View Full Version : Small Mafia Game Cereal killer mafia
Hi folks, this your chill postcapped game where you get to shitpost 49 times and then have 1 read? Or uh, anyway.
Playerlist
1. Montmorency
2. Totally not Taffy
3. Visor
4. Raskolnikov
5. nebjiamn r. Sleep
6. ladd
7. EnderWiggin
8. Wisdom
9. El Barto
10. Jan
11. Kagemusha r. Cape90
12. Syn
13. Suibian
Rules
1. 50 postcap, lifted 1 hour before EoD. EoD is:
12:00 for UTC+11 (AEDT)
21:00 for UTC-4 (EDT)
03:00 for UTC+2 (CEST)
2. This is a normal 10:3 closed setup with full flips. The flavor of this game is “cereal.” VTs are “vanilla cereals,” wolves are “cereal killers.” Flavor names will be assigned randomly and have no bearing on alignment or role. Flavor is purely optional and for my own amusement.
3. Day phases will last 48 hours, Night phases will last 24 hours. There will be a 24 hour pregame period. Wolves have daytalk at all times, including pregame.
4. Do not lie about real-life commitments. Similarly, do not question the validity of other players’ real-life commitments. If you will be inactive for a prolonged period of time, inform the game host so you can be replaced.
5. Mafia is a game of analysis - removing a player’s ability to analyze things is against the spirit of the game. Keep references that only a handful of players would understand to a minimum. Encoded messages, hidden text, and other such methods are a no-no. Everything you have to say or not say should be clearly readable in your post by anyone.
6. You may thank posts (but do it responsibly). Do not edit your posts. Do not quote information directly from moderator communication, your role PM, private chats, or any other sources of game communication outside the main game thread. Only living players may post in the game thread. Do not post in the game thread during the Night phase.
7. You may not privately communicate with anyone except the game moderator, unless you're explicitly allowed to do so by the game moderator. This includes using systems outside the scope of the game to communicate something game-related. Any game-related questions should be asked privately to the moderator. Do not talk about your conversations with the moderator in any game thread.
8. Do not use out-of-game information (such as Discord, other forum activity, other mafia activity, or real-life activity) to generate reads. Do not use out-of-game information to exert pressure or influence on this game. Do not mention out of game information in the context of explaining or speculating on a player’s alignment in this game.
9. Votes must be bolded and on a separate line using this format: Vote: player. Any votes not following this format will not be counted. You will be rewarded with frequent and (probably) accurate vote counts. :00 good, :01 bad. Votes made after modpost saying stop posting will not be counted.
10. Majority votes will not cause a yeet until YoLo, (you’re goddamn right) where votes will be locked. The player with the most votes at deadline will be yeeted. In the event of a tie, the yeet will be randed between the tied wagons by the game moderator.
11. Do not fake daytime activations. There may or may not be daytime abilities, but faking them will get you a Stern Warning or possibly modkilled.
12. If you believe a player is violating one of these rules by the letter, or in spirit, contact the game moderator privately. Do NOT address the potential violation in the thread, proceed on normally.
13. Moderator decisions are final.
14. Try to keep the game fun for everyone, since that's why we're all here.
Sample town role PM Vanilla cereal, in the form of:
Fruit loops
Last time, Toucan Sam was on the run from a fruit-crazed pimp named Octavio Paz, who was also a literary critic (before he was (reportedly) killed in a duel, although truthfully he simply failed to show up) when he wasn’t a pimp, and who was (and still is to this day) searching ravenously for a balanced breakfast. Toucan Sam and a Chilean poet, who later forgets to mention that Toucan Sam ever existed, cross the deserts of Sonora together with Wasalu Muhammad Jaco, American rapper and record producer, the three of them also searching, desperately, not for a balanced breakfast, but for the ultimate fruity flavor. It’s somewhere out there, says Toucan Sam, gesturing impotently at the empty landscape, but no one believes him, not even himself. They believe in the act of searching, though, and in the act of dreaming even more than the act of believing, and so their search goes in circles for a long time. Eventually, all three of them forget to mention that the toucan ever existed, and then they forget the pimp and the poet, too. Will you succeed where Wasalu Muhammad Jaco and the others failed? You can help find the ultimate fruity flavor by going to Toucansam dot com. Ask your parents’ permission.
::)::
You’ve always been afraid of death. Please don’t kill me, you whisper prayerfully to the night, but you know it ignores you. Sometimes a strange longing takes you, and for a moment you believe you’re about to meet your end. “Aquí está,” you say out loud. “Los asesinos en cereales me llevan.”
One day, as the rising sun peeks through your huddled cardboard covers, you have an epiphany, or at least a thought. “Soy le defensore de les despoetices,” you proclaim convincingly. “Y nadie puede silenciarme. ¡Adelante, mi arma es mi voz!” You emerge from your dusty fortress into the dawnlit lands and set out ayonder with tongue in hand. You may be a little bland, but you certainly have an appetite.
You win when all threats to cereal have been eaten.
Votals and flips:
Votal 1.1 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850575&viewfull=1#post2053850575)
Votal 1.2 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850608&viewfull=1#post2053850608)
Votal 1.3 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850694&viewfull=1#post2053850694)
Votal 1.4 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850765&viewfull=1#post2053850765)
Votal 1.5 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850818&viewfull=1#post2053850818)
Votal 1.6 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850832&viewfull=1#post2053850832)
Votal 1.7 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850846&viewfull=1#post2053850846) - EoD1
Day 1: El Barto was a Mafia Goon.
Night 1: Montmorency was a Vanilla Townie.
Votal 2.1 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850950&viewfull=1#post2053850950)
Votal 2.2 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850993&viewfull=1#post2053850993)
Votal 2.3 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851056&viewfull=1#post2053851056)
Votal 2.4 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851210&viewfull=1#post2053851210)
Votal 2.5 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851258&viewfull=1#post2053851258)
Votal 2.6 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851273&viewfull=1#post2053851273) - EoD2
Day 2: Wisdom was a Vanilla Townie.
Night 2: Taffy was a Vanilla Townie.
Votal 3.0 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851334&viewfull=1#post2053851334)
Votal 3.01b (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851350&viewfull=1#post2053851350)
Votal 3.3 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851394&viewfull=1#post2053851394)
Votal 3.4 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851485&viewfull=1#post2053851485)
Votal 3.5 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851532&viewfull=1#post2053851532)
Votal 3.6 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851553&viewfull=1#post2053851553)
Votal 3.7 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851587&viewfull=1#post2053851587) - EoD3
Day 3: Sleep was a Mafia Goon.
Night 3: Syn was a Town 1-shot Vigilante.
Votal 4.1 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851642&viewfull=1#post2053851642)
Votal 4.2 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851661&viewfull=1#post2053851661)
Votal 4.3 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851685&viewfull=1#post2053851685)
Votal 4.4 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851710&viewfull=1#post2053851710) - EoD4
Day 4: Cape was a Vanilla Townie.
Night 4: Visor was a Vanilla Townie.
Votal 5.1 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851727&viewfull=1#post2053851727)
Votal 5.2 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851763&viewfull=1#post2053851763)
Votal 5.3 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851824&viewfull=1#post2053851824)
Votal 5.4 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851840&viewfull=1#post2053851840) - EoD5
Day 5: Raskolnikov was a Vanilla Townie.
Night 5: Suibian was a Vanilla Townie.
Votal 6.1 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851902&viewfull=1#post2053851902)
Votal 6.2 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851916&viewfull=1#post2053851916)
Votal 6.3 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851934&viewfull=1#post2053851934)
Votal 6.4 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851943&viewfull=1#post2053851943)
Votal 6.5 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053851962&viewfull=1#post2053851962) - EoD6
Day 6: Ender was a Mafia 1-shot Vest Giver.
Game over, Town wins.
Day 1 start timer (https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/retirement?iso=20231026T12&p0=152&msg=day+1+start+in&font=cursive&csz=1)
Game is in pregame until tomorrow, no posting etc.
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 02:02
Hello friendos :hide:
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 02:03
So some things.
No idea how to read into cuth not playing this when he, all dubious scenarii aside, just reviewed a mountainous setup and advised noob Gemma to put 6 wolves in a 13er. I wonder if this is genuine or appearing to be busy to buy himself time before the next embarassement? Cuth are we having a pokemash moment or a smas all stars moment? Hard to tell with you tbh
Anyway much has been made on MU about my skill issues as it were. Jokes on you I took a binding vow at the beginning of 2023 that every time in a game I mention I am flawed, I have imperfect skills, and I have weaknesses my skills actually sharpen and I bend reality to make it so my team always wins.
I am 24-1 this year. The 1 is Anni where town lost because they didn't shoot my top suspect after I died n1 and he power wolfed. I am 15-1 as town. 9-0 as wolf. I am skilled, calm, and ferociously violent as either alignment if need be but mostly chill and here for a good time not a long time. I believe my town game is crisper than ever and my ability to both lead and follow has improved. My read are crystal-like in their clarity and I re evaluate very well these days. As scum my games and the fear I leave behind will speak for themselves.
Ok, so clearly I literally know I am awesome. So what's the deal with what I said in past games? All of that I just rambled about is true but also I recognize that I DO struggle more without meta at times and I do often use posting to help me in scum hunting through real time interactions and sneaky lines of inquiry and play. 50 postcap feels rough compared to I believe the 80 or 100 of the previous game.
Also, I think it should be pretty obvious that fake solving as a wolf and actually figuring out people are very different experiences with limited posts. And if they aren't then they are to me. I guess you can murder me if you want if you think for some weird reason wolf Raskol fakes this sentiment and then proceeds to do his best to solve before post capping. Don't really get it tbh. That post cap doesn't obstruct me from wolfing because I just need to fake solve. I worry for this post cap because I need to actually solve. I feel we may be speaking different languages. Just FYI. My solving has clearly at this point been eventful. Sorry for showing a little humility I guess I can turn up the ego if you like lmao. I know that's not what you are thinking yeah yeah, it is just the ultimate mountain out of a mole hill and would never be wolf indicative for me. My posting after won't really fit into this narrative as I will do my best Anyway yknow?
Day 1 has started!
EoD1 timer (https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/wfh?iso=20231028T12&p0=152&msg=eod1&font=serif&csz=1)
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 02:07
OK so now that some wisdom has been brought to the thread, and it's been clearly and undoubtfully established I am villagery, I shall go to sleep.
Oh my bad, nearly forgot (bear with me, it's late) Vote: Visor
:bow:
nebjiamn
10-26-2023, 02:07
I am 24-2 this year.
fixed
OK so now that some wisdom has been brought to the thread, and it's been clearly and undoubtfully established I am villagery, I shall go to sleep.
