Quote Originally Posted by TuffStuffMcGruff View Post
Are you saying that all church goers are decent people and that none of them are sociopaths? In fact, the simple fact that he was a church goer should damn his sanity in the eyes of some forum members, I would think.

The reality is that in a church full of 100 people that Tiller was a part of, If I was forced to guess which one of them was a sociopath, my guess would be the guy that has killed tens of thousands of children for money.
Still, these people knew his proffesion, and they still accepted him as a Christian. It is suggestive of his character.

Quote Originally Posted by Don Corleone View Post
Membership, even active participation, is no guarantee of one's true character. The BTK Killer was an Elder in his Lutheran church. Surely we're not going to argue that that justifies his actions?
Something of a strawman, as he was not hiding the fact he was an abortionist. So your comparison doesn't work.

None of this affects my origonal point, it is un-Christian to reject someone because of their actions, especially if we find those actions repulsive.