Wow, I've been writing a 5 pages long paper in which I quote various historians, sociologists, and even wiccans who reject the whole 'Wicca has been here forever' theory. I've even included a part about the Mithraic Mysteries (I hardly remember why now).

It was exhausting, but interesting. If she doesn't change her mind with that (and she won't), then I don't know what to do.
I'm now tempted to buy a book on this topic just to make sure I'm even more right than I think I am.

As for dumping her, I don't think dumping your relationship whenever you disagree on a certain topic is the best idea ever, 'cause I'm never going to find someone with whom I'll agree all the time.

Quote Originally Posted by AdrianII
I'm not going to tell you to dump her or not, that is entirely your business. But I would say that she is compensating for something. Find out what that is and try to address it. That's my two cents, in all modesty, because who are we to judge your personal issues.