Netherworld II [Concluded]

[Joooray]

Chaotix did tell me about this supposed ability of his, and asked me if I would be prepared to give up my life to save someone more useful to the town cause. Frankly, I thought he was just testing me to see my reaction, and said that I would (which was true only to the extent that I would die to save someone who I knew to have a useful ability).

Since his death now seems assured (and fully deserved), I won't jump on the bandwagon right now. Instead, I'd going to vote: johnhughthom once more, in the hope that he'll give some reason for his latest unexplained vote.

So Winston tell me, you have some kind of special role that keeps you from voting for anybody else but john? And what happens if he actually dies? Or are you just really cranky?

Anyway, the case against Chaotix seems solid, so I just hop on. Vote: Chaotix.

[Winston Hughes]

So Winston tell me, you have some kind of special role that keeps you from voting for anybody else but john? And what happens if he actually dies? Or are you just really cranky?

I am pretty cranky. Not sure if that's why I keep voting for john, or if it's because he really is acting suspiciously. Either way, I figure it's a better move than jumping on whichever bandwagon happens to roll past.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I find that Winston is posting a suspiciously large amount.

[Winston Hughes]

I find that Winston is posting a suspiciously large amount.

By the gods, you're right! Let's lynch the loose-lipped fool before he brings disaster to each and every one of us!!

[pevergreen]

Unvote: Chaotix, Vote: Winston

I find I agree with Sasaki. Whats going on .Org?

Do we, perchance, need to reintroduce the mandatory first vote of Sasaki voting Ichigo, and then the second vote of Ichigo voting Sasaki?

The (now defunct) curse of Kage?

The insults aimed at Lemur?

peverreenk?

[Askthepizzaguy]

When did that Sasaki-Ichigo thing get started? I assume one of them told a big fat lie and the other vowed perpetual revenge?

[Winston Hughes]

Unvote: Chaotix, Vote: Winston

I find I agree with Sasaki. Whats going on .Org?

'What's going on?' indeed. I didn't understand any of that post.

Winston isn't acting that odd, he doesn't lurk either, hes new to the org so he post count will be low, but its hard for you to give a proper judgment yet. And whilst he may seem 'suspicious' suspicious is the game he plays all the time from the few games he has been in.

I've been rumbled.

[pevergreen]

'What's going on?' indeed. I didn't understand any of that post.

You have to have been around a while to get most of that. the most recent is peverreenk. The lemur one is before my time and Curse of Kage was an ongoing thing.

[Chaotix]

Ugh... seriously? Now you think I'm mafia, TinCow?

Well, I'll tell you what. Whether I get lynched or not, you've just screwed the town over by revealing my role. If you thought you might be embarrassed if you were wrong about Sasaki, then you have hit the jackpot of all embarrassing decisions with this move.

And I'll show you why. I'll lay out a nice little list of possible outcomes.

-You lynch me. Congratulations, whether you believe me or not, you, Garuda, and every other pro-town role have lost their only chance at being revived once they die.

-You let me live. In this case, I assume you want me to prove my power is real. Fine. As soon as the mafia sees what I can do, they will try to kill me anyway. And if you try to protect me, then you leave yourself undefended. So we will be constantly playing a guessing game with the mafia over who to protect, and if they are allied, they will simply put a hit on both of us. And then, provided I survive, I will have to sacrifice player after player to keep bringing you back.

What is is you want, exactly? Would you like more information on my role? You have the basic gist of it already.

I cannot account for the absence of Yama, but perhaps it is because he anticipated what you might do. I am not Yama. I am Hortulanes. I am a wandering alchemist, who has learned the secret to create life- and as with all alchemy, it is an equivalent exchange. I must extinguish one life to bring back another. That is all.

[TinCow]

Ugh... seriously? Now you think I'm mafia, TinCow?

Well, I'll tell you what. Whether I get lynched or not, you've just screwed the town over by revealing my role. If you thought you might be embarrassed if you were wrong about Sasaki, then you have hit the jackpot of all embarrassing decisions with this move.

Oh, please. You revealed your role to at least 3 people who were about to be lynched. You clearly do not care about your role getting out.

-You lynch me. Congratulations, whether you believe me or not, you, Garuda, and every other pro-town role have lost their only chance at being revived once they die.

Garuda and I agree on this. We don't find you particularly useful and think you're scum. Considering we're the only people your claimed role can even theoretically help, that's not a good sign.

