Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[Louis VI the Fat]

So did anybody find that stash of gold?

Has the Pirate Map treasure ever been found?

[White_eyes:D]

Fine....but no more of this "Your out to get the Four Horsemen stuff":whip:

I get upset with that...I went AVSM because I thought he was a Brit...if you guys had told me he was a Vig...I would have backed off:stare:

Unvote: Vote:Jooray because both officers think your scum and your the last on the list...:bow:

[Beskar]

I done some talking.

FoS: Blackadder and Taka for not handing in protection orders.

[Crazed Rabbit]

Reenk might also be a good choice.

He was investigated and found to be investigating people. He then claimed to be a third watchstander, even though he says he only investigated a couple people.

CR

[Beskar]

He also worked with Mavengreen.

[White_eyes:D]

I am sure you can handle Reenk:yes:

[Crazed Rabbit]

Yes, pever wanted me to promote Reenk to an officer's position. Which would be quite odd if Reenk really was a watchstander.

CR

[A1_Unit]

vote:Jooray

Uhmm... I think we need to make some protection groups on Crazed Rabbit after ATPG's threats (or does that even work against the undead?).~:confused:

[Crazed Rabbit]

I'm not worried about ATPG. He's just sore because he couldn't talk his way out of this.

CR

[Chaotix]

IT WAS A TRAP.

I CAN'T BELIEVE IT WAS A TRAP.

:wall:

......................

:laugh4:

Wow. It honestly didn't cross my mind. A real Trojan horse, there, just like the write-up... but who is the Blunderbuss guy that's guarding the treasure?

In any case, I suppose it worked out to CR's favor because I didn't protect ATPG as the Captain asked (and actually, I didn't get the PM before the last time I was at my computer and couldn't have changed it anyway).

Good luck, guys- There should be only one Maven and one British left, as well as that Blunderbuss guy, if the write-ups are to be trusted.

[White_eyes:D]

Protect groups are short in supply now....we have hardly any people who will turn down that offer of gold....better take note of those who are reliable...*raises hand*:beam:

[A1_Unit]

I bet that rapier guy is the British special officer.:yes: I mean, who else knows how to use a sword like that except a gentleman/officer educated in the style.

[Death is yonder]

Mad that you fell for it...??:bounce:

We all were in parasite, join the club~:mecry:

The only reason that kept me from accepting that offer, bad memories of how I duped the people in Parasite and how ironic it would be now :no:


Wait, I was the only one who turned it down?

I feel dirty inside.

Join the club :juggle2::juggle2:

At least you weren't almost killed when you turned up for protection solo :wall:


Parasite worked the same way, it was sent by the host...and when you look at it....some of it doesn't match what GH would say...:laugh4:

I mean what are the odds everyone would find a "Chest full of gold" unaccounted for, on a ship out at sea?:clown:

Well actually it was "a mysterious voice in your mind", I have no idea why people actually thought they changed.

FoS: Captain Blackadder and Taka for leaving me out hanging to dry

Vote: Joooray

So what were you doing last night matey, trying to gnaw on some gold? :whip:

[Beskar]

I love how no one even read my warnings in the thread and didn't even think twice.

[A Very Super Market]

I've said from the beginning of this game Joooray is guilty! :soapbox:

But no, nobody listened. Sasaki was too wussy to vig him. The Four Horsemen need to be spoonfed names of scum lest they kill town. The crew ignores me. The captain drinks me rum and does me wench.

:cries:

Foo', we made our own choices. Go back to your cheeses.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Foo', we made our own choices. Go back to your cheeses.Nibbling on one right now. Paid for by the ten gold one of you with wobbly knees paid me. :tongue2:

[Yaropolk]

Vote Reenk Roink. He's a confirmed power role not collaborating with town effort.

[Askthepizzaguy]

vote:Jooray

Uhmm... I think we need to make some protection groups on Crazed Rabbit after ATPG's threats (or does that even work against the undead?).~:confused:

NOTHING WORKS AGAINST THE UNDEAD, MORTAL!!!! :evil:

[A1_Unit]

Yeah, I thought so.:surprised:

[TinCow]

FoS: taka, Captain Blackadder, and Double A

Taking gold has become the fashion of the day. Too easy to claim that as an excuse, I don't buy it.

