
johnhughthom
landlubber
Lissa
Montmorency
NotJimRV
Sprig
TheFlax
Visorslash
Zack

[El Barto]

I wasn't thinking.

An' tha' be why I has four more doubloons than before.

I'd rather have my gold in my own pocket, personally.

I as well would rather have yer gold in me own pocket, mon.

Why? Gold's pretty useless at this point. The top brass has been in place for the last few rounds, and the only way to keep up with them would be to steal.

Gae on, lad, I be listenin'…

if they knew she was part of a vig group? Potential chance to frame two people at once

Why be ye makin' sic an effor' tae defend yonder lady?

I realize that you are going to kill me regardless and I get it, but anyone voting me over/before spaceman is scummy because the mechanical things that implicate me and spaceman implicate spaceman more strongly

order matters because a vig is more blockable than a lynch and another night alive for spaceman means if he's french he can do things tonight

Wish flips took less than three days so you could see this sooner, I know it's kinda useless from any perspective but mine right now

And me being blocked makes perfect sense if spaceman is french

Nah, does no' make any sense 'cept in the case whar he can't actually convert -which be nae real. I amn't buyin' yer stuff.

[Andres]

@Andres Can you confirm?

For 1 gold, I'll tell you in private; 3 gold for a public post.

[El Barto]

An' if he wants both it be four gold in all?

[Csargo]

For 1 gold, I'll tell you in private; 3 gold for a public post.

Deal. 3 gold it is.

Pm sent to GH.

[El Barto]

Andres, ye daft numptie, ye be sellin' oot cheap! A got four gold fer makin' an inconsequential pos' only yesterday!

[Sprig]

Public Duels when only one person attempt to murder, sound like a thing I should try to do tonight!

"Argh, I wouldn't recommend this *Squawk*."

Squawky Jim looked a bit sheepish.

"Turns out, I nearly died. *Squawk.*"

- - -

Reading through this. Some one helpfully pointed out in the rules that not only does failure have a chance of being revealed but, but a chance of death also.

[Visor]

Lissa is being thrown in the brig.

[Zack]

Get your orders in vigilantes. This is important.

[Andres]

Deal. 3 gold it is.

Pm sent to GH.

My N1 investigation told me that Kagemusha was guarding gold and Double A was putting someone in the brig. Nothing more, nothing less.

Results are different if you investigate only 1 person.
@Csargo

Verstuurd vanaf mijn SM-G357FZ met Tapatalk

[Zack]

My N1 investigation told me that Kagemusha was guarding gold and Double A was putting someone in the brig. Nothing more, nothing less.

Results are different if you investigate only 1 person.
@Csargo

Verstuurd vanaf mijn SM-G357FZ met Tapatalk

didn't you already say this in the thread? lol

[Visor]

Csargo doesn't trust the faceless evil me or AA.

[Zack]

Why was BSmith tracked and then scanned? It's an odd choice, especially the redundancy/wastefulness of it.

Why has Visor not been scanned at all, and Double A not been scanned (was only tracked n1)?

[Ituralde]

Finally someone be askin the right qurstions! What be the Captain and his men doing?

[Montmorency]

Don't you consider yourself one of the Captain's men? :(