Ibn has a role of some sort (as demonstrated by him faking a townie role PM) and doesn't seem inclined to convince us it's a pro-town role. I agree he can't be the .44 killer because he appears to have been blocked after GH was, ah, talked to. However, that still leaves the supernatural thing and Isabelle. The supernatural thing (hereinafter ST) might be neutral or pro-town, but Isabelle is definitely not.
Time for another summary of who can be what, assuming (*cough*) that GH is legit.
GeneralHankerchief - The Guide and cannot be ST, as he was 'attacked' by it on N9.
Glyphz - Cannot be ST or .44 Magnum killer, as he was blocked by GH on N7, when both appeared.
Seamus Fermanagh - Cannot be ST or .44 Magnum killer, as he was blocked by GH on N7, when both appeared.
Lord Winter - Cannot be .44 Magnum killer, as was blocked by GH on N9. Could be ST, as the nature of the N9 write-up and GH's PM from Andres make it plausible that the ST could have talked to GH despite being one of the blocked.
Ibn-Khaldun - Cannot be .44 Magnum killer, as was blocked by GH on N9. Could be ST, as the nature of the N9 write-up and GH's PM from Andres make it plausible that the ST could have talked to GH despite being one of the blocked.
boudica - Can be ST or .44 Magnum killer.
YLC - Can be ST or .44 Magnum killer.
So, our only options for the .44 are boudica and YLC.
Now, there is some other evidence to point towards. On Night 5, we had another one of these 'Mexican Standoffs'. Unlike the other one, the Night 5 write-up doesn't talk about a .44 Magnum. However, if we assume it was the same person, then that clears boudica of being the .44 Magnum killer, as she was blocked by GH that night. So, if you want to go with that assumption, by process of elimination YLC must be the .44 Magnum killer.
Bookmarks