Wait, I worked it out, it is Atheotes!! Atheotes is the Mafia!!!

Look at the write-up. As I said, I am Spock, it isn't Pizza, out of that, everyone else voted.

Two votes weren't heard, two people didn't vote, AVSM and Tratorix, this leaves the last person to be Atheotos.

Atheotos is the mafia!!! Now to brig him.