Pokemon Nuzlocke FireRed Mafia [Concluded]

[El Barto]

Right now Logic. If Jabbz' fixation on Logic is odd, Logic's secret antidote shortlist is more so.

Either way, I don't know what it would mean vis-a-vis Manasi and Champ.

Very well. (see below)

Few things, then:

Gyrados killing Zack was clearly a Mafia kill. I would say this was the first proper nightkill without basis in an earth or ground attack/Pokemon, but that's actually wrong as I'll mention below. Csargo flipped as Heracross, a Fighting Bug pokemon. It can have Rock/Ground moves in its repertoire, including Rock Blast/Slide and Earthquake. Plenty of Normal attacks, e.g. Strength.

Let's take a closer look at the (fatal) night attacks:

N1 - Unseen attacker kills Cuth/Oddish with Earthquake (?)
N2 - Very brief and generic writeup, unseen attacker kills Sooh/Diglett with "Strength", throwing a rock but not actually being a rock/ground attack; Strength is a very generic Normal attack that Onyx, Gyarados, or Heracross could all deploy
N3 - First attacking Pokemon identified, Onyx kills BSmith ( (critical hit but move unknown, could be rock throw per repetition within writeup)
N4 - Zack blocks Csargo, no kill, S.S. ticket spam
N5 - Gyarados identified, kills Zack/Paras with Earthquake (like D1?)

So N1-2 could have been anyone, including Csargo, including Gyarados. I think we should see the other two Mafia flip as Gyarados and Onyx. Caveat to mention is that Onyx was associated with Brock with the writeup, and if our enemy Pokemon are part of Team Gary, then we could be talking Gyarados and Charizard.

I think Barto scum reflects well on Jabbz and Logic, poorly on Manasi and Champ. Barto town reflects better on Manasi, worse on Logic.

Are you, with your self-vote?

I have said that I am willing to be lynched in order to clear the air.

What do you think of El Barto:

Flip scum, +town Jabbz Logic, -town Manasi Champ
Flip town, +town Manasi, -town Logic

I haven't done enough reading into El Barto to really answer that right now, but on first glance that looks about right.

So, since I am town, we agree to vote:Logic?

But meanwhile, Monty… if I were to be revealed as scum, that would be good for Jabbz and Logic. If I were to be revealed as town, that would be bad for Logic. What of Jabbz? Inversely, what of Champ?