[johnhughthom]

So Winston tell me, you have some kind of special role that keeps you from voting for anybody else but john? And what happens if he actually dies? Or are you just really cranky?

I think he took my unexplained vote for him in the first round to heart.

[Beskar]

@CCRunner
Just what is your role? Who are you?

@atheotes
What is your role? Who are you?

[Winston Hughes]

I think he took my unexplained vote for him in the first round to heart.

It's true. I can hardly contain my rage at the sheer injustice of it. Does not a man deserve to know the nature of the crimes of which he is accused? I demand explanation!

[johnhughthom]

It's true. I can hardly contain my rage at the sheer injustice of it. Does not a man deserve to know the nature of the crimes of which he is accused? I demand explanation!

Honestly, I voted for you because I like your name. I realise that is a terrible crime and beg understanding and forgiveness (not papal forgiveness, the real thing).

[Winston Hughes]

Honestly, I voted for you because I like your name.

You like my name? Ah, well that paints things in a very different light. I like getting compliments. Doesn't happen often. I wonder why...

unvote: johnhughthom; vote: pevergreen

[Askthepizzaguy]

Because it's clearly irrelevant and no one besides me is interested in this:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I'll grant that YLC might be a town asset. So let me ask someone who might be more likely to respond, meaning anyone: WHY did he lie to me and suggest he could make me lynch immune? What was the point of that? How does it benefit the team to get me to waste an entire round on myself, thinking I was lynch immune? I could have attracted murders in my direction, too, with a false role claim.

It's a darn good thing I am not worth reviving, that's all I will say. If we win this game, fine... I just want to know why I wasn't even worth giving an explanation to when I was screwed out of my life so badly by a supposedly pro-town character.

[ULC]

Because it's clearly irrelevant and no one besides me is interested in this:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I'll grant that YLC might be a town asset. So let me ask someone who might be more likely to respond, meaning anyone: WHY did he lie to me and suggest he could make me lynch immune? What was the point of that? How does it benefit the team to get me to waste an entire round on myself, thinking I was lynch immune? I could have attracted murders in my direction, too, with a false role claim.

It's a darn good thing I am not worth reviving, that's all I will say. If we win this game, fine... I just want to know why I wasn't even worth giving an explanation to when I was screwed out of my life so badly by a supposedly pro-town character.

That is quite simple - I didn't. I even joked about it, and when I thought you had taken it seriously, I even tried to warn you that I could not make you lynch immune.

For clarification, I told ATPG early on that I was a stump, that I had no vote and could not be removed from the game (partially true ) - I told him we could be a duo, knowing that he carried a "lynch immune without actual ability" air about him, I thought we could perpetuate that farce, and he could act as my cover as I fed the town information.

It didn't pan out - sorry toots

[Askthepizzaguy]

That is quite simple - I didn't. I even joked about it, and when I thought you had taken it seriously, I even tried to warn you that I could not make you lynch immune.

For clarification, I told ATPG early on that I was a stump, that I had no vote and could not be removed from the game (partially true ) - I told him we could be a duo, knowing that he carried a "lynch immune without actual ability" air about him, I thought we could perpetuate that farce, and he could act as my cover as I fed the town information.

It didn't pan out - sorry toots

I think you "warned" me when I was about to be lynched, which I consider too late. So the joke is on me, ha ha. Just pointing out how pointless and wasteful it was.

@pevergreen-

What does that have to do with the price of tea in Australia?

[pevergreen]

What does that have to do with the price of tea in Australia?

I don't see the connection, but I laughed.

[Double A]

unvote, vote: atheotes

If a deflector shield type role is in the game, it's not so hard to believe that there's a reviver who has to sacrifice someone to bring someone else back.

And confirmed killer > unconfirmed ? role

... - Sigurd

[pevergreen]

Because it's clearly irrelevant and no one besides me is interested in this:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I'll grant that YLC might be a town asset. So let me ask someone who might be more likely to respond, meaning anyone: WHY did he lie to me and suggest he could make me lynch immune? What was the point of that? How does it benefit the team to get me to waste an entire round on myself, thinking I was lynch immune? I could have attracted murders in my direction, too, with a false role claim.

It's a darn good thing I am not worth reviving, that's all I will say. If we win this game, fine... I just want to know why I wasn't even worth giving an explanation to when I was screwed out of my life so badly by a supposedly pro-town character.

tbh you are annoyingly powerful while alive and dead.

The players who don't go out on a limb (most of the players from capo and before, plus a few more recent ones, TinCow, khaan et al) just follow whatever you say, from game to game.