Solve this problem

[boudica]

Yup, you guys got it. Posted it because my instinct was to make a snap judgement of "A and 4", which seems perfectly correct until you take a second look. Peoples instinctive method of testing the rule is to look for examples that would fit the pattern when actually they should be looking for examples that disprove the rule. Seems to relate to mafia on some level.

Interesting point. So while looking for 'scummy' behaviour perhaps what we should really be doing (as townies) is beginning the game by assuming that EVERYone else is mafia and seeking out evidence that disproves that assumption.

Sorry if that's stating the obvious... I'm still new to mafia

I didn't get the question right until the second example btw. I thought I was being clever by only turning over 'E'.