Right . I plan on posting this during the night phase, in case that I am dead when it dawns. I am sorry for not speaking up right away, but I thought I could just as well get the most out of my unlucky situation, as possible. When one is being attacked and does not die, then there is only one real way to go, and that is that this person is to die, whether by lynch or night kill. So well, here is my thoughts during the last round.


Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I am attacked according to the write up, and I survive. I have no idea as to why I survive, since I really don't have a special role in any way. That I survive is as far as I see it, either because of a doctor, or because that the person who attacked me is not able to kill all (or has a potential fail). Now as I said, it is only standard to have the person who survives, eliminated, so I thought the best would be to just sit quiet for a single phase, since it really boosted activity for a day 1 .. and well that is always useful imo. So that is plain and simple the first and most important reason to why I didn't think it would be beneficial to just reveal all right away. The second thing is that I somehow hope that the mafia would attack me, given the secrecy (only told Renata, because I can't keep my mouth shut). If the mafia would kill me, then that reduces the chance that they will hit an important role (yes that is just the kind of player that I am). The only downside to this, as far as I see, is that people may have given this whole thing a lot of unecessary thought, and if that is so , then I am sorry ofc :). But I don't agree with people (DIY comes to mind) that says this is just hurting town.
anyway, that is about all of it. I think this is/was the best time to come clear, since there is hardly much advantage in keeping this up during the next coming day phase


Quote Originally Posted by TinCow View Post
You shouldn't wait, you should make him tell you right now. If he's a pro-town role, the mafia already know it. He gains nothing by hiding if he's pro-town. The only benefit he gets out of stalling is buying more time as scum. Plus, there's the fact that he survived a night kill. How many pro-town roles do you know that are night-kill immune? Not exactly a balanced power for a pro-town role to have. Finally, there's the fact that the write-up specifically shows GE up and about and 'active' last night.

Make him confess now.

And then lynch him no matter what he says.

[edit]Oh, one more thing. He's very happy to ID Ironside as potential scum simply because Ironside is more active via PMs than in the thread. That's an incredibly scummy move, essentially just tossing a possible pro-town role ID out into the public thread for no reason whatsoever. What was the point in saying that? It doesn't even look like GE tried to verify whether Ironside was pro-town or not, GE just concluded that Ironside had a role and that was a good enough reason for GE to want to publicly ID Ironside and get him lynched. GE is the scummist scum that ever scummed.
I guess I will just reply to you, since you seem the most eager to have me eliminated :p.. I will see if I can go over the different points you are making. first part about that I gained nothing: that should be explained above. Through the explanation, you may also see that it is a not a thing that should end up buying the scum more time (on the contrary if they have actually gone after me this night phase.). As for the Ironside part.. well there I think you are adding a bit more into my posts, than what I am actually saying. If I direct your first to the spoiler, and then let you return here, then you can see that I wished to see what was possible to get out of the unfortunate thing. I am saying that I find it odd when people are very active to go fish for information in private, but does not even show up during the day phase to even talk or vote. The point of mentioning this to others, since I find it strange, should be rather clear. You are saying that I didn't try to verify if Ironside have a pro town role. In that you are completely correct, so where you conclude from that I just wish ironside hung, and that I suddenly am sure that he has a role? well I don't know where that is comming from, and I asume it is just a mistake on your behalf. I am going public with strange behavior (from the way I see it) and I have not exactly done anything else concerning Ironside :)