[Centurion1]

atpg is soooo not the undead killer. Hes just bitter about dying, our capn's safe lads

[pevergreen]

I told you I was townie.

[Reenk Roink]

Vote: Yaropolk :whip:

:book:


Anyway, anyone who thinks it is odd that the captain would go ahead and be willing to kill someone who has claimed a watchstander despite no proof to the contrary except that I was "investigated as investigating"... Wow. :rolleyes: :laugh4:

pever is a townie - he has shown me his role PM which has a Pirate quote that is identical to that of another townie (Atpg). He can pretend to be a Maven all he wants, but unless he was converted, he was nothing more than able seamen messing around.

[Chaotix]

I love how no one even read my warnings in the thread and didn't even think twice.

I actually didn't see your post in the thread, yeah (entirely possible it wasn't there yet when I checked yesterday). Had I popped back in before the end of the round it would have set off a blaring siren in my mind and I would've changed the orders. :laugh4:

So I guess what I'm saying is that I blame you for dying, because your warning was not loud or obnoxious! :clown:

[pevergreen]

Vote: Yaropolk :whip:

:book:

I am so very, very close to getting rid of peverreenk.

To say I'm unhappy with you would be an understatement.:no:

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Vote: Yaropolk :whip:

:book:


Vote: Reenk Roink the writeup basically said that pever was pro maven. :inquisitive:

[pevergreen]

How does it saying I am definately a loyal seaman say I am maven?

I was able to be recruited by them, but nothing else.

edit:


pever is a bit of an interesting case. He was definitely a loyal crewman for us, but had sympathies for the Maven. I wouldn't trust anything he said to you before he died.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

then why didn't other wirteups about able seamen say as much? this is the only time a writeup has stated anything like that. I do not think you were JUST a able seamen. :shrug: I could be wrong, but what the heck its possible.

Call it a gut feeling.

[Crazed Rabbit]

:whip:

:book:

No proof to the contrary?

You only say you've investigated 2 people over the entire game. A terribly low amount of investigations, just like when you falsely claimed investigator in my own mafia game.

CR

[pevergreen]

Basically, while I was alive I attempted to join the maven. They wouldn't take me though. I tried to help them but they wouldn't have me. Then once I was dead...well. I'm dead. :shrug:I win if the town wins.

[Reenk Roink]

No proof to the contrary?

You only say you've investigated 2 people over the entire game. A terribly low amount of investigations, just like when you falsely claimed investigator in my own mafia game.

CR

Another lie like you said you were going to be quiet about me. :rolleyes: I told you of 3 investigations as well as 2 night actions which I said I wouldn't tell and I'm not going to tell, lynch me with your pro town group or not. I did protect split the first two nights like I said I did.

So again, any reason why you want to kill me before you have confirmation of my role? :inquisitive: It's either utter incompetence or something more sinister to lynch someone caught investigating. :laugh4:

As for the town, here is the proof of my role:


Your role is:

Watchstander

I often think that the night is more alive and more richly colored than the day.
~ Vincent Van Gogh

Someone has to keep the ship going while the Captain and his crew get some sleep (or at least pretend to). That someone would be you. Your job entails basic duties such as making sure the ship is straight, nothing’s falling apart, and watching for potential attacks. However, as the Presence is a streamlined vessel (you heard a rumor that it was originally the personal ship of an adventurous Frenchman) and pretty much runs itself, you have a lot of down time. This means looking carefully at what’s going on.

Your goal: Ensure a Presence victory by eliminating all her threats. As you are a mid-level officer, you are ensured that you will be well-compensated for your work, and thus the accumulation of treasure is not a motivation to you.

Powers: Unlike most of the Able Seamen aboard, you are somewhat limited in the scope of night actions that are available to you. However, you perform your stated duties particularly well.

- Every night, you may investigate two persons on board the ship. This basic investigation will tell you what they were doing that night. Follow-up investigations will reveal more about them, including susceptibility and eventually their true affiliation.
- You are not the only Watchstander on board. Should you find others, you may work together to investigate targets, which will bring about more thorough results in a faster period of time.
- You may not Abandon Ship at any time. Doing so would be a dereliction of duty. Even pirates have that much honor, mate.

Finally, if you are appointed First Mate or Quartermaster, those powers replace your current powers. You will gain your original powers back upon being sacked. Good luck!

Base gold: 115

(unlike in CR's game, this is an actual PM, much hard to forge - and other watchstanders should step up and confirm it)

[White_eyes:D]

Too risky to keep Reenk alive....too many times has he show a Role PM before he was lynched...I would quote a saying like "The boy who cried wolf" but I think you get the idea:yes:

[Crazed Rabbit]

That's similar to the watchstander PMs I've seen. But it was those same watchstanders who said a maven might have a watchstander cover role.

And so you say three investigations instead of two. Fine, that is still low. And you still refuse to give out any more investigation results. What am I supposed to think, hmm?

You're not first on the list, though. Nor do I plan to go after you this night. But right now you're certainly not helping.

CR

[Captain Blackadder]

:shrug: The room of gold was a ruse to make people replace there, night action so they would stop protecting Pro-towns...and if I am not mistaken....they are trying to kill all the watchstanders, so we are blind....:sweatdrop:

But a side-effect(I think) is that you will get killed by the "Blunderbuss killer" if your Protect target is killed....but I have no proof of that:juggle2:

No you don't I must admit I did fall for the gold. Hey I'm a pirate what do you expect Besker died but I didn't. I just assumed it was random chance as GH said and since besker hadn't being attacked yet I assumed he would be fine for one more night.

[Crazed Rabbit]

Well that turned out well, didn't it?
:stare:

CR

[Captain Blackadder]

Yes it didn't but i have learned my lesson no more falling for the lures of that sweet,sweet gold.

[Double A]

:wall:

I can't believe I fell for that! It never even crossed my mind that it was a trick! I trust GH (as far as moderators go) AND he even made it seem like I was spechul instead of it being a dirty trick!

[GeneralHankerchief]

I trust GH (as far as moderators go)

Hey hey hey now, you hate me as a host. Leave the moderator part out of it. :laugh4:

[White_eyes:D]

I just don't get why anyone who was protecting a Pro-town would fall for that:shrug:

I almost fell for it....but then warning bells started ringing in my head, by the fact that most of my group was not sending in there orders, despite being active...:stare:

They didn't even check the PM I sent them....:furious3:

[Beskar]

No you don't I must admit I did fall for the gold. Hey I'm a pirate what do you expect Besker died but I didn't. I just assumed it was random chance as GH said and since besker hadn't being attacked yet I assumed he would be fine for one more night.

I got attacked on Night 5, plus I pretty much warned people in-thread.

[Double A]

Hey hey hey now, you hate me as a host. Leave the moderator part out of it. :laugh4:

Oh I don't hate you, that's such a strong word. I prefer the term "strongly dislike."

[Death is yonder]

No you don't I must admit I did fall for the gold. Hey I'm a pirate what do you expect Besker died but I didn't. I just assumed it was random chance as GH said and since besker hadn't being attacked yet I assumed he would be fine for one more night.

Uh... Beskar was attacked and subsequently saved on a previous night, and being exposed as a "pro-town" sort of or "highly unlikely to be mafia", naturally with all this gold offers and the warnings in the thread, one would think that this is rather widespread and hence meant to cause chaos while the Maven/British attack the now unprotected target...

:inquisitive:

[A1_Unit]

You have to admit is was a pretty convincing PM - White_Eyes:D was lucky to get those hints about the ruse (his team not responding).:yes:

[TinCow]

I just don't get why anyone who was protecting a Pro-town would fall for that:shrug:

I almost fell for it....but then warning bells started ringing in my head, by the fact that most of my group was not sending in there orders, despite being active...:stare:

They didn't even check the PM I sent them....:furious3:

Precisely. I can accept one or two random townies going for it, but a dozen townies, including nearly an entire protection team? It gets even worse though. Remember this post (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=2355870&postcount=1948) by Beskar? I will refrain from mentioning the name of the Watchstander Beskar was referring to there (no, it's not Reenk), but I have been told that person didn't investigate for a FOURTH time last night. This time the excuse wasn't that they were after treasure, but that they submitted their orders late.

All of this coincides with our former solo storyteller now showing up with a partner. We have at least one scum hiding his activities by going along with the excuse everyone else is giving.

FoS: Everyone who backed out on their orders last night.

Vote: Captain Blackadder

Flippant responses come across very much like gloating.

[KukriKhan]

OK, so we've all learnt a lesson here: stick to Plan A. If you're a viggie: vig. If you're a protee: protect. If you're other: do other.

24 of us still live. Of which 1 or 2 are baddies, by my reading. I highly recommend we ignore dead guys and their input; understandably they are trying to eke out what "fun" they can. I appreciate that; but in the end: their contributions are moot. Overcome by reality.

22 vs. 2, worst case. Obviously, we can do this. So let's do it.

PM me:

1) your role PM
2) an accounting, night-by-night, of what you have done during this game.

I'll compare that info you provide, with the write-ups of who has died, been attacked, been protected, and so on, and provide an in-thread report.

At this point, if you lie, it will be found out. And die.

If you fail to respond, you automatically become a target. And die.

So, let's get this over with, and walk away as victors.

[Double A]

Uh Captain should we listen to Kukri?

I'm just curious, and I've basically been under a rock for the last week when it comes to this.

[pevergreen]

And why should we trust you.

I know you like range.

[a completely inoffensive name]

OK, so we've all learnt a lesson here: stick to Plan A. If you're a viggie: vig. If you're a protee: protect. If you're other: do other.

24 of us still live. Of which 1 or 2 are baddies, by my reading. I highly recommend we ignore dead guys and their input; understandably they are trying to eke out what "fun" they can. I appreciate that; but in the end: their contributions are moot. Overcome by reality.

22 vs. 2, worst case. Obviously, we can do this. So let's do it.

PM me:

1) your role PM
2) an accounting, night-by-night, of what you have done during this game.

I'll compare that info you provide, with the write-ups of who has died, been attacked, been protected, and so on, and provide an in-thread report.

At this point, if you lie, it will be found out. And die.

If you fail to respond, you automatically become a target. And die.

So, let's get this over with, and walk away as victors.

I ain't trusting anyone but my Tavern buddies. And you ain't one.

[Captain Blackadder]

Precisely. I can accept one or two random townies going for it, but a dozen townies, including nearly an entire protection team? It gets even worse though. Remember this post (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=2355870&postcount=1948) by Beskar? I will refrain from mentioning the name of the Watchstander Beskar was referring to there (no, it's not Reenk), but I have been told that person didn't investigate for a FOURTH time last night. This time the excuse wasn't that they were after treasure, but that they submitted their orders late.

All of this coincides with our former solo storyteller now showing up with a partner. We have at least one scum hiding his activities by going along with the excuse everyone else is giving.

FoS: Everyone who backed out on their orders last night.

Vote: Captain Blackadder

Flippant responses come across very much like gloating.

I was not being flippant it is a major problem and it will never happen again but in my case it would not have made a differance the write up indicate besker was attacked by multiple people and thus even if I had protected him he still would have died. Ultimitly we need to see the positives out of this we know esxcatly how many people are left for town to kill. Personally I think whomeverthe watchmaster is that failed to investigate is one that needs to be looked at. Or everyone who claims that they were tempted should send the pm to our captain and he can see who is lying. For I doubt that the actual scum got the same message and are using it as smokescreen.

[White_eyes:D]

Two points....1.A couple of people might already have had it before hand(I think Beskar can confirm):juggle2:

2.We might not be able to share it if GH says "NO":sweatdrop:

[Seamus Fermanagh]

It's so sad I am now. Sure'n I let the potcheen do the thinkin' again and thought "well, maybe them other's don't know about that sweet little barricoe of guineas you spied...."

