Quote Originally Posted by Beskar View Post
As for my explanations, they make perfect sense, how don't they make sense to you?

The cult claimed privately they recruited Classical_Hero, and I am sure if Classical_Hero wants to get mafia killed, he will reveal this himself.
So you're just being obviously lied to.

For one, it's impossible for Andres to be mafia. He died blocking an attack from the mafia after all.

What is clearly possible is he was some rival neutral/second-cult/anti-cult group. You're being lied to by the cult.

It makes no sense from a game balance perspective that a cult with massive recruiting capabilities can just catch all the mafia.

What makes far more sense, if the cult is neutral and their goal was to defeat some other neutrals, is that mafia could just be converted by the cult themselves and look like regular recruits. Doesn't change the cult/neutral conflicts and doesn't change the mafia/town status.

Or if the cult is anti-town, then it makes sense that they can't recruit the mafia, but then we LOSE to the cult if we don't do something, so worth a lynch today if that's the case.

Lynch MRD.