Oh my bad, nearly forgot (bear with me, it's late) Vote: Visor
:bow:
Votes must be bolded and on a separate line
Great vote otherwise.
Hello
Vote: Jan
Hi Jan Hi! It's nice to see you again.
I think the only people I have played with here are Visor and Jan. That was a really long time ago though; you guys might not remember me. I usually go by Tammy.
Will y'all consider it a scum tell and string me up if I admit that I hate cereal and secretly hope the scum team destroys this abomination that calls itself food? Because I do.
Vote: Jan
Hi Jan Hi! It's nice to see you again.
I think the only people I have played with here are Visor and Jan. That was a really long time ago though; you guys might not remember me. I usually go by Tammy.
Will y'all consider it a scum tell and string me up if I admit that I hate cereal and secretly hope the scum team destroys this abomination that calls itself food? Because I do.
Ello! That is a proper vote. Well done!
And yes I remember Tammy!
This is the first time I have left my ww retirement home (outside of the odd mash once or twice a year) in a while!
I have times when I eat cereals daily and times when I don't eat any for a long time. No judgment from me!
But that really applies to most of my food habits.
On a more important note wouldn't the scum eat/kill the cereal while the village ignores it?
Totally not Taffy
10-26-2023, 03:08
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVSuSsoXABQ
I am awake because I make bad choices.
Vote: Raskolnikov
vote: Raskolnikov
wolfing
Montmorency
10-26-2023, 06:23
1. 50 postcap, lifted 1 hour before EoD. EoD is:
Damn, I've been sold a pup!
You’ve always been afraid of death. Please don’t kill me, you whisper prayerfully to the night, but you know it ignores you. Sometimes a strange longing takes you, and for a moment you believe you’re about to meet your end. “Aquí está,” you say out loud. “Los asesinos en cereales me llevan.”
One day, as the rising sun peeks through your huddled cardboard covers, you have an epiphany, or at least a thought. “Soy le defensore de les despoetices,” you proclaim convincingly. “Y nadie puede silenciarme. ¡Adelante, mi arma es mi voz!” You emerge from your dusty fortress into the dawnlit lands and set out ayonder with tongue in hand. You may be a little bland, but you certainly have an appetite.
You win when all threats to cereal have been eaten.
Game is in pregame until tomorrow, no posting etc.
I suppose I missed my chance to ask whether all of us are quasi-Spanish speakers.
Anyway much has been made on MU about my skill issues as it were. Jokes on you I took a binding vow at the beginning of 2023 that every time in a game I mention I am flawed, I have imperfect skills, and I have weaknesses my skills actually sharpen and I bend reality to make it so my team always wins.
What happened on MU?
Anyway, either this was copypasta or Rask is partners with Cuth.
Vote: Rask
HYPE!
I suppose I don't need to play. No one does. Rask got this!
Damn, I've been sold a pup!
I suppose I missed my chance to ask whether all of us are quasi-Spanish speakers.
What happened on MU?
Anyway, either this was copypasta or Rask is partners with Cuth.
Vote: Rask
this is also wolfing
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 07:41
Vote: Monty
I want you all to know I had to google my cereal.
this is also wolfing
Vote: Monty
I want you all to know I had to google my cereal.
Either rvs on a friend or piling on as an excuse. Time will tell. But it looks telling.
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 08:15
Good morning friendos and welcome to the finally out of retirement newcomers. (been there lol)
Yes Monty, this was a special edition of an Achro post from the last game lol.
I've determined through expert skill exercice that Syn is town. :yes:
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 08:16
Vote: Visor
Get in here pal.
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 08:17
HYPE!
I suppose I don't need to play. No one does. Rask got this!
Soap Wis. NGL this got me pinged. Enjoy the tunnel ;)
Bisous bisous
Vote: Visor
Get in here pal.
Give me Mahomes
Hi Tammy, long time no see
Sup Jan, glad y'all made it to our neck of the woods
vote: raskol j'accuse
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 09:36
I thought Monty was in the Achro game tbh.
The good news is that if syn is a wolf Monty and rask are his partners :curtain:
Sup Jan, glad y'all made it to our neck of the woods
https://media3.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPTc5MGI3NjExYXViNW9ibTB2ZnI4cmN3OXA3ZDRqbmNoOGpnN2tlNG56dWtjb3lkYiZlcD12MV9pbnRlcm5hbF9naWZfY nlfaWQmY3Q9Zw/818orzZgX2CfgAFKiU/giphy.gif
https://media.tenor.com/2Eyukj5-DrYAAAAC/you-should-know-that-i-now-prefer-pacifism-to-combat-worf.gif
but on the other hand
Vote: ladd
https://media.tenor.com/2Eyukj5-DrYAAAAC/you-should-know-that-i-now-prefer-pacifism-to-combat-worf.gif
but on the other hand
Vote: ladd
https://media.giphy.com/media/55itGuoAJiZEEen9gg/giphy.gif
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 10:38
The good news is that if syn is a wolf Monty and rask are his partners :curtain:
How about Monty is a wolf, syn town, and taffy secretly loves me?
https://media.giphy.com/media/55itGuoAJiZEEen9gg/giphy.gif
https://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m6ocjglvuE1rarrc6o1_500.gif
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 10:46
I thought Monty was in the Achro game tbh.
what would that do for you?
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 10:58
what would that do for you?
It would feel a lot weirder that they didn't get the copypasta.
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 11:02
How about Monty is a wolf, syn town, and taffy secretly loves me?
Secretly? :thinking:
https://24.media.tumblr.com/2eed24c60cacda5243f8d19ec5ef2be4/tumblr_mfk9fjYojr1s01khio1_250.gif
when raskol rands wolf without me
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 11:27
Is that from Mafia I (goat game)? Final scene? (y y I'll talk about this game l8r, feel free to sus me :p )
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 11:30
It would feel a lot weirder that they didn't get the copypasta.
ok I will actually provide you with something more (outside my ironclad read on Synchan):
there is a real disconnection between the content of that Monty post and the vote on me. Like if he felt the need to justify making me a wagon (third vote iirc).
Dumb read but that's actually why I posted what I posted. Lettuce see how it unfolds during toDay.
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 11:31
Also Ender, why didn't you check instead of posting that line?
Votal 1.1
Rask (3) - Taffy (#11 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850548&viewfull=1#post2053850548)), Syn (#12 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850549&viewfull=1#post2053850549)), Monty (#13 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850550&viewfull=1#post2053850550))
Visor (1) - Rask (#6 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850543&viewfull=1#post2053850543))
Jan (1) - Suibian (#9 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850546&viewfull=1#post2053850546))
Monty (1) - Ender (#16 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850554&viewfull=1#post2053850554))
ladd (1) - Visor (#26 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850564&viewfull=1#post2053850564))
https://media.tenor.com/ZxEdoFmG3xsAAAAM/spongebob-squarepants-eating-food.gif
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 12:03
Vote: Monty
:curtain:
I hereby proclaim that both Rask and Syn are town!
Reason: Gut instinct
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 12:59
Also Ender, why didn't you check instead of posting that line?
Because I'm lazy.
Montmorency
10-26-2023, 16:43
there is a real disconnection between the content of that Monty post and the vote on me.
You wouldn't say that of everyone voting?
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 18:52
No Monty.
I was speaking about this precisaly:
Anyway, either this was copypasta or Rask is partners with Cuth.
Vote: Rask
Neither of your argument seems a logical reason to cast a vote (worded differently: none of them are actually aligment indicative).
Good morning friendos and welcome to the finally out of retirement newcomers. (been there lol)
Yes Monty, this was a special edition of an Achro post from the last game lol.
I've determined through expert skill exercice that Syn is town. :yes:
How about Monty is a wolf, syn town, and taffy secretly loves me?
what's with the naked pocketing, mang
I hereby proclaim that both Rask and Syn are town!
Reason: Gut instinct
do you have an opinion about something other than the loudest part of the game?
????????
aw it converted the emojis to question marks
hater website
Montmorency
10-26-2023, 19:26
No Monty.
I was speaking about this precisaly:
Neither of your argument seems a logical reason to cast a vote (worded differently: none of them are actually aligment indicative).
Why did you find that illogical enough to attract your attention relative to other votes?
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 19:40
what's with the naked pocketing, mang
Nothing... you are a friendo. But the read is there aorn: your tone and lack of doubt and circonvolution pings me as town!Syn. Not sure you play/care enough to make this evolve so there is that.
Raskolnikov
10-26-2023, 19:42
Why did you find that illogical enough to attract your attention relative to other votes?
Because your vote was the first to ping me and, NGL, the vote is on me so I look into it more than others obviously. (I am town pal, I am not going to be the D1)
I have times when I eat cereals daily and times when I don't eat any for a long time. No judgment from me!
But that really applies to most of my food habits.
On a more important note wouldn't the scum eat/kill the cereal while the village ignores it?
Ah you envision we're all bowls of cereal at a big table or something and the scum get rid of us by eating (killing) us? I mean I guess I could ignore it seeing that other people certainly find it delicious, but what would be the fun in that?
Hi Visor!
Totally not taffy - I like you. You wanna know why? I was literally just about to post the video that you posted in #11 because that song has been in my head since last night. Well not the whole song, only the first few lines on a non-stop loop. Inside my head right now is an annoying place to be. Anyway, I was about to look up the link for that song, glanced down and uh never mind.
I was about to be onboard with Rask's Monty read when I got here:
Why did you find that illogical enough to attract your attention relative to other votes?
because I was like uh every other vote is rvs? But never mind that cosign after this:
No Monty.
I was speaking about this precisaly:
Neither of your argument seems a logical reason to cast a vote (worded differently: none of them are actually aligment indicative).
This is reaching if serious. Monty's vote is based on copy pasta or being partners with cuth, who's not in the game, so it seems like an obvious joke/rvs vote and not an attempt at making an alignment-based vote. (Mea culpa if I'm mistaking a joke interaction between you two as serious)
Even though I think that's reaching, I don't think that Rask is scum for it. I kinda like post #48, and he told us he was town, so thanks for that. It makes everything easier.
Rasko jumping into the fray and basically leaving rvs 1 seconds in should read good but ..
I have trouble agreeing with several takes tbh.
Soap Wis. NGL this got me pinged. Enjoy the tunnel ;)
Bisous bisous
Let's start with this one. Wisdom doesn't really strike me as a player who will start the game as a wolf basically asking for heat.
Which is what the initial post does.
Maybe I am missing some inside joke between the two, but Rasko has not really joked and instead played an early aggression game.
Second take is this:
No Monty.
I was speaking about this precisaly:
Neither of your argument seems a logical reason to cast a vote (worded differently: none of them are actually aligment indicative).
In reference to this:
Anyway, either this was copypasta or Rask is partners with Cuth.
Vote: Rask
And I am scratching my head because Montys post in both worlds is not serious.
Copy/pasta is shitposting and partners with cuth is shitposting because cuth is not in the game.
If this was a toan read or something like that I could accept it, but that reason makes so little sense to me.
Tammy gets mindmeld village points for having similar thoughts about Raskos progression to me at the same time.
Btw tammy whenever I think about playing the werewolf games with you I have to think about regs owners market game on dlp where nacho and you subbed in two wolf slots and a big point of you winning the game (I think you did) was that I was all about giving you space to breathe after subbing into two slots that I was scumreading.
I don't remember anything else about that game just the lingering regret while trying to stay steadfast when giving people time to play the game these days.
Tammy gets mindmeld village points for having similar thoughts about Raskos progression to me at the same time.
Btw tammy whenever I think about playing the werewolf games with you I have to think about regs owners market game on dlp where nacho and you subbed in two wolf slots and a big point of you winning the game (I think you did) was that I was all about giving you space to breathe after subbing into two slots that I was scumreading.
I don't remember anything else about that game just the lingering regret while trying to stay steadfast when giving people time to play the game these days.
haha I was like oh that's a nice mind meld; it would be nice if Jan is town too but I posted that first nyah nyah.
Yeah we won that game. But it wasn't just because you gave me space when I was very obviously fumbling around upon replace in. (I was super intimidated by your read on my predecessor and didn't know how to overcome it iirc). Town didn't show up one day so we no-yeeted, and I think I was the target that time, so I got another day. Town also didn't hold us accountable for what we said we bought, and I think I was able to use that to push bs on someone else as well. I think anyway. I miss regfan! He told me after that game that he would yeet me on sight if he ever saw me post that I sucked as scum in a game again. rip regfan's ability to read me LOL.
But, I just pretty much consider it good manners to give people space upon replace in. Not every time mind you, but most of the time.
Totally not Taffy
10-26-2023, 21:20
Either rvs on a friend or piling on as an excuse. Time will tell. But it looks telling.
What did Ender do that Syn and Monty didn't?
How about Monty is a wolf, syn town, and taffy secretly loves me?
Secretly? :thinking:
That's right, ignore my blatant chainsaw defending Visor.
Also Ender, why didn't you check instead of posting that line?
Because he randed town.
You wouldn't say that of everyone voting?
Well I voted him right after saying I make bad choices, so I assume he agrees with the connection there :laugh4:
Totally not taffy - I like you. You wanna know why? I was literally just about to post the video that you posted in #11 because that song has been in my head since last night. Well not the whole song, only the first few lines on a non-stop loop. Inside my head right now is an annoying place to be. Anyway, I was about to look up the link for that song, glanced down and uh never mind.
Pocket successful :love:
This post is a Taffy hardclaim.
Totally not Taffy
10-26-2023, 21:23
I thought Raskolnikov's early reactions were good, but then he got overly explanatory, sad.
What did Ender do that Syn and Monty didn't?
Honestly just timing:
this is also wolfing
Vote: Monty
I want you all to know I had to google my cereal.
I can see someone just voting a friend and this being a happy accident or a wolf that sees a random shot in a direction and votes there.
Basically close to nothing. But it pinged me at the time.
haha I was like oh that's a nice mind meld; it would be nice if Jan is town too but I posted that first nyah nyah.
Yeah we won that game. But it wasn't just because you gave me space when I was very obviously fumbling around upon replace in. (I was super intimidated by your read on my predecessor and didn't know how to overcome it iirc). Town didn't show up one day so we no-yeeted, and I think I was the target that time, so I got another day. Town also didn't hold us accountable for what we said we bought, and I think I was able to use that to push bs on someone else as well. I think anyway. I miss regfan! He told me after that game that he would yeet me on sight if he ever saw me post that I sucked as scum in a game again. rip regfan's ability to read me LOL.
But, I just pretty much consider it good manners to give people space upon replace in. Not every time mind you, but most of the time.
Now that you said that all the memories are flooding back and the sadness increases.
About the no-yeet part which is simply atrocious gameplay. You don't deserve to win if you do stuff like that as a village player.
Anyway I will try to beat you to the mindmeld-post next time.
Nothing... you are a friendo. But the read is there aorn: your tone and lack of doubt and circonvolution pings me as town!Syn. Not sure you play/care enough to make this evolve so there is that.
denied
suibian and jan can be town ig
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 22:37
Honestly just timing:
I can see someone just voting a friend and this being a happy accident or a wolf that sees a random shot in a direction and votes there.
Basically close to nothing. But it pinged me at the time.
I absolutely saw the Syn post and was already thinking it and it *is* part of why I voted there.
I just prefer pressure over RVS =P
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 22:37
Because he randed town.
Me omw to pocket Taffy :creep:
suibian and jan can be town ig
wolfy ig m'lord
EnderWiggin
10-26-2023, 23:10
wolfy ig m'lord
Wolfy m'lord, milord
wolfy ig m'lord
do you promise?
Montmorency
10-26-2023, 23:36
Wolfy m'lord, milord
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZcdI1u_9o8
You asked?
Allez, venez, Milord!
Vous asseoir à ma table
Il fait si froid, dehors
Ici c'est confortable
Laissez-vous faire, Milord
Et prenez bien vos aises
Vos peines sur mon cœur
Et vos pieds sur une cuvette laiteuse
Je vous connais, Milord
Vous n'm'avez jamais vue
Je n'suis qu'une louve du fourr(é)
Qu'une ombre de la rue
Montmorency
10-26-2023, 23:44
Because your vote was the first to ping me and, NGL, the vote is on me so I look into it more than others obviously. (I am town pal, I am not going to be the D1)
Would you say you give up as scum D1?
This is reaching if serious. Monty's vote is based on copy pasta or being partners with cuth, who's not in the game, so it seems like an obvious joke/rvs vote and not an attempt at making an alignment-based vote. (Mea culpa if I'm mistaking a joke interaction between you two as serious)
No, I was making generic analysis and forgot that Cuth was a setup reviewer.
Now that you said that all the memories are flooding back and the sadness increases.
About the no-yeet part which is simply atrocious gameplay. You don't deserve to win if you do stuff like that as a village player.
Anyway I will try to beat you to the mindmeld-post next time.
I like holstering ousts, or whatever. It puts a pep in my step.
No, I was making generic analysis and forgot that Cuth was a setup reviewer.
Huh? So my original response was going to be me expressing confusion over why Cuth would even figure in your generic analysis at all, but then I realized that before I made a total fool out of myself, I should actually read that big post and maybe I would find my answer there. Which I did, but now I'm even more confused because while he mentions Cuth, his first sentence has him saying he doesn't know what to make of Cuth not playing this.
I don't know what to make of your response because two people gave you an out that it looked like a joke, but you're like nope just generic analysis which could be just a bit of sloppiness from reading a long post and forgetting the first line which hey I'm plenty sloppy myself so understandable. But your question to him about whether or not he gives up as scum kinda feels like it's an actual read which feels a bit like doubling down on a read that stemmed from a misunderstanding.
I feel like I'm missing something. Am I missing something? Am I wandering in the middle of a dance I should wallflower on?
El Barto
10-27-2023, 03:10
I beleive I should vote: Montmorency.
On another note, I like Ender. They feel carefree in a way that makes me happy.
Votal 1.2
Rask (3) - Taffy (#11 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850548&viewfull=1#post2053850548)), Syn (#12 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850549&viewfull=1#post2053850549)), Monty (#13 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850550&viewfull=1#post2053850550))
Monty (3) - Ender (#16 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850554&viewfull=1#post2053850554)), Rask (#38 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850576&viewfull=1#post2053850576)), Barto (#67 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850606&viewfull=1#post2053850606))
Jan (1) - Suibian (#9 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850546&viewfull=1#post2053850546))
ladd (1) - Visor (#26 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850564&viewfull=1#post2053850564))
https://media.tenor.com/F7FkuNKHDc4AAAAM/spongebob-cereal.gif
Sleep replaces nebjiamn.
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 03:33
On another note, I like Ender. They feel carefree in a way that makes me happy.
https://i.imgur.com/kJHlbxx.gif
Montmorency
10-27-2023, 03:47
Huh? So my original response was going to be me expressing confusion over why Cuth would even figure in your generic analysis at all, but then I realized that before I made a total fool out of myself, I should actually read that big post and maybe I would find my answer there. Which I did, but now I'm even more confused because while he mentions Cuth, his first sentence has him saying he doesn't know what to make of Cuth not playing this.
I just saw Cuth's name a lot in signups, then again in Rask's copypasta. Your process is sound, but's not that complicated after all. Call it a variant of inattentional blindness. Ender thought I was in some MU game, too.
I don't know what to make of your response because two people gave you an out that it looked like a joke, but you're like nope just generic analysis which could be just a bit of sloppiness from reading a long post and forgetting the first line which hey I'm plenty sloppy myself so understandable. But your question to him about whether or not he gives up as scum kinda feels like it's an actual read which feels a bit like doubling down on a read that stemmed from a misunderstanding.
I'm asking an innocent question.
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 03:51
I just saw Cuth's name a lot in signups, then again in Rask's copypasta. Your process is sound, but's not that complicated after all. Call it a variant of inattentional blindness. Ender thought I was in some MU game, too.
Game was here bronana
~townpoints
Suibian
~good vibes
Syn
Wisdom
~fine
EnderWiggin
Totally not Taffy
------
Raskolnikov - Montmorency - I should have more opinion but I have reasons to dislike both tbh.
El Barto - 1 post, no input, all pill-on. Weaksauce.
Mostly unsorted people with little use so far:
Visor
nebjiamn r. Sleep
ladd
Kagemusha
Vote: El Barto
So, it looks like deadline is tomorrow. I'm not sure if I can post in the morning, but regardless I'll be back 3-4 hours before deadline and will be able to be here until.
Since I don't think anyone here knows me well enough to know my annoying voting practices, and it is usually a point of confusion when I play with new people, I'll just let you know that I'm a stingy voter who typically doesn't vote hop. My vote on Jan is RVS, and I have absolutely no intention of making that a serious vote. I'll move it tomorrow, but I'm not sure where I want it right now.
I am sleepy though so a domani ciao ciao!
Sleep replaces nebjiamn.
we have benneh at home
benneh at home:
Howdy
vote: syn
insert generic and aggressive retort here
Raskolnikov - Montmorency - I should have more opinion but I have reasons to dislike both tbh.
El Barto - 1 post, no input, all pill-on. Weaksauce.
