I don't know if I believe it but here is the thing
Let me tell you the kinds of derps and dumbtells I have seen in my ancient amount of years
Last year (I think) Return of the Clowns game, Lightfoot as town with moderator powers was reading the game, and making a post with claims in it.
instead of replying to an old post, she edited that old post, so that she edited in a claim she saw later in the thread, before the claim was ever made.
It looked like, since no "edited by" showed up, since she is a moderator, that she predicted Colby's claim.
Colby was obviously a wolf, and therefore, her predicting Colby's claim in advance made it seem like she had wolf chat with Colby.
Everything else she posted all game was townie and herself.
Worse, she has terrible memory and DIDNT REMEMBER SHE EDITED THE POST. FLAT OUT DID NOT KNOW SHE DID IT AT ALL. Couldn't explain how it happened, didn't even know that it happened.
That one post made me throw out my town read on her and start over as possibly outed.
I eventually decided..... if every single other post in the game is townie, then she fooled me.
If I can't town read her or wolf read her based on all her other posts, outside of that one anomaly, that might have spewed her wolf wolf with Colby, evidence of sharing a wolf chat, then I didn't want to let a mistake that gross impact the game.
I chose to ignore what should have been outing evidence she couldn't explain as TMI and always wolf wolf with Colby.
I town read her based on 99 percent of her iso otherwise.
And she was town. And we defeated all 3 actual wolves.
I have seen the impossible, wolfiest derps.
I do not accept derp clears anymore, and I do not find derps to be wolfy. Derps are tactics as wolf, and townies can derp so hard, in a wolfy enough way, that I refuse to alignment read a derp anymore.
Forever, as a policy.
If I cannot read you based on 99 out of 100 other posts in your eventual iso, I dont deserve to townread you or wolf catch you based on any derp.
End of policy rant about derpclears and dumbtells.
TLDR, as a policy, due to specific examples over the years, nothing derpclearing is clearing, and wolfy dumbtells can come from townies enough that I throw away all that evidence as crappy evidence.
It's as valid to me now as third on the wagon is always a wolf. It's just not true, it correlated once upon a time.
Derpclears correlated with townie behavior, wolfy dumbtells that look fake correlated with wolfy behavior once upon a time.
We're mostly stone cold veterans.
All that stuff is beyond NAI now. Throw it away.
My advice, ignore me on it if you wanna solve it your own way.
This is the most assertively i think Ive ever declared something null, ever. I am passionate about this being null.
This is in general, I reserve the right to find something particularly difficult to fake derp or find something impossibly wolfy and vote it, but.
It's gotta be super exceptional. Way worse than the Lightfoot example above.
Good choice, someone tried to derpclear me when I was mafia before, it is a play I sometimes like doing on purpose. I was just wondering because of this + the reasons you were townreading me. I know both instances are fairly different though.
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
All of the bolded are wolftells.
Please continue villaging if you are, villagers wolftell.
Interesting post
Originally Posted by Visor
Random aside - I don't think monty is a Wolfy villager, I just think people find it hard to follow his logic sometimes and then assume it must make him a wolf
I think last game I played with Monty, Monty got POE voted out I think when they were indeed town.
Originally Posted by Logic
I feel more attacked by this than your naked vote.
I don't necessarily get this. You see, with some of my posts I had humor in mind. I do not get that impression from your posts this game. Perhaps this was posting just to post
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Phrased exactly how I mean it, because I am adopting the new closed notebook style for everything null and above.
I do not object to Taffy and Monty seeing Day 2, so far.
Interesting read especially on Taffy who is hardly a presence so far and hasn't been towny at all.
I am assuming this all has to do with some of what Ender said about Taffy
Taffy/Monty = NAI or towny, unsure yet
Taffy I think doesn't treat me like this as wolf but that's much weaker and pending further posts.
So I am taking it Pizza is going with a cautionary angle where Ender has TMI. Though I feel like this POV is better to have if you are actually actively wolfreading Ender which it appears ATPG is not exactly.
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Leans list, Closed Notebook style: (All other names redacted, in some order of townie to null, with tiers.)
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Lean wolf (barely... call this "votable" tier.)
5. Ampharos
Unsorted (which means I have reads on everyone else and do not wish to vote unless I can townread Ampharos and/or a lot of unsorteds.)
Re: Casual december game
Originally Posted by Ampharos
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks