StarWars: Return of the Sith [Concluded]

[TinCow]

There is another level to this that I feel the need to mention. If the amber eyes killer does indeed turn out to be Darth Talon, that means that Sigurd intentionally made both of the Sith Krayt's Hands. That would not be a coincidence. If both of Krayt's Hands are in this game, and the game does not end with Darth Talon's death, it almost certainly means that Darth Krayt himself is also in this game. In fact, I'd say that's probably likely... as it stands right now, we're looking at 2 mafioso in a 40 person game. That seems like a VERY small number to me. It would make far more sense if it was three mafioso, two killers (Darth Nihl and Darth Talon) and one 'Godfather' (Darth Krayt).

If this theory turns out to be correct, there is one very strong candidate for Darth Krayt: ATPG. Why? Because he described this exact set-up of the game after the very first write-up.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I should dig up one of his shadow fort quotes about "I kept telling you guys the dead could attack".

[Askthepizzaguy]

Rule of two, Tincow. Sorry.

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showt...=1#post2478575



That was also separate from the murders. It's straight from Sigurd himself. Nice thinking though.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

It does say "should be" :p

Being under suspicion is fun Pizza.

[TinCow]

Rule of two, Tincow. Sorry.

That's why you're not the best lynch today. My point was that you need to be removed IF the Amber Eyes killer is Darth Talon and IF the game does not end with Darth Talon's death. If either of those conditions are not true, then my theory holds no water.

[Askthepizzaguy]

It does say "should be" :p

Being under suspicion is fun Pizza.

It is, though. Besides I already confessed.

What's even more fun is thinking that I was the Sith Godfather all along, after the game I've played. God that would have been an awesome performance. Sorry I can't claim credit. But if you wish, I will curse all of your names as you drag me to the airlock, and wish bad things upon you. I've wanted to all game long.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Wait a minute... are you suggesting that Nomi Sunrider is packing?

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Darth_Krayt

Darth Krayt is a male.

Check under my skirt.... IF YOU DARE!!!! MWAHAHAHAHAHHAA......

[Subotan]

@Subotan:

Explain why you voted for autolycus, then voted for pever, on the round Niklas slipped away. Why did you make those votes? Why did you not vote the next round?

Same reason you did, at that point in time:

Oh, I agree with your candidates [Niklas/White_Eyes]. But, I think you're scummy as well, and I think I could be wrong about my candidates, and if so, those are the easy lynches and you went directly for them.

I did not want a huge runaway bandwagon to develop on some of the other candidates, ACIN style (Which, contrary to what you assumed, I was genuinely livid about, and I raged to Sigurd about it). I then switched to pever as Tincow demonstrated compelling evidence that he was behaving suspiciously. And if anyone saved Niklas, it was himself. I didn't come online the .Org for the rest of the day.

I didn't vote for Niklas the following day because I was extremely busy with schoolwork (I had already missed several "final" deadlines :sweatdrop... ). Besides, it's not like you needed my help, and there were others who voted for him as well.

When I add that with who you did vote for who is now deceased, the pattern is very clear. You're an opportunist, and those you vote for wind up dead by the lynch or the murder. Those who remain have very good reasons why they aren't dead yet. Their survival provides cover for you, or in the case of John, until recently he was able to provide cover for you, and in the case of pevergreen, he's tempting lynchbait, and in the case of me, you know that I will continue to attract votes and blocks and investigations off of you. Besides, why would you kill someone as tempting as a Sith recruitable?

Absolute rubbish. I've already demonstrated why your maths doesn't stack up. Statistically, if 3/4 of the players are killed, then 3/4 of whoever any given player votes for are going to die.

It's absurd to use that result as a defense, especially when IMO it points more towards your guilt than anything else.

This is of course ignoring the fact that a mafioso would likely have to give up one of his kills to avoid investigation, but whatever. We all know that your opinion actually means fact.