Daft I was. Oh, I made a bit more than I'd've been able to claim for actually doin' the protectin' the Cap'n suggested -- t'weren't quite an Order, mind, I'd no be shirkin tha' -- but what I made weren't worth the risk. I'm fortunate I am that Llugh and the Virgin both saw to it that my chap wasn't harmed in the night.


Now, to put things in plain sight, we've got a watchstander revealing himself....or we have a lyiing rogue trying to hoodwink us all. Placing your votes on summat else is nee good at this point. Either we have to

VOTE: Reenk Roink

or we should believe Reenk, vote for nobody this day, and change captains.

What's it to be lads?

[Louis VI the Fat]

- I can understand the lure of Treasure. But why oh whygo after it just when the town roles have been revelead? And why not inform the captain that you will not be available for the night? (I know of at least one person who PM'ed me he was off to check something out)


- B..but Reenk...why do you claim in a single post to have protected 2 nights AND claim to have a role that doesn't allow you to do protections? :pirate:


Another lie like you said you were going to be quiet about me. :rolleyes: I told you of 3 investigations as well as 2 night actions which I said I wouldn't tell and I'm not going to tell, lynch me with your pro town group or not. I did protect split the first two nights like I said I did.

So again, any reason why you want to kill me before you have confirmation of my role? :inquisitive: It's either utter incompetence or something more sinister to lynch someone caught investigating. :laugh4:

As for the town, here is the proof of my role:


Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

Your role is:

Watchstander

I often think that the night is more alive and more richly colored than the day.
~ Vincent Van Gogh

Someone has to keep the ship going while the Captain and his crew get some sleep (or at least pretend to). That someone would be you. Your job entails basic duties such as making sure the ship is straight, nothing’s falling apart, and watching for potential attacks. However, as the Presence is a streamlined vessel (you heard a rumor that it was originally the personal ship of an adventurous Frenchman) and pretty much runs itself, you have a lot of down time. This means looking carefully at what’s going on.

Your goal: Ensure a Presence victory by eliminating all her threats. As you are a mid-level officer, you are ensured that you will be well-compensated for your work, and thus the accumulation of treasure is not a motivation to you.

Powers: Unlike most of the Able Seamen aboard, you are somewhat limited in the scope of night actions that are available to you. However, you perform your stated duties particularly well.

- Every night, you may investigate two persons on board the ship. This basic investigation will tell you what they were doing that night. Follow-up investigations will reveal more about them, including susceptibility and eventually their true affiliation.
- You are not the only Watchstander on board. Should you find others, you may work together to investigate targets, which will bring about more thorough results in a faster period of time.
- You may not Abandon Ship at any time. Doing so would be a dereliction of duty. Even pirates have that much honor, mate.

Finally, if you are appointed First Mate or Quartermaster, those powers replace your current powers. You will gain your original powers back upon being sacked. Good luck!

Base gold: 115
(unlike in CR's game, this is an actual PM, much hard to forge - and other watchstanders should step up and confirm it)

[Captain Blackadder]

- I can understand the lure of Treasure. But why oh whygo after it just when the town roles have been revelead? And why not inform the captain that you will not be available for the night? (I know of at least one person who PM'ed me he was off to check something out)


- B..but Reenk...why do you claim in a single post to have protected 2 nights AND claim to have a role that doesn't allow you to do protections? :pirate:




Very suspicious

vote reenk Untill he can explain the descrepency.

[KukriKhan]

OK, so we've all learnt a lesson here: stick to Plan A. If you're a viggie: vig. If you're a protee: protect. If you're other: do other.

24 of us still live. Of which 1 or 2 are baddies, by my reading. I highly recommend we ignore dead guys and their input; understandably they are trying to eke out what "fun" they can. I appreciate that; but in the end: their contributions are moot. Overcome by reality.

22 vs. 2, worst case. Obviously, we can do this. So let's do it.

PM me:

1) your role PM
2) an accounting, night-by-night, of what you have done during this game.