I agree with this POE and I think Jan is very cool and awesome and great
I actually do think Raskol is overcompensating though and that Monty is throwing his analytical skills at something fake in order to have the appearance of looking townie
El Barto made a cheap vote and nothing else. it's the sort of vote where if he's teamed with monty and monty goes over, el barto looks good because "why would a wolf park a vote on their teammate when they could have done it on literally anyone else"
but it could also be a nothingburger from a villager who hasn't read anything except a vote tally and likes tying wagons
I have more reasons to like everyone else tho (even if that reason is simply "didn't do that")
Vote: Jan
Hi Jan Hi! It's nice to see you again.
I think the only people I have played with here are Visor and Jan. That was a really long time ago though; you guys might not remember me. I usually go by Tammy.
Will y'all consider it a scum tell and string me up if I admit that I hate cereal and secretly hope the scum team destroys this abomination that calls itself food? Because I do.
oh hey maybe i won't regret joining this game after all
The good news is that if syn is a wolf Monty and rask are his partners :curtain:
lol
I thought Raskolnikov's early reactions were good, but then he got overly explanatory, sad.
the overly explanatory parts are the good ones from him tbqh, don't think he should be a wagon
I actually do think Raskol is overcompensating though and that Monty is throwing his analytical skills at something fake in order to have the appearance of looking townie
El Barto made a cheap vote and nothing else. it's the sort of vote where if he's teamed with monty and monty goes over, el barto looks good because "why would a wolf park a vote on their teammate when they could have done it on literally anyone else"
but it could also be a nothingburger from a villager who hasn't read anything except a vote tally and likes tying wagons
I have more reasons to like everyone else tho (even if that reason is simply "didn't do that")
vote: syn
i find it hard to believe these are real thoughts
comes across more like trying to encourage momentum on two early game wagons while pocketing jan
how is rask "overcompensating"? what is montmorency "throwing his analytical skills at" that is "fake"? are you trying to claim this is scum theater between the two of them?
vote: syn
i find it hard to believe these are real thoughts
comes across more like trying to encourage momentum on two early game wagons while pocketing jan
how is rask "overcompensating"? what is montmorency "throwing his analytical skills at" that is "fake"? are you trying to claim this is scum theater between the two of them?
the two early wagons are witawally because of me to begin with
who is sleep anyway
that's not a dismissive question btw literally who is sleep
do I know you from anywhere
vote: syn
i find it hard to believe these are real thoughts
comes across more like trying to encourage momentum on two early game wagons while pocketing jan
how is rask "overcompensating"? what is montmorency "throwing his analytical skills at" that is "fake"? are you trying to claim this is scum theater between the two of them?
anyway
to your actual questions
I feel they answer themselves honestly (wolfy use of honestly)
rask stayed up specifically to spam copypastas and then leaned extremely hard into a town read on me, and he usually ingratiates himself to me when he's wolfing before doing a sudden 180 on d2/d3
i don't have a lot of experience with monty besides getting stomped in a game on CFC years ago, but I associate his analytical approach with genuine solving, and I don't feel there is genuine solving involved here. they're smart-sounding posts for the sake of appearing smart. there isn't really much you can do on d1, tbf, but that's why you just go with vibes instead of milking a rock for all it's worth
I don't have an answer to the associations question since creating worlds on d1 is lame-o spaghetti-o (pls ignore my el barto post thanks)
do you have an opinion about something other than the loudest part of the game?
????????
My opinion is that last time I opened thread we were still in rvs ^^ I'm waiting until the game actually starts before I start reading people!
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 07:19
My opinion is that last time I opened thread we were still in rvs ^^ I'm waiting until the game actually starts before I start reading people!
If you're looking for RVS it's the 3rd left on the right back a-that way.
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 07:20
I feel like Sleep was in a game recent-ish (for me who barely plays these days) and they were revealed to be someone I know.
I can't be bothered to check tho.
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 07:20
If it helps the game was on here.
My opinion is that last time I opened thread we were still in rvs ^^ I'm waiting until the game actually starts before I start reading people!
thank you wisdom very cool
I feel like Sleep was in a game recent-ish (for me who barely plays these days) and they were revealed to be someone I know.
I can't be bothered to check tho.
thank you ender very cool
oh hey maybe i won't regret joining this game after all
How does it feel to replace into a scum slot? Sweatin cold buckets?
Couldn’t resist going back to bed.
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 07:50
Rasko jumping into the fray and basically leaving rvs 1 seconds in should read good but ..
I have trouble agreeing with several takes tbh.
Let's start with this one. Wisdom doesn't really strike me as a player who will start the game as a wolf basically asking for heat.
Which is what the initial post does.
Maybe I am missing some inside joke between the two, but Rasko has not really joked and instead played an early aggression game.
Second take is this:
In reference to this:
And I am scratching my head because Montys post in both worlds is not serious.
Copy/pasta is shitposting and partners with cuth is shitposting because cuth is not in the game.
If this was a toan read or something like that I could accept it, but that reason makes so little sense to me.
Sup guys
About Wisdom, it was a joke since I tunneled them hard last time we played and I was wrong.
About Monty, as said, the fact it was the third vote on me may have rubbed me the wrong way but heh. And for the record you are misrepresenting some facts, it took me a whole night (in my time zone) to leave rvs :p (beside, postcap etc etc)
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 07:55
denied
denied
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 07:57
On another note, I like Ender. They feel carefree in a way that makes me happy.
I agree with this read
Sup guys
About Wisdom, it was a joke since I tunneled them hard last time we played and I was wrong.
About Monty, as said, the fact it was the third vote on me may have rubbed me the wrong way but heh. And for the record you are misrepresenting some facts, it took me a whole night (in my time zone) to leave rvs :p (beside, postcap etc etc)
Apologies. I agree that some time elapsed before you left rvs, but the thread itself was very much still in its infant state.
I left monty and you in your own bubble because I have trouble placing either while you are active enough that I should have a clearer idea.
Kind of frustrating, but at least you are not visor.
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 08:02
I actually do think Raskol is overcompensating though and that Monty is throwing his analytical skills at something fake in order to have the appearance of looking townie
El Barto made a cheap vote and nothing else. it's the sort of vote where if he's teamed with monty and monty goes over, el barto looks good because "why would a wolf park a vote on their teammate when they could have done it on literally anyone else"
but it could also be a nothingburger from a villager who hasn't read anything except a vote tally and likes tying wagons
I have more reasons to like everyone else tho (even if that reason is simply "didn't do that")
you think Monty and me are ww? :inquisitive:
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 08:07
Thoughts on Visor anyone?
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 08:12
Thoughts on Visor anyone?
He exists.
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 08:12
That was a visor validation post.
insert generic and aggressive retort here
Quit stealing my moves
Thoughts on Visor anyone?
about as rand as me
rask is probably a villager
That was a visor validation post.
??
???? in
????? this
??????house
?????? we
????????????
Validate visor
?????????? ??
????????????
about as rand as me
rask is probably a villager
yeah but with other players raising their stock ~rand becomes worse by the minute.
yeah but with other players raising their stock ~rand becomes worse by the minute.
fair enuf
syn has the most objectively villagery posts ITG
sleep is gira for those who don't know. hi gira
jan/suibian i have nothing against, but feel like all the posts they have made so far any decent wolf could make in their sleep in a game this slow. Tho I have a feeling jan will prob end up being my top vilager by the end of the day but who knows
only game i played with el barto here zack said he is a villager who likes to go down to work and takes no shit from anyone iirc
so with their first post def not a off to a great start
monty slightly pinged me in their defense cause i feel instead of going AT rask for what was imo a clearly poor argument from them (sorry rask) they tried to mediate and deflect with posts like this:
You wouldn't say that of everyone voting?
Why did you find that illogical enough to attract your attention relative to other votes?
i dunno, i have never seen monty wolf but i have seen him village and I kinda feel like he is missong some of the edge here
fair enuf
syn has the most objectively villagery posts ITG
sleep is gira for those who don't know. hi gira
jan/suibian i have nothing against, but feel like all the posts they have made so far any decent wolf could make in their sleep in a game this slow. Tho I have a feeling jan will prob end up being my top vilager by the end of the day but who knows
Gut wolves
Jan
Syn
I hope you can steer me the right way if I'm wrong here friend!
Syn is more jokey than snarky which I tend to find wolfy from him
Jan is only gut, didn't vibe with how easy he called me town, but I haven't actually tried to read him properly in years (I think we've only played mashes) so I have no clue.
sleep is gira for those who don't know. hi gira
oh okay I vaguely know them. they played one of my games on the syndicate a couple years ago
Gut wolves
Syn is more jokey than snarky which I tend to find wolfy from him
mfw my two posts toward you have been snarky and not jokey
well, three now
also verifiably untrue
LAUGH TELL
Gut wolves
Jan
Syn
I hope you can steer me the right way if I'm wrong here friend!
Syn is more jokey than snarky which I tend to find wolfy from him
Jan is only gut, didn't vibe with how easy he called me town, but I haven't actually tried to read him properly in years (I think we've only played mashes) so I have no clue.
Jan is town and is very cute also
(are you watching, sleep)
Syn is more jokey than snarky which I tend to find wolfy from him
how?
I really don't see it
Jan is only gut, didn't vibe with how easy he called me town, but I haven't actually tried to read him properly in years (I think we've only played mashes) so I have no clue.
Honestly? Fair.
I have a perception of you in my head that makes me think you're less afraid and more free-flowing/careless as a villa compared to a wolf.
I can't say for certain if that is true, but my heart says yes, and my head can't be trusted this week.
Objectively you haven't done anything thus far to lock you in. But my vibes read on you is enough for a townlean.
I find myself agreeing with all of ladds words while not feeling like he added a lot new to the game. (basically only the el barto meta)
Makes me think I am good at ww or being pocketed.
Fine with either tbh.
Or we just both suck.
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 09:14
we just both suck.
3 chars
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 09:19
That was a joke, but actually I kinda agree with Ladd too about Monty (recent follow up meh)
Not sure I see what Wisdom sees in Syn's posts (jokey rather than snarky) but I might have to look again.
Any thoughts on Taffy?
That was a joke, but actually I kinda agree with Ladd too about Monty (recent follow up meh)
Not sure I see what Wisdom sees in Syn's posts (jokey rather than snarky) but I might have to look again.
Any thoughts on Taffy?