[pevergreen]

Unvote, Vote: Subotan

Wewt I managed to stay awake! I'm not going to miss class for the third day in a row!

[Askthepizzaguy]

Cheer up Subotan. I may be eating humble pie once again due to Tincow's excellent baking skills. And you might get cleared tonight by the block. Or I might. And that will put an end to all of this nonsense about ESP.

I never believed a word of that anyway. I was um.... just putting on some pressure.

[TinCow]

Tally:

Centurion1: 7 (Choxorn, Centurion1, johnhughthom, Subotan, DE, TinCow, ATPG
Subotan: 3 (atheotes, Psychonaut, pevergreen)

I recommend against making the vote any closer than this. Centurion1 is a solid lynch, no matter how you look at it. Let's keep the votes skewed like this to prevent mafioso manipulation.

Note that Centurion1 is voting for himself, and Niklas has not voted yet. With the vote tally as it stands right now, the two of them together could swing the vote to 6:5, which is too close for comfort. Another vote on Centurion1 would be nice.

[Niklas]

Your tally is incorrect.

vote: Subotan

Mwahahahaha.

[Secura]

Cheer up Subotan. I may be eating humble pie once again due to Tincow's excellent baking skills.

Baked in the oven of shame at gas mark egg-on-your-face?

[Sigurd]

voting ended...

[Askthepizzaguy]

Baked in the oven of shame at gas mark egg-on-your-face?

Hey, just doing my job. Someone's got to put real or imagined pressure on peeps. Centurion1 was also high on my suspect list, but the result on Subotan seemed like it was just neutral enough where Sigurd could go "well I did say 'most likely', I didn't say it was a slam dunk". Plus I just had a bad feeling about Subotan. Unfortunately the true lurker escapes my detection once again. That's why I think Tincow is a good analyst. In a recent game he questioned why I thought that, iirc, but it's quite clear his analytical skills should not be sold short.

I'm also not so completely blind to my own fallibility that I couldn't immediately toss away all the work I did this round accusing Subotan and putting pressure on him for a candidate I sincerely thought was better. It's better to have egg on your face and victory, than getting your way and defeat.

[Subotan]

Your tally is incorrect.

vote: Subotan

Mwahahahaha.

So scum count bunvotes as real votes, eh? Interesting.

EDIT:

And that will put an end to all of this nonsense about ESP.

[TinCow]

Ok, I'm running into coincidences all over the place now. I've been reading all kinds of Wookiepedia stuff on the Rule of Two/Rule of One/Darth Krayt, etc. lately. Apparently Darth Krayt was eventually killed by Darth Wyyrlok III, who Wookiepedia describes as "the most trusted servant of Darth Krayt." Not only that, he was marked as 'the Third' because his mother and grandfather had the same names and had also been Sith Lords. ALL of them served Darth Krayt. All three of them were Chagrian... and I and III were both Male. In addition, Darth Wyyrlok III became the Master of Darth Nihl after Darth Krayt's death, and he had yellow eyes... like our current killer.

Like I noted before, Centurion1 is a Chagrian Male. Darth Wyyrlok III also fits better into the 'force user' killer than Darth Talon does, if you read his abilities.

*shrug* We'll find out soon I guess.

[Husar]

Only two mafia really doesn't seem like a lot in a 40 player game but I guess their potential ability to recruit was meant to balance this out.
Just wanted to point that out, otherwise good case on Centurion.

[Centurion1]

How about stupid case on centurion a wall of text does not a good case make his case assumes I actually know all south star wars which I most deibwtly do not I deleted my original role pm AB Olympic have an addendum to off of second of all I never said I WA female finally LOL our just Wrong bit hey wait for a surprise

[Secura]

How about stupid case on centurion a wall of text does not a good case make his case assumes I actually know all south star wars which I most deibwtly do not I deleted my original role pm AB Olympic have an addendum to off of second of all I never said I WA female finally LOL our just Wrong bit hey wait for a surprise

Are you drunk? o_O

[Choxorn]

That seems likely. It's certainly possible both Subo and Cent could be mafia, somehow. We'll see with the update.

