Well, what the cult says doesn't make sense either.

Let's take the case of Andres. He was a town aligned roleblocker and then got recruited to cult A - killed - revived as town - recruted during the revival or after? - to cult B? - so which cult wasn't able to recruit him? How many cults are there? What if there is no cult at all and MRD is making all this up in his sick head? I'm willing to put this to a test and lynch MRD.

@ Beskar: classical claimed to have been recruited? Do we have evidence on this? If so, where does it come from? MRD?