I liked the multiquoting post, but it is easy to fake as a wolf. In detail:
What did Ender do that Syn and Monty didn't?
their question to me.
thoughts:
i agree with syn re rask - he is certainly coming across differently than he normally does to me and my first instinct was to just go overcompensating wolf, but on a reskim his posts aren't all that bad and it is likely just a knee jerk reaction and i think i am fine just letting him do his thing, i'd probably err on the side of calling him a mild villager for now
i have no thoughts on monty yet, not unexpected, expect to get there over the next day phase or two
nothing from tammy has seemed AI yet (maybe feeling the desire to explain her playstyle is a touch wolfy? but i'm not going there today anyway)
nothing from ladd moving the needle
wisdom has seemed... bog standard for wisdom so far, either alignment they are going for a pretty simple strategy, expect this read to have more teeth tomorrow
had a few niggling things from jan, but also kind of just want to let play its course right now
not really leaving me with a lot of targets lol
i;m still up in the air about how i feel on syn right now - maybe a touch wolfy
nothing from el barto
nothing from kage
don't recall anything taffy said
gira just joined so shruggos
leaving me with ender, i guess?
though it feels like this is just gonna be a game where i struggle to have strong reads (like every other game)
I find myself agreeing with all of ladds words while not feeling like he added a lot new to the game. (basically only the el barto meta)
Makes me think I am good at ww or being pocketed.
Fine with either tbh.
Or we just both suck.
there isnt much to add to the game so far IYAM
i think syn/rask are v/v which seems the spiciest take i have given some people think rask is a wolf and some people think syn is one
i vaguely lean v on both ender/taffy based on toan/vibes tbh
mostly a yolo read tho
Wisdom any villa reads? read on rask?
i;m still up in the air about how i feel on syn right now - maybe a touch wolfy
why syn wolfy?
why syn wolfy?
the celestial beings spoke to me
just feel like the way he is constructing his posts feels more pointed, idk
with all these yolo v reads, who do u think are the wolves
the celestial beings spoke to me
just feel like the way he is constructing his posts feels more pointed, idk
with all these yolo v reads, who do u think are the wolves
it could be a ton of people lol there isnt really that much to off
of the active posters monty is prolly the 1 who pinged me the most as wolfy but its still not really a strong read
i see no reason why people like you/wisdom/sui/sleep cannot be wolves either. maybe even jan!
maybe even jan!
don't bother. I have accepted my fate as n1 sacrifice.
it could be a ton of people lol there isnt really that much to off
of the active posters monty is prolly the 1 who pinged me the most as wolfy but its still not really a strong read
i see no reason why people like you/wisdom/sui/sleep cannot be wolves either. maybe even jan!
ye i mean there is no reason why not
i kind of expect wolf wisdom to have felt the need to do more maybe? possibly a bad read
don't bother. I have accepted my fate as n1 sacrifice.
unironically villagery post
ye i mean there is no reason why not
i kind of expect wolf wisdom to have felt the need to do more maybe? possibly a bad read
ya i thought about that too and sure i could make that read but idk if it would have much meaning when it's def not gonna hold up to d2 and maybe not even to eod
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 10:00
Monty, where is your head at?
oh i forgot eod was at 4 am lmao
good excuse to miss it
:curtain:
Monty, where is your head at?
Hey that's my thing that I ask smh
Monty, where is your head at?
def earning your Undertitle
vote: ender
For now, italics
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 10:03
Hey that's my thing that I ask smh
Stop it pal
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 10:04
def earning your Undertitle
:curtain:
mfw my two posts toward you have been snarky and not jokey
well, three now
also verifiably untrue
LAUGH TELL
Pfft (:
Honestly? Fair.
I have a perception of you in my head that makes me think you're less afraid and more free-flowing/careless as a villa compared to a wolf.
I can't say for certain if that is true, but my heart says yes, and my head can't be trusted this week.
Objectively you haven't done anything thus far to lock you in. But my vibes read on you is enough for a townlean.
I mean sure, in a vaccuum I get it, it's just that statistically wolves are way more prone to call me town early than town are (when I'm town at least), so I'm being cautious. ^^
And, I mean, you're right, so a point to you if you're town here!
wisdom has seemed... bog standard for wisdom so far
Gdi Visor, give me something bad so I can call you a wolf for it!
i vaguely lean v on both ender/taffy based on toan/vibes tbh
mostly a yolo read tho
Wisdom any villa reads? read on rask?
I'd say Rask is the closest I have to a town read because his approach to me is exactly what I expect v!Rask's approach to be. Problem is that he is aware, so it coooould be calculated.
So, no, I don't really have a town read that I strongly believe in.
Ender kinda vibes like I remember v!him to be?
I dunno, I want more heat in general from everyone at the moment.
I'd say Rask is the closest I have to a town read because his approach to me is exactly what I expect v!Rask's approach to be. Problem is that he is aware, so it coooould be calculated.
So, no, I don't really have a town read that I strongly believe in.
Ender kinda vibes like I remember v!him to be?
I dunno, I want more heat in general from everyone at the moment.
wolfy :curtain:
ye i mean there is no reason why not
i kind of expect wolf wisdom to have felt the need to do more maybe? possibly a bad read
Sorry to burst your reasonings but this week have been hecking busy, currently playing because I'm guarding an exam at work which is kind of chill, but yeah, I'm busy as a bee atm. It's NAI
wolfy :curtain:
<3 Vote me you coward!
Vote: wisdom
en garde :duel:
Vote: wisdom
en garde :duel:
Vote: Syn
Hiya!
monty slightly pinged me in their defense cause i feel instead of going AT rask for what was imo a clearly poor argument from them (sorry rask) they tried to mediate and deflect with posts like this:
i dunno, i have never seen monty wolf but i have seen him village and I kinda feel like he is missong some of the edge here
Kinda vibing with this. I can't remember montmercy's meta but this makes both ladd look more v and monty look more w.
Votal 1.3
Rask (3) - Taffy (#11 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850548&viewfull=1#post2053850548)), Syn (#12 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850549&viewfull=1#post2053850549)), Monty (#13 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850550&viewfull=1#post2053850550))
Monty (3) - Ender (#16 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850554&viewfull=1#post2053850554)), Rask (#38 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850576&viewfull=1#post2053850576)), Barto (#67 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850606&viewfull=1#post2053850606))
Syn (2) - Sleep (#84 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850623&viewfull=1#post2053850623)), Wisdom (#148 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850687&viewfull=1#post2053850687))
Jan (1) - Suibian (#9 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850546&viewfull=1#post2053850546))
Barto (1) - Jan (#73 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850612&viewfull=1#post2053850612))
Wisdom (1) - Visor (#147 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850686&viewfull=1#post2053850686))
https://media.tenor.com/2HJiPz3baqYAAAAM/breakfast-cereal.gif
EoD1 in 13 hrs: timer (https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/wfh?iso=20231028T12&p0=152&msg=eod1&font=serif&csz=1)
Raskolnikov
10-27-2023, 13:06
Votal 1.3
Rask (3) - Taffy (#11 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850548&viewfull=1#post2053850548)), Syn (#12 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850549&viewfull=1#post2053850549)), Monty (#13 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850550&viewfull=1#post2053850550))
Monty (3) - Ender (#16 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850554&viewfull=1#post2053850554)), Rask (#38 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850576&viewfull=1#post2053850576)), Barto (#67 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850606&viewfull=1#post2053850606))
Syn (2) - Sleep (#84 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850623&viewfull=1#post2053850623)), Wisdom (#148 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850687&viewfull=1#post2053850687))
Visor (1) - Rask (#6 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850543&viewfull=1#post2053850543))
Jan (1) - Suibian (#9 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850546&viewfull=1#post2053850546))
Barto (1) - Jan (#73 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850612&viewfull=1#post2053850612))
Wisdom (1) - Visor (#147 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850686&viewfull=1#post2053850686))
https://media.tenor.com/2HJiPz3baqYAAAAM/breakfast-cereal.gif
EoD1 in 13 hrs: timer (https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/wfh?iso=20231028T12&p0=152&msg=eod1&font=serif&csz=1)
Vote on Visor no longer valid I guess?
wisdom trending down bronanas
(did i speak it into existence?)
wisdom trending down bronanas
(did i speak it into existence?)
Good thing you're voting me then!
Votal 1.3 (again but better this time)
Rask (3) - Taffy (#11 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850548&viewfull=1#post2053850548)), Syn (#12 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850549&viewfull=1#post2053850549)), Monty (#13 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850550&viewfull=1#post2053850550))
Monty (3) - Ender (#16 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850554&viewfull=1#post2053850554)), Rask (#38 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850576&viewfull=1#post2053850576)), Barto (#67 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850606&viewfull=1#post2053850606))
Syn (2) - Sleep (#84 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850623&viewfull=1#post2053850623)), Wisdom (#148 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850687&viewfull=1#post2053850687))
Jan (1) - Suibian (#9 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850546&viewfull=1#post2053850546))
Barto (1) - Jan (#73 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850612&viewfull=1#post2053850612))
Wisdom (1) - Visor (#147 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850686&viewfull=1#post2053850686))
https://media.tenor.com/2HJiPz3baqYAAAAM/breakfast-cereal.gif
EoD1 in 12 hrs: timer (https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/wfh?iso=20231028T12&p0=152&msg=eod1&font=serif&csz=1)
Totally not Taffy
10-27-2023, 14:53
no time for catchup posts, have some reads
Ladd Ender Wisdom
rest of you
Jan Syn Suib
I don't remember anything Visor has said
Totally not Taffy
10-27-2023, 16:42
no time for catchup posts, have some reads
Ladd Ender Wisdom
rest of you
Jan Syn Suib
I don't remember anything Visor has said
Ladd and Ender because they're posting the way I'm used to them posting when town, and none of the things that usually tell me they're wolf are present
Wisdom for extensive mindmelding in her reactions to Jan's posts
Jan and Syn because they seem to be compulsively pushing on every bit of misyeet bait available
Suib because she completely ignored my slot after I gave her a cheap townread for something nobody should ever townread anyone for
The Visor line
to take a dig at him for what he said about me in his readslist
to show I've read it
to let him know I think it's weaksauce
How to clear yourself in 1 post
Guide by taffy
I am gonna go out tn
Will be back around eod minus 3 hours to choose who to vote
V
Ladd
Syn
Jan
Taffy
These are the people i feel best about
Still v read rask..kinda. but last post spurt from them was a bit anemic with all those questions
How to clear yourself in 1 post
Guide by taffy
is that meta or because you think the post is that pure?
I agree that the thought process reads citizenesque, but more in you get town points for it than you are clear.
is that meta or because you think the post is that pure?
I agree that the thought process reads citizenesque, but more in you get town points for it than you are clear.
Post reads super pure to me, no meta involved
(I also vastly enjoyed the villagy pettiness of the visor line)
How does it feel to replace into a scum slot? Sweatin cold buckets?
Couldn’t resist going back to bed.
Sleep - Are you still wiping the sweat off your forehead? Did I stun you into silence?
Ladd and Ender because they're posting the way I'm used to them posting when town, and none of the things that usually tell me they're wolf are present
Wisdom for extensive mindmelding in her reactions to Jan's posts
Jan and Syn because they seem to be compulsively pushing on every bit of misyeet bait available
Suib because she completely ignored my slot after I gave her a cheap townread for something nobody should ever townread anyone for
The Visor line
to take a dig at him for what he said about me in his readslist
to show I've read it
to let him know I think it's weaksauce
Who's misyeet bait?
I didn't read pocket accepted as a town read; I read it as yay song twinsies. Although I might not have questioned it even if I thought it was that.
Jan and Syn because they seem to be compulsively pushing on every bit of misyeet bait available
tmi tbh bbq atm
also that read on me seems poorly constructed. the wagons on rask and monty began after I specifically pointed them out as being wolfy. surely if you wanted to push me for my reads, it'd be for stagnation, not opportunism, which is the argument you could make for everyone else voting them
but it doesn't really parse anyway since you throw in a certainty that both rask and monty are misyeet bait while neither of them make it onto your limited town list
will try to be here for EOD goodbye hugs and kisses
Montmorency
10-27-2023, 18:51
Game was here bronana
How am I supposed to know that?
I actually do think Raskol is overcompensating though and that Monty is throwing his analytical skills at something fake in order to have the appearance of looking townie
El Barto made a cheap vote and nothing else. it's the sort of vote where if he's teamed with monty and monty goes over, el barto looks good because "why would a wolf park a vote on their teammate when they could have done it on literally anyone else"
but it could also be a nothingburger from a villager who hasn't read anything except a vote tally and likes tying wagons
I have more reasons to like everyone else tho (even if that reason is simply "didn't do that")
Most disliked post.
i don't have a lot of experience with monty besides getting stomped in a game on CFC years ago, but I associate his analytical approach with genuine solving, and I don't feel there is genuine solving involved here. they're smart-sounding posts for the sake of appearing smart. there isn't really much you can do on d1, tbf, but that's why you just go with vibes instead of milking a rock for all it's worth
:stars:
only game i played with el barto here zack said he is a villager who likes to go down to work and takes no shit from anyone iirc
:mellow:
i dunno, i have never seen monty wolf but i have seen him village and I kinda feel like he is missong some of the edge here
People say this every game.
Montmorency
10-27-2023, 18:57
nothing from ladd moving the needle
You were the one who caught him in Rask's game a year ago, right? I expect you to keep up the good work.
Monty, where is your head at?
Stay the course.
Hey that's my thing that I ask smh
I don't have any strong reads, just bracing to humiliatingly misread Ender or Kage or something.
Kinda vibing with this. I can't remember montmercy's meta but this makes both ladd look more v and monty look more w.
pff
no time for catchup posts, have some reads
Ladd Ender Wisdom
rest of you
Jan Syn Suib
I don't remember anything Visor has said
Part of this is scary mindmeld, but there's a catch.
I am gonna go out tn
Will be back around eod minus 3 hours to choose who to vote
V
Ladd
Syn
Jan
Taffy
These are the people i feel best about
Still v read rask..kinda. but last post spurt from them was a bit anemic with all those questions
:creep:
tmi tbh bbq atm
Possible.
also that read on me seems poorly constructed. the wagons on rask and monty began after I specifically pointed them out as being wolfy. surely if you wanted to push me for my reads, it'd be for stagnation, not opportunism, which is the argument you could make for everyone else voting them
but it doesn't really parse anyway since you throw in a certainty that both rask and monty are misyeet bait while neither of them make it onto your limited town list
:uhoh2:
rask stayed up specifically to spam copypastas and then leaned extremely hard into a town read on me, and he usually ingratiates himself to me when he's wolfing before doing a sudden 180 on d2/d3
i don't have a lot of experience with monty besides getting stomped in a game on CFC years ago, but I associate his analytical approach with genuine solving, and I don't feel there is genuine solving involved here. they're smart-sounding posts for the sake of appearing smart. there isn't really much you can do on d1, tbf, but that's why you just go with vibes instead of milking a rock for all it's worth
How did rask lean extremely hard into a town read on you?
I want to ask you more about your expectations on Monty's analytical approach and how it matches up here, but I'm not sure there's more to explain with what's here. But if you have more, I'd love to hear it. I can't make up my mind on whether or not I think Monty is scum or if I'm just confused by him.
oh okay I vaguely know them. they played one of my games on the syndicate a couple years ago
Is your homesite the syndicate? I think I've specced some games with syndicate people and enjoyed their approach. I wish I could remember the names; it's been a long time.
You pointing out your wolf tells here and there is endearing. Not sure if it's alignment indicative, but I enjoy it nonetheless.
also that read on me seems poorly constructed. the wagons on rask and monty began after I specifically pointed them out as being wolfy. surely if you wanted to push me for my reads, it'd be for stagnation, not opportunism, which is the argument you could make for everyone else voting them
but it doesn't really parse anyway since you throw in a certainty that both rask and monty are misyeet bait while neither of them make it onto your limited town list
And this is a bit of a mind meld
thoughts:
i have no thoughts on monty yet, not unexpected, expect to get there over the next day phase or two
nothing from tammy has seemed AI yet (maybe feeling the desire to explain her playstyle is a touch wolfy? but i'm not going there today anyway)
leaving me with ender, i guess?
though it feels like this is just gonna be a game where i struggle to have strong reads (like every other game)
Is Monty hard to read in general?
I expected to get called out for that actually! It's more important to me that people don't end up confused today and I get some suspicion for explaining it than the alternative. (Sadly enough I think I'm probably out of my scum range. At least I think I am; I haven't drawn scum in years and I expect that to be a terribly obvious showing when I do. Hope not though!)
Why ender? Is that implying you scum read him or would be willing to vote him or is that just spitballing thoughts? (Oh you vote him later, so I guess it's an actual scum read.) I think he's town are you saying my tone read sucks?
don't bother. I have accepted my fate as n1 sacrifice.
Nope, this is not allowed. I joined this game specifically to play with you and you are not allowed to leave night one!
~~~
I like Ladd's posts, nothing groundbreakingly town in them, but I get that feel nonetheless.
Monty - when you say that you are bracing to humiliatingly misread Ender, do you usually scum read them when town or town read them as scum?
(Man I hate posting like this.)
Montmorency
10-27-2023, 19:12
Gemma
This forum allows timer tags.
Phase ends:
EOD 1
The format is demonstrated with brackets broken to avoid triggering:
[ TIMER=1:00 AM UTC,10/28/23;EOD 1 ] EOD 1 [ /TIMER ]
When this timer runs down it will display the string "EOD 1", forevermore. I added that string both wrapped by the tags and within the lead tag, because I don't remember atm which approach works, or if they have separate functions.
Montmorency
10-27-2023, 19:17
Is Monty hard to read in general?
:wacky:
Monty - when you say that you are bracing to humiliatingly misread Ender, do you usually scum read them when town or town read them as scum?
No, I was able to townlock him ride or die midgame our last play together, though it didn't save us in the end. So it would be embarrassing to MR him.
:wacky:
No, I was able to townlock him ride or die midgame our last play together, though it didn't save us in the end. So it would be embarrassing to MR him.
Is that you agreeing your hard to read?
What is your read on him so far this game?
~~~
Considering sheeping Jan.
Is that you agreeing your hard to read?
What is your read on him so far this game?
~~~
Considering sheeping Jan.
Thanks a lot. I don't really feel like I have a strong stance at this moment.
Inclined to kill a low-hanging fruit because a quarter of the game is not really playing so far.
And I don't have a confident wolfread.
This is not fun, but keeping dead slots around is also not a real option. (Plus I likely won't make EoD)
I think he's town are you saying my tone read sucks?
... no? lol
this is weirdly defensive - the read i made was not strong in any sense
... no? lol
this is weirdly defensive - the read i made was not strong in any sense
https://i1.wp.com/paigefinndoherty.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/fencesitter.jpg
vote:el barto
Gonna make a boring place holder but 99% ill be back
I dont say this often but this feels like the kind of game that could use some eod chaos
Thanks a lot. I don't really feel like I have a strong stance at this moment.
Inclined to kill a low-hanging fruit because a quarter of the game is not really playing so far.
And I don't have a confident wolfread.
This is not fun, but keeping dead slots around is also not a real option. (Plus I likely won't make EoD)
Same. I was considering voting Monty but his more recent posts have me feeling like maybe I'm confused by him rather than I scum read him. Don't know.
... no? lol
this is weirdly defensive - the read i made was not strong in any sense
heh that was meant to be a bit tongue-in-cheek. I mean I am interested in your read and whether or not I should even take my tone read seriously, but I'm not feeling defensive about it. I am feeling really hyper and punchy at the moment though! I blame all the coffee I drank on an empty stomach while grading midterms; I don't usually drink coffee and right now it feels like there's a ping pong tournament going on inside my head.
oh okay, i can see it now
tone just struck me as weird lol
vote:el barto
Gonna make a boring place holder but 99% ill be back
I dont say this often but this feels like the kind of game that could use some eod chaos
i get it, but i won't be voting there #bias
talk to me a bit about ender if u can pls
i get it, but i won't be voting there #bias
talk to me a bit about ender if u can pls
Already threw him off my v reads
It was mostly a silly read based on his v first post about cereals
Rest of his posts are w/e
Same. I was considering voting Monty but his more recent posts have me feeling like maybe I'm confused by him rather than I scum read him. Don't know.
What makes you feel that way about monty s recent posts?
Montmorency
10-27-2023, 22:25
I haven't had a D1 quite like this in a long, long time.
Wagons are
3 Rask/Monty
2 Syn/Bart
Only Kage not voting/posting.
I'll only be back for EOD hour, so don't go too crazy uWu.
I absolutely saw the Syn post and was already thinking it and it *is* part of why I voted there.
I just prefer pressure over RVS =P
So your wolf read on monty is real?
Can you explain why?
If i stop posting it means i went to sleep
Feel like the good stuff will happen last 2ish hours of today but i def wont be awake for it
I am warming up to Sui, maybe i am just falling for their good tone but their posting seems okay
I feel like i should be concerned about rask (and maybe i am) but their SoD was still good enough that i dont wanna vote them today
We are about to start watching "Life is Beautiful" (1997).
Which means I am around for another 2 hours or so.
Going to bed
vote: Montmercy
Glgl
EnderWiggin
10-27-2023, 23:29
Going to bed
And I am awake. The revolving door works once more.
id prefer either ender or wisdom to die i thikn
prob ender
What makes you feel that way about monty s recent posts?
His 166 and 167 felt a bit more natural? Looking back there's not a huge reason why and scum could definitely feel a bit more natural as they settle in from early awkwardness, but I liked I liked the scary mind meld with a catch response to taffy and your read's posts, and I liked the bit about bracing himself for humiliatingly misreading ender or kage.
