Gemma's Favorite Music Mafia

[nebjiamn]

obligatory: no one gets a ton of cred for killing an afk wolf but i still want to say the rask wagon is pure. i was sorta wigged out by lissa's eod in the moment, but in the context of her not wanting to kill taffy, pushing on arctic sorta makes sense? I'm not sure, will table for now, but I have her town otherwise

n1 thoughts:

• i thought arctic was pure af during eod which is the main issue giving me pause with lissa. i didn't agree with his push on taffy but i also didn't hate it from him.
• i think visor had a towny eod and i tr'd him before it, so he should be town
• i think stett's town regardless of the vote and idt she'd bus there over a multitude of options if she was a wolf anyway
• i'm certain annika is town from the eod. not really even cause she voted rask and rask flipped wolf, but because of the conviction she had in wanting to save arctic there and not just defaulting to someone like taffy and stayed pretty strong on maple. the vote is icing on the cake--probably technically within her range nowadays but i'll roll with town based off the other stuff anyway.
• i thought ender had a good eod even though he was voting and pushing arctic most of it? like it felt more real than it did from lissa
• maple's eod was terrible IMO. the omgus on annika wasn't good but even worse to me was the conviction and refusal to reconsider--perhps an unfair read since annika wasn't really re-evaling maple either--but a lot of maple's responses just read like "wolf smells blood, sinks teeth deeper into victim", unfounded confidence powerwolf kinda vibes
• i cannot make sense of waza's vote when he was jokingly pushing rask all day, he should have been fine to just kill there over a pr claim? but i want to see his reasoning for landing on taffy.
• taffy could ceratinly still be a wolf but IMO the juice wasn't worth the squeeze after the claim and hopefully they are either deador have some kind of information today. dipping out after claiming PR should be NAI but i will concede to the taffy voters that it didn't look great
• if taffy is town i kinda hate ladd, but if taffy is wolf i love him. a lot of the reason i was trying to silently push him after post-cap 'lift' was a lot of ladd's reads have bugged me in how non-collaboriative they have been. i was willing to test that cause i sorta agreed with the taffy read upon my own re-read, but when taffy claimed/if taffy is real, that non-collaboriativeness in his reads feels more wolfy to me (reads specifically i can think of this applies to are: taffy/sunbae/initial dya read but there are prob a few others i'm forgetting atm)
• pzelda not around for EOD but not really going to worry about them. THEY are actually the d1 threadspewed villager IMO and if they're wolf then shame on everyone for letting silly meta reads get in the way of discussion around their slot
• dya not around for EOD but I just sorta think they're town from their posting. would like to see where they are today and how they post before locking anything in but i feel good about them.
• sunbae could go either way. i thought his wall was OK but the wolf read on dya i don't really love? and the whole PR claim fiasco after taffy did was pretty wolfy and some of it reeked of kinda "salty wolf whos miselim just got ran through" -- admittedly some of this is offset by him being an absolute clown at eod and drawing a picture of me crying (i laughed out loud btw, stellar drawing)

i think some post-eod clarity makes some of taffy sus live make more sense. since they went afk it felt kinda wild to see them wagoned without having any posts beyond that pr claim, but the beauty of retrospect kinda shows me how reasonable that actually was at the time. still wanna see wazas reasoning though


so here's where i am after day 1. tier 1 and 2 are ordered, tiers 3 and 4 are unordered within:

always town (0 wolves)
nebjiamn
annika
didistetter

exceedingly likely to be town (hopefully 0 wolves in this)
visor
lissa
pzelda

townleans (0-1 wolves in this and the exceedingly like to be town pile)
arctic
dyachei
ender

concern pile (1-2 wolves, hopefully 2 )
taffy
sunbae
maple
ladd - always town if taffy is wolf
waza

---

of my concern pile, some unlikely (but not impossible!) pairings off the top of my head:
ladd/taffy (ok this one should be impossible)
waza/taffy (bussing taffy at EoD would be nuts with rask as someone he was soft pushing all day anyway, kinda absurd to not take the credit on rask he was claiming all day if taffy is also a wolf)
sunbae/waza

some pairings that i think work from my concern pile
sunbae/ladd
sunbae/maple
sunbae/taffy
ladd/waza
maple/taffy
maple/waza (waza never discusses maple at all except to say maple is in a large poe of potential wolves at the start of game. maple townleans waza twice. but afaict they dont have any interactions)


possibly unnecessary caveat: its very very possible that my concern pile does NOT have all 2 wolves, so i'm not really solving for today's wolf based on that and IDRT anyone else should either. especially in the context of rask being afk and us not really having valuable info for interactions there. ill just be voting who i think is most likely to be wolf period.


and with that said i kinda wana just kill maple and go to d3 but lettuce see what today brings

---

this spot saved for the post-nightphase RIP nightkill comment:

RIP sunbae GG

---

this spot saved for the post-nightphase RIP stettdiedn1 again comment if stett dies instead of anyone else:

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO STETT YOU DUMB BITCH WHY DID YOU DIE AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH