The Brothel - Large Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Andres]

GeneralHankerchief is on a holiday, I believe (he said so in the Throne Room).

I'm really confused about Caius' 'role claim' and after the exchange between makaikhaan and CR, I really don't know who to believe.

First suspect: gut says: Craterus might be mafia.

Reasons:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Adds up with what I said too.

Vote for Sigurd people.

Awfully fast to blindly follow a somehow dubious detective reveal (makaikhaan who claimed to be the 'real' detective, after GH revealed and announced a one week absense.)

It's interesting that you've revealed after GH has gone. I guess you were waiting for the morning but... who knows. I believe you for now.

In one post, Craterus casts doubts about makaikhaan, but still 'believes' him.

Sigurd, how do you explain khaan's guilty result then?

And why did Elite Ferret vote you if he was your client and presumably knew you to be innocent?

This doesn't add up.

Sticks to the vote for Sigurd.

Too cautious? A detective's a detective. Apparently.

Seeing as Sigurd is probably innocent, I'll unvote: Sigurd, vote:makaikhaan.

I'm not entirely convinced by the reveal, it still doesn't add up and you're probably a mafia target by now anyway (assuming you're not the mafia we're looking for).

Strike 3

"a detective is a detective. apparently." --> I don't see a reason for the sudden chance of hart. Is it because mafia buddy makaikhaan's stunt seems to be failing?

And why is Sigurd "probably innocent"? If you believe 'khaan's reveal, then why not stay consequent and vote Sigurd, who turned up guilty after investigation according to 'khaan?

My second suspect is makaikhaan. CR, who is most probably innocent, counterclaimed makaikhaan's claim.

I've gone over 'khaan's posts and here's my analysis:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

ATTENTION!!!

I am the real detective! I gave my previous results, as well as my role PM to General Hankerchief after I found him to be innocent on night one. I have once again investigated Sigurd Fafnesbane, and I have achieved a guilty result on him. And we can see that clearly, Sigurd did not want Cronos to be lynched, which tells us that Cronos must be guilty as well.

Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane

Tally:

Sigurd Fafnesbane- 2(Khaan, Craterus)

This reveal is very, very suspicious.

1) GH revealed his results because he goes on vacation (he annoucend this in the Throne Room as well, so this is not just a lie.)
2) After GH has left (and no longer able to counterclaim), makaikhaan reveals himself as the "real" detective.

Something doesn't seem right to me. Why the reveal of partial results by GH? Why not just keeping a low profile? Why was makaikhaan so sure that he was about to get killed at night that he and GH felt the need for this charade?

But what bothers me the most is the perfect timing in case this would be a mafia stunt. He reveals right after GH left. How convenient.

Now I know you're fibbing, Caius. That PM is so blatantly a rip off of the PM that GH posted earlier. I am not puritan. I don't know what you're up to. However, if Sigurd's group killed someone, than that would indeed explain my investigation result. I'm assuming that it was Rythmic you killed. However, it would seem that Rythmic had been innocent. As a result of the fact that Sigurd had helped murder an innocent client/prostitute, he showed up as guilty, because he did something 'anti prostitute' so to speak. Therefore, I will unvote: Sigurd and Vote: Caius. I don't know what you're trying to accomplish by trying to steal my role claim.

EDIT: One more thing, there's way too many errors in that 'PM' you claimed to have been Omanes'. And we all know you don't have the best english.

Maybe Caius did that to show how easy it is to do what you did? But Caius should explain himself indeed. However, all of this does not explain you unvoting Sigurd who you, as a supposed detective, found out to be guilty, after an investigation? Strange

Okay, a little reviewing of the thread...

Vote: Elite Ferret

He's been lurking ever since he got back, and for whatever reason, there was one less kill on night one.

Now, this is really getting weird? Why not insisting on lynching Sigurd, who you discovered to be guilty? Are you desperately seeking for new suspects? That's a really strange vote, dear makaikhaan

'khaan's whole reveal stinks + CR, confirmed innocent, says 'khaan lies <-> Craterus sounds more scummy to me.

For now, I Vote : makaikhaan.

Might change to Craterus though.