The Settlement [Concluded]

**Askthepizzaguy** · 03-20-2009, 12:47

Maybe I am tired from lack of sleep, but I've noticed more than one townie accuse me of overlooking something, when they themselves grossly overlooked something in that very same accusation.

Two in the past hour, privately.

Please, before you tell me I'm not paying attention, please recheck your facts first. Thanks much.

**Seamus Fermanagh** · 03-20-2009, 13:01

While I am gratified to those who were kind enough to forward me information, I caution ALL players against jumping to decisions on lynches.

Sasaki is quite correct in that we should be careful about ASSUMING we know who did what murders. There is evidence in the write ups and we should make tentative assessments of who was mafia killed etc. But I stress a note of caution as well.

So far, unless I am totally lost, ALL of the roles contain a bit of sugar/vinegar -- good guy but must outlast X or SK of 33% of town but looking for town win -- and Reenk is a tricksy one. We must have a care for these inherent contradictions (kudos Reenk, its well crafted).

Don't just say "we must lynch x," but reference in the information and provide us a why. The arguments will get better and we'll winnow out the ones whose answers don't come to par.

That's all from "Sheepnet" for now

**Jolt** · 03-20-2009, 13:03

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Maybe I am tired from lack of sleep, but I've noticed more than one townie accuse me of overlooking something, when they themselves grossly overlooked something in that very same accusation.

Two in the past hour, privately.

Please, before you tell me I'm not paying attention, please recheck your facts first. Thanks much.

Well, townies are the uninformed majority. :P

**Askthepizzaguy** · 03-20-2009, 13:39

I feel I was too harsh, even in that carefully worded post. I apologize.

We all make mistakes sometimes. Especially me.

taking a break. Back later.

**boudica** · 03-20-2009, 15:48

ooc: It's going to take me any spare time I get this evening just to go through all those PMs you shepherds shared, let alone catch up on this thread. From skim-reading it I gather that Faction Heir hasn't responded to GH's accusation from beyond the grave.

ATPG - please no need to respond to this: I understand why you would put pressure on players for not responding to your questioning, but your idea of a timely manner is clearly not the same as everyone elses. Remember that while you don't need to catch up with everything you write - the rest of us do - even if it's just to spot the rare and potentially incriminating post by someone else in the thread

**GeneralHankerchief** · 03-20-2009, 17:14

ATPG or Seamus:

Can you please elaborate on this series of PMs? I'm not sure what to make of it:

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Originally Posted by Anonymous Too Living Player

So, can I join the club?

I am on the town's side with a side objective of killing a certain someone (and my kill only works if it is that person, not at other times - then I just nick some items, like a healing potion from sasaki last night)

Yes, providing you quote me your entire role Pm within the next 5 minutes.

Sorry, by now I must be certain. Shady people will try to infiltrate, but I trust you to a certain extent.

he took like 30 seconds to respond with the full thing.

**boudica** · 03-20-2009, 17:43

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

ATPG or Seamus:

Can you please elaborate on this series of PMs? I'm not sure what to make of it:

Seems like Pisuf (is that an insult?) is a paid up member of the United Masonic Shepherd Detective (and Pizza Delivery) Agency

@ Faction Heir - As GH has not elaborated on his claims your response seems fitting to me for now.

GH - care to elaborate further?

**GeneralHankerchief** · 03-20-2009, 17:44

Working on it boudica, thanks.

**Seamus Fermanagh** · 03-20-2009, 19:12

Originally Posted by boudica

Seems like Pisuf (is that an insult?) is a paid up member of the United Masonic Shepherd Detective (and Pizza Delivery) Agency

Yes, that player was & is claiming a detective role of sorts. While we could be getting "played," pizza was noting that the player's response to his "give me your PM quickly" WAS very prompt. It would not have been possible for that person to have constructed it rapidly in response to pizza's request. If we're being played here, it was organized in advance.

Moreover, the one shared detective result does seem to have been born out by a subsequent PM sharing with pizza. Again, this does not preclude an elaborate setup -- Tincow schooled us all that such are possible during Capo II -- but we all know such elaborate efforts are less frequent/likely.

**FactionHeir** · 03-20-2009, 17:16

I didn't respond because they are baseless and I already gave my part of the story earlier in the thread. Unless he actually has some hard evidence that he would post, there is no point in posting more WIFOM.