And for all those who want to know the last unrevealed role, I'm Mara Jade.

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Are you drunk? o_O

No. Most likely we are too drunk to understand what he just said.

[Centurion1]

Typingon my Droid lovely device but wouldn't rwcommened writing essays on it

[Sigurd]

Round 13

Night

When Qui-Gon Jinn finally arrived, the Jedi in session had just finished a long and heated discussion and a tally was presented. Qui-Gon had a quick look at it and smiled. “Very good Jedi, I am pleased.” He looked up and scanned the gathered few. “Would Mas Amedda please come forward” A huge blue headed man got up and moved carefully to the front. Qui-Gon looked the man in the eyes. “You have been found to be most likely Sith of all the remaining crew. You know what that entails, right?” Mas just nodded. Qui-Gon nodded to the waiting Knights. They escorted the big blue man out of the Auditorium.
One Master leaned in:” We finally got the Twi’Lek, didn’t we?” Qui-Gon Jinn turned and faced the Jedi Master. “Twi’Lek? Mas Amedda is not a Twi’Lek. He is a Chagrian. What gave you the idea that He was a Twi’Lek?” The Master just shrugged. “They all look alike to me.”
Mas Amedda was brought to the space barrier and he unceremoniously stepped out into space vacuum. He drifted slowly outside and the coldness of space soon brought a frozen look to him. Mas Amedda waved back at his audience and smiled. He was soon brought inside again and he walked right past the Jedi Master who had accused him, giving him a long stare.

Let’s get back to work people, shouted Qui-Gon.

Tally:

Centurion1: 6 (ATPG, Choxorn, Diamondeye, johnhugh, Subotan, TinCow)
Subotan: 5 (atheotes, Cent1, Niklas, pever, Psycho)

Not voting: 2 (Chaotix, Split)

Night ends at 23:00 GMT+1 Thursday 6th of May (23 hours from now) Night actions in by 22:00 GMT+1 (22 hours from now)

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Lynched:

a completely innocent name
TheFlax
Belisarius II
Yaseikhaan
Thermal Mercury
Greyblades
Niklas
White_eyes:D
autolycus

Killed:

Beefy187
Husar
Captain Blackadder
Khazaar
Csargo
Ibn-Khaldun
Methos
Andres
Beskar
Winston Hughes
Chaotix
Sasaki Kojiro
Joooray
Kagemusha
Secura
atheotes
GeneralHankerchief
Diana Abnoba
Yaropolk
Renata
YLC

Force Ghost:

Chaotix
atheotes
Niklas

Alive:

Askthepizzaguy
Centurion1
Choxorn
Diamondeye
johnhughthom
pevergreen
Psychonaut
splitpersonality
Subotan
TinCow

[Subotan]

He had Force Breath? And he didn't tell us? Good God, we've got our Sith!

[TinCow]

He had Force Breath? And he didn't tell us? Good God, we've got our Sith!

[White_eyes:D]

One Master leaned in:” We finally got the Twi’Lek, didn’t we?” Qui-Gon Jinn turned and faced the Jedi Master. “Twi’Lek? Mas Amedda is not a Twi’Lek. He is a Chagrian. What gave you the idea that He was a Twi’Lek?” The Master just shrugged. “They all look alike to me.”

Proof that EVEN Jedi Masters are racist

[TinCow]

Proof that EVEN Jedi Masters are racist

Hey, I fixed my error almost immediately!




Besides... they do look alike...

[Centurion1]

You ijits I found aholocton why tell you that you wouldn't believe me anyway bloody fool obviously subo is the sith why doesn't anyone investigate me for crying out loud

[johnhughthom]

You ijits I found alcohol why tell you that you wouldn't believe me anyway bloody fool obviously subo is the sith why doesn't anyone investigate me for crying out loud

Fixed.