So, yeah not enough to go this guy is town, but enough for me to consider that I might just be confused by his earlier approach.
that's not a dismissive question btw literally who is sleep
do I know you from anywhereno don't think so, we might have been in a game once years ago
I feel like Sleep was in a game recent-ish (for me who barely plays these days) and they were revealed to be someone I know.
I can't be bothered to check tho.Gira on MU, i assume it's been discussed but just for clarity's sake will confirm
anyway
to your actual questions
I feel they answer themselves honestly (wolfy use of honestly)
rask stayed up specifically to spam copypastas and then leaned extremely hard into a town read on me, and he usually ingratiates himself to me when he's wolfing before doing a sudden 180 on d2/d3
i don't have a lot of experience with monty besides getting stomped in a game on CFC years ago, but I associate his analytical approach with genuine solving, and I don't feel there is genuine solving involved here. they're smart-sounding posts for the sake of appearing smart. there isn't really much you can do on d1, tbf, but that's why you just go with vibes instead of milking a rock for all it's worth
I don't have an answer to the associations question since creating worlds on d1 is lame-o spaghetti-o (pls ignore my el barto post thanks)
dunno this all feels extremely reachy
in particular "stayed up specifically to spam copypastas" is a big nothing, beyond that your sole point is he is townreading you which is not terribly convincing
im not necessarily asking about worldviews but montys whole game basically has been built around criticizing rask and it feels like ur not actually trying to analyze what hes saying so much as you decided to call him scum on page 1 and then use any reason to justify it, i would expect a townie to try to reduce cognitive dissonance there but it looks like a very vague generic attack rather than anything based on his actual content
Totally not Taffy
10-27-2023, 23:59
Who's misyeet bait?
The person who didn't recognise a pasta for what it was and/or didn't look at the player list
The person who reacted poorly under pressure
The person who made one naked vote and no other posts
These people could be wolves, but this is all very obvious stuff other players are going to scumread you for, and both Jan and Syn are making much more out of it than is warranted for what is probably going to turn out NAI flubbing.
id prefer either ender or wisdom to die i thikn
prob ender
Why not me?
The player who makes posts that are good enough on tone not to immediately ping you but without sticking with you is more likely scum.
How does it feel to replace into a scum slot? Sweatin cold buckets?
Couldn’t resist going back to bed.
i'm loving it, already plotting how to troll you by openwolfing in your face again
Why not me?
The player who makes posts that are good enough on tone not to immediately ping you but without sticking with you is more likely scum.
are you trying to argue visor should be scumreading you
The person who didn't recognise a pasta for what it was and/or didn't look at the player list
The person who reacted poorly under pressure
The person who made one naked vote and no other posts
These people could be wolves, but this is all very obvious stuff other players are going to scumread you for, and both Jan and Syn are making much more out of it than is warranted for what is probably going to turn out NAI flubbing.
Why not me?
The player who makes posts that are good enough on tone not to immediately ping you but without sticking with you is more likely scum.
we've voted each other enough :P
Totally not Taffy
10-28-2023, 00:11
are you trying to argue visor should be scumreading you
It's D1 and I'm playing with a bunch of people who have never played with me before, from experience my expectation is to get pushed.
All of you cannot be experts in reading awkward lowposters. And mostly I'm trying to push Visor for a read but well...
we've voted each other enough :P
mission failed.
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:12
id prefer either ender or wisdom to die i thikn
prob ender
https://media.tenor.com/b_oe8JW7cUoAAAAd/dang-this-is-what-the-betrayal-feels-like.gif
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:13
Me: Posts I'm awake
Also me: Gets distracted with discord chatting.
Anyway, actual reading thread time.
fair enuf
syn has the most objectively villagery posts ITG
sleep is gira for those who don't know. hi gira
jan/suibian i have nothing against, but feel like all the posts they have made so far any decent wolf could make in their sleep in a game this slow. Tho I have a feeling jan will prob end up being my top vilager by the end of the day but who knowswhat are you seeing with syn that i'm not
tammy hates wolfing and everytime i've seen jan draw wolf in a mash he's phoned it in. obviously vastly different game environments but for someone who has been semi-retired for a long time he seemed eager to get into the thick of it in a way that is way more likely town
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:18
Rask is probably town btw. Not just a tone read.
I didn't say this before now because I liked people voting/talking about em and wanted to see if that gathered any further info, but I had the read from... page 2 probably.
The person who didn't recognise a pasta for what it was and/or didn't look at the player list
The person who reacted poorly under pressure
The person who made one naked vote and no other posts
These people could be wolves, but this is all very obvious stuff other players are going to scumread you for, and both Jan and Syn are making much more out of it than is warranted for what is probably going to turn out NAI flubbing.
Oh I thought you were referring to them as misyeet bait in general, as in it's par for the course for them, and I was wondering why you had expectations that they should know that. Well Syn would make sense, but it looks like it's Jan's first game here, so you putting that expectation there felt odd. But you were just referencing low-hanging fruit in terms of their posting, so that makes a bit more sense.
I've also pushed on Monty and you didn't include that in the reasoning why you scum read me, so I didn't know if you were including Monty in your misyeet bait list.
i'm loving it, already plotting how to troll you by openwolfing in your face again
cries in shouting to the rooftops that you're scum while getting told by the rest of town that I don't know what I'm talking about.
GOOD TIMES
what are you seeing with syn that i'm not
tammy hates wolfing and everytime i've seen jan draw wolf in a mash he's phoned it in. obviously vastly different game environments but for someone who has been semi-retired for a long time he seemed eager to get into the thick of it in a way that is way more likely town
Mashes are just there to phone it in while you chat with friends.
I think my last normal game was the thing earlier this year and Wiggles Breaking Bad anon game the year before.
(But if you ppl want to play some blood on the Clocktower I am always down to clown).
Anyway I am not certain how I would play this game as wolf. My play normally is dictated a lot more by my mood but I tend to get exhausted in mashes as a wolf.
cries in shouting to the rooftops that you're scum while getting told by the rest of town that I don't know what I'm talking about.
GOOD TIMES
the important lesson is that you need to learn to sound more competent, right?
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:30
What happened on MU?
Anyway, either this was copypasta or Rask is partners with Cuth.
Vote: Rask
This vote is still the worst. Justifications and also completely weirdly at odds with the tone of it. Even acknowledges it might be a copypasta.
I think I'll ignore if Monty was in the game or not because I can't be bothered to go remember which game it was to check. And also I forget things all the time so I can't *really* fault Monty if he just plain forgot that post.
You wouldn't say that of everyone voting?
This reaction to being called out about his post tho feels kinda off. Like a "Why single out meee!" kind of statement.
Why did you find that illogical enough to attract your attention relative to other votes?
These are his only posts in thread so far, he cares more about how his vote is perceived than adding to any other content.
The next post is a meme response to my meme response which was... funny enough I guess but not the point.
And then again:
Would you say you give up as scum D1?
No, I was making generic analysis and forgot that Cuth was a setup reviewer.
I like holstering ousts, or whatever. It puts a pep in my step.
Monty's actual game talk has been (into page 3 already) only about his vote.
I just saw Cuth's name a lot in signups, then again in Rask's copypasta. Your process is sound, but's not that complicated after all. Call it a variant of inattentional blindness. Ender thought I was in some MU game, too.
I'm asking an innocent question.
And again. I'm actually curious when he makes his first read/talk/whatever that isn't about the vote.
Then finally on page 6 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850706&viewfull=1#post2053850706) he comments about posts other than the vote. (Which is already over half the day done.)
A lot of it is vague statements with a statement he has no "strong reads" and a pockety statement about "mindmelding scarily with a catch" with Taffy (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850707&viewfull=1#post2053850707). (Notably the wolfreads didn't contain Rask. He makes no statement about this.)
:wacky:
No, I was able to townlock him ride or die midgame our last play together, though it didn't save us in the end. So it would be embarrassing to MR him.
I'll note that if I remember right I also townread Monty early on that game.
Not a strong argument but a dissimilarity to here.
And that's about all of Monty's posts.
Like idk about you but I'm not feeling like Monty cares about solving this game aside from making sure his vote doesn't look bad. He hasn't even tried to push on Rask. He's made more comments about how Rask reads his vote than that.
wisdom's posts on pg 4/5 do nothing for me
(But if you ppl want to play some blood on the Clocktower I am always down to clown).
i would rather die
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:33
Good luck getting as much effort about any of my other reads this phase.
My other sort of scumread rn is Jan.
Mostly cause (and this is going to sound self-centred I know), the following post:
Either rvs on a friend or piling on as an excuse. Time will tell. But it looks telling.
It feels like the lame-duck style I see often used to shade people without directly attacking them.
I also don't know Jan that well so this is a wild hipshot of a read but I feel good about it.
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:34
Oh I just got reminded by seeing Sleep's posts that their main entry felt like obligation to do more work than they needed to. Which takes 3rd place on my scumread list.
It's a good list I swear.
wisdom's posts on pg 4/5 do nothing for me
:2thumbsup:
Good luck getting as much effort about any of my other reads this phase.
My other sort of scumread rn is Jan.
Mostly cause (and this is going to sound self-centred I know), the following post:
It feels like the lame-duck style I see often used to shade people without directly attacking them.
I also don't know Jan that well so this is a wild hipshot of a read but I feel good about it.
weirdly enough i also did not like that post but msotly because it felt like just putting words out to comment on something - almost forced
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:35
Sui gets a townread for their bubbly approach to making reads. (This is not a pocket I swear.)
I promise to review this read on...
*Checks smudged writing on hand.*
Day 3, because their style of play also strikes me as one I'll probably townread.
the important lesson is that you need to learn to sound more competent, right?
Indeed I do! Will you teach me?
And Ender's post that follows this one makes me feel like my earlier thoughts about Monty were on target and not just confusion. hrm
i would rather die
that is a valid option in the game of werewolf tbh.
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:36
weirdly enough i also did not like that post but msotly because it felt like just putting words out to comment on something - almost forced
I'm adopting this reasoning because it sounds less self-centred.
Thank you for your contribution.
Like idk about you but I'm not feeling like Monty cares about solving this game aside from making sure his vote doesn't look bad. He hasn't even tried to push on Rask. He's made more comments about how Rask reads his vote than that.
truthfully i don't really care about that at all
would prefer to leave monty for another day
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:37
Ladd feels mildly opportunistic in the way his reads have moved. I'm keeping this one in my back pocket but I'm also not gonna explain it because idk. I'm not calling this one a scumread so much as--
Actually yeah nm Ladd can be 4th on my list.
What do you mean it was supposed to only be 3 names??
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:38
truthfully i don't really care about that at all
would prefer to leave monty for another day
Well unless you gimme a good reason to go somewhere else I'm not gonna.
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:40
Right I nearly forgot. But Taffy trying to bait people into scumreading them is actually towny I think.
Same. I was considering voting Monty but his more recent posts have me feeling like maybe I'm confused by him rather than I scum read him. Don't know.
that's weird because i felt the opposite way where a lot of what he was posting was pure filler and i liked him less than i did earlier because he didn't seem to be producing actual thoughts
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:41
Anyone I haven't listed has either not made a post I care about. Or I've forgotten.
Which is entirely possible given I'm on like 3 hours sleep and more coffee than I should probably admit.
It's D1 and I'm playing with a bunch of people who have never played with me before, from experience my expectation is to get pushed.
All of you cannot be experts in reading awkward lowposters. And mostly I'm trying to push Visor for a read but well...
only person here who is an awkward lowposter atp is barto? i think everyone else has a decent amount of content
probs a towny approach though, shrug
This vote is still the worst. Justifications and also completely weirdly at odds with the tone of it. Even acknowledges it might be a copypasta.
I think I'll ignore if Monty was in the game or not because I can't be bothered to go remember which game it was to check. And also I forget things all the time so I can't *really* fault Monty if he just plain forgot that post.
This reaction to being called out about his post tho feels kinda off. Like a "Why single out meee!" kind of statement.
These are his only posts in thread so far, he cares more about how his vote is perceived than adding to any other content.
The next post is a meme response to my meme response which was... funny enough I guess but not the point.
And then again:
Monty's actual game talk has been (into page 3 already) only about his vote.
And again. I'm actually curious when he makes his first read/talk/whatever that isn't about the vote.
Then finally on page 6 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850706&viewfull=1#post2053850706) he comments about posts other than the vote. (Which is already over half the day done.)
A lot of it is vague statements with a statement he has no "strong reads" and a pockety statement about "mindmelding scarily with a catch" with Taffy (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850707&viewfull=1#post2053850707). (Notably the wolfreads didn't contain Rask. He makes no statement about this.)
I'll note that if I remember right I also townread Monty early on that game.
Not a strong argument but a dissimilarity to here.
And that's about all of Monty's posts.
Like idk about you but I'm not feeling like Monty cares about solving this game aside from making sure his vote doesn't look bad. He hasn't even tried to push on Rask. He's made more comments about how Rask reads his vote than that.
really good post by ender, this gets to what i took issue with from monty but in more words than i could be bothered to use. just feels like monty is stalled in neutral
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 00:46
only person here who is an awkward lowposter atp is barto? i think everyone else has a decent amount of content
probs a towny approach though, shrug
The "awkward Lowposter" in reference was Taffy themselves I think.
Votal 1.4
Monty (4) - Ender (#16 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850554&viewfull=1#post2053850554)), Rask (#38 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850576&viewfull=1#post2053850576)), Barto (#67 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850606&viewfull=1#post2053850606)), Wisdom (#185 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850726&viewfull=1#post2053850726))
Rask (3) - Taffy (#11 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850548&viewfull=1#post2053850548)), Syn (#12 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850549&viewfull=1#post2053850549)), Monty (#13 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850550&viewfull=1#post2053850550))
Barto (2) - Jan (#73 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850612&viewfull=1#post2053850612)), ladd (#175 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850716&viewfull=1#post2053850716))
Jan (1) - Suibian (#9 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850546&viewfull=1#post2053850546))
Syn (1) - Sleep (#84 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850623&viewfull=1#post2053850623))
Wisdom (1) - Visor (#147 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php/154906-Cereal-killer-mafia?p=2053850686&viewfull=1#post2053850686))
https://media.tenor.com/qJTZ8meojtwAAAAM/bran-flakes-spongebob.gif
Day 1 has ended.
that's weird because i felt the opposite way where a lot of what he was posting was pure filler and i liked him less than i did earlier because he didn't seem to be producing actual thoughts
I agree with this too. When Ladd asked me what I liked about the posts and went back I realized that it was mostly emojis and what I liked were a couple sentences that aren't really all that alignment indicative but I had a knee-jerk maybe I'm just confused by him reaction.
dunno this all feels extremely reachy
it's d1 I'm not going to galaxy-brain anything yet
in particular "stayed up specifically to spam copypastas" is a big nothing, beyond that your sole point is he is townreading you which is not terribly convincing
i too like to ignore the second half of sentences in my responses. the key point in that is that rask tends to overcompensate (e.g., pocket) when wolfing, and trying to appear hyper-present/enthusiastic and committing to a hard read d1 meets that criteria
im not necessarily asking about worldviews but montys whole game basically has been built around criticizing rask and it feels like ur not actually trying to analyze what hes saying so much as you decided to call him scum on page 1 and then use any reason to justify it, i would expect a townie to try to reduce cognitive dissonance there but it looks like a very vague generic attack rather than anything based on his actual content
it's been a fairly stagnant reason. I don't believe I have come up with anything else to scum-read him for since then
anyway all my homies love cognitive dissonance
I do not like my wagon partners
Oh I just got reminded by seeing Sleep's posts that their main entry felt like obligation to do more work than they needed to. Which takes 3rd place on my scumread list.
It's a good list I swear.
that's because i did! i got the notice i was replacing in, then procrastinated for a few hours, and by that time it was 1 AM but i didn't feel like leaving the thread with nothing before i went to sleep (no pun intended). call it self-conscious if you like, i knew if i just made an intro post and dipped i was probably going to catch shit for it and then i wind up getting into arguments with people and it completely kills my ability to actually get reads.
meh
unvote: syn
vote: wisdom
Ladd feels mildly opportunistic in the way his reads have moved. I'm keeping this one in my back pocket but I'm also not gonna explain it because idk. I'm not calling this one a scumread so much as--
Actually yeah nm Ladd can be 4th on my list.
What do you mean it was supposed to only be 3 names??
ladd basically feels like himself i don't think anything he's posted is super alignment indicative so far
Oh so is Taffy's view that they're an awkward low poster and is used to getting pushed by poeple that don't know them therefore it's suspicious that they're not getting pushed by people that don't know them? Is that what they meant?
Sleep - why wisdom?
Totally not Taffy
10-28-2023, 01:03
Well unless you gimme a good reason to go somewhere else I'm not gonna.
He posted a most excellent song, with gripping lyrics and moving delivery.
Totally not Taffy
10-28-2023, 01:04
Oh so is Taffy's view that they're an awkward low poster and is used to getting pushed by poeple that don't know them therefore it's suspicious that they're not getting pushed by people that don't know them? Is that what they meant?
This.
Montmorency
10-28-2023, 01:06
Phew! Now let me enjoy my food.
https://i.imgur.com/WWvnlHn.gif
Going to bed
vote: Montmercy
Glgl
Now that's a name I haven't seen in exactly 10 years, since the very first interfora Mafia Champs.
id prefer either ender or wisdom to die i thikn
prob ender
What's different about him?
This vote is still the worst.
I don't hold your wall against you.
Oh so is Taffy's view that they're an awkward low poster and is used to getting pushed by poeple that don't know them therefore it's suspicious that they're not getting pushed by people that don't know them? Is that what they meant?
Sleep - why wisdom?
no i think taffy was criticizing people for voting awkward low posters
chewed it over in my head and was the vote i felt best with - i don't know how to explain it in meta terms but when wisdom is town i expect them to make it obvious in terms of their energy and here they feel like they're not showing that, comes across as posting just to post
This.
oh guess i was wrong
Montmorency
10-28-2023, 01:14
unvote: Rask
vote: Taffy
One thing I'm relatively sure of for now is that Taffy-Syn antipaired.
He posted a most excellent song, with gripping lyrics and moving delivery.
I think only Rask really got it.
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 01:16
I don't hold your wall against you.
It's a nice wall to hold tho.
Kind of like the subtle paranoia of Taffy expecting to be pushed but not being pushed. Makes the thinking I accepted a town read I shouldn't and ignored make more sense.
Sleep - I was kinda expecting your vote to end up on Monty based on your posting so your wisdom vote was a surprise. I didn't remember anything they posted, so I read through their iso to see if I should sheep you and they seem fine? How strong is your meta read there?
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 01:19
that's because i did! i got the notice i was replacing in, then procrastinated for a few hours, and by that time it was 1 AM but i didn't feel like leaving the thread with nothing before i went to sleep (no pun intended). call it self-conscious if you like, i knew if i just made an intro post and dipped i was probably going to catch shit for it and then i wind up getting into arguments with people and it completely kills my ability to actually get reads.
https://media.tenor.com/zd1jUmlynEIAAAAC/alright-carry-on.gif
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 01:20
Kind of like the subtle paranoia of Taffy expecting to be pushed but not being pushed. Makes the thinking I accepted a town read I shouldn't and ignored make more sense.
Sleep - I was kinda expecting your vote to end up on Monty based on your posting so your wisdom vote was a surprise. I didn't remember anything they posted, so I read through their iso to see if I should sheep you and they seem fine? How strong is your meta read there?
Will say I did notice the "I like ur wall" and then voting somewhere else.
EnderWiggin
10-28-2023, 01:22
One thing I'm relatively sure of for now is that Taffy-Syn antipaired.
I think only Rask really got it.
Heya Monty.
Can I have some brief top town/top wolf reads from ya?
Just like... idk
First 3 names for either like Taffy did to pocket you.
Kind of like the subtle paranoia of Taffy expecting to be pushed but not being pushed. Makes the thinking I accepted a town read I shouldn't and ignored make more sense.
Sleep - I was kinda expecting your vote to end up on Monty based on your posting so your wisdom vote was a surprise. I didn't remember anything they posted, so I read through their iso to see if I should sheep you and they seem fine? How strong is your meta read there?
not super strong based on what's been posted but i don't have any super strong reads as of right now
got prompted by visor giving me the thumbs up in #208, then saw syn poasting and decided i might be reading too much into his his posts so moved there. hadn't seen the VC at the time or i might've voted monty
One thing I'm relatively sure of for now is that Taffy-Syn antipaired.
what
not super strong based on what's been posted but i don't have any super strong reads as of right now
got prompted by visor giving me the thumbs up in #208, then saw syn poasting and decided i might be reading too much into his his posts so moved there. hadn't seen the VC at the time or i might've voted monty
https://i.imgur.com/W6E7zpQ.jpg
Montmorency
10-28-2023, 01:26
Heya Monty.
Can I have some brief top town/top wolf reads from ya?
Just like... idk
First 3 names for either like Taffy did to pocket you.
Why do you think Taffy pocketed me?
I'll post my world near EOD. I'm OK with anyone who's been a protowagon or wagon, except Barto since his time isn't ripe.
Heya Monty.
Can I have some brief top town/top wolf reads from ya?
Just like... idk
First 3 names for either like Taffy did to pocket you.
wolfnana
ender or wisdom pls
dont kill monty or rask
Visor why are you scum reading wisdom?
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.