I'll compare that info you provide, with the write-ups of who has died, been attacked, been protected, and so on, and provide an in-thread report.

At this point, if you lie, it will be found out. And die.

If you fail to respond, you automatically become a target. And die.

So, let's get this over with, and walk away as victors.

10 hours later:

:crickets:

OK then, have it your way. And nvm. Just trying to do my bit for a town victory.

vote: Reenk Roink

too much subterfuge, not enough "funny".

[shlin28]

:angry:

I cannot believe some people would abandon their worthless duties to get their grubby hands on some shiny gold. What good gold is for when you are dead at the bottom of the ocean?

Vote: Reenk Roink

[A1_Unit]

10 hours later:

:crickets:

OK then, have it your way. And nvm. Just trying to do my bit for a town victory.

vote: Reenk Roink

too much subterfuge, not enough "funny".

I'm not going to tell you everything I've been doing and my shockingly ordinary mass-produced role without CR's orders.

[Centurion1]

Watchstanders cannot prtect they cannot do anything except investigate. oyu sir are a liar.

Vote: Reenk Roink

[Crazed Rabbit]

Stop voting for Reenk. We can verify what he's doing easily enough.

Joooray is on the short list of suspected maven. He's a better choice

CR

[Yaropolk]

CR - how many investigations into RR are we currently? I trust you and all but RR just screams scum at me. Investigator who's lying about his actions to the public and doesn't want to share in the town effort - don't tell me he's clean.

[Crazed Rabbit]

We can verify if he's clean tonight.

For now, do not vote him. I will take it personally...like I did with ATPG.

CR

[Subotan]

Vote:Jooray, since I proposed that he needs a nap with the fishies.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

We can verify if he's clean tonight.

For now, do not vote him. I will take it personally...like I did with ATPG.

CR

:inquisitive:

Fine, Unvote: RR, Vote: Jooray

[Reenk Roink]

So I was getting gold OK? :laugh4: I actually didn't know that we couldn't even protect because in the first two nights I was slaked to protect split and then I got PMs from GH... And frankly, we were never supposed to tell... It explicitly said that in GH's PM.

I don't even care at this point, I'm mulling over whether to even give the 5 other results I had to you guys. And I am not going to be bullied in joining this dumb pro town group that has been infiltrated, even though it looks like the town is in good position despite it. :snobby:

I will work alone, and if you kill me so be it. You guys still are dumb to go and kill a watchstander who hasn't even been checked out yet, just for doing something another watchstander has also been doing?

[Joooray]

Stop voting for Reenk. We can verify what he's doing easily enough.

Joooray is on the short list of suspected maven. He's a better choice

CR

As I said before. I can not be original scum because of the whole LG and w&f situation. Don't believe me, fine, but I am not scum. I don't have much else to offer in my defense, because all the targets I protected with my pt groups, some of which were organized by you, CR, were never attacked.

I have to admit, I was lured by gold last night as well, I don't see any shame in being the greedy pirate I am. :pirate: Also after all you wanted our group to protect Atpg, who you, looking at the write-up, obviously wanted dead anyway. So I don't really understand why you wanted us to protect him, the argument that you wanted to see if we can protect him from being converted sounds a bit fishy in the light of all of this.

Unfortunately I don't have any idea about who might be a better target for the lynch.

[TinCow]

I agree that the Reenk situation can be resolved better with some actions tonight. We just lost one watchstander, we don't want to potentially lose two in a row due to carelessness.

Unvote; Vote: Jooray

[Double A]

I have no idea who to vote for... Seamus is a watchstander so that's not a good choice, and Jooray... is there even a case on him, besides a gut feeling by Pizza?

[TinCow]

Seamus is a watchstander so that's not a good choice

Why do you think Seamus is a watchstander?

[Double A]

I don't, but apparently he is.

[TinCow]

I don't, but apparently he is.

Seamus has been claiming he's a watchstander?

[Double A]

People have been saying he's a watchstander, and CR said not to vote for him.

:shrug:

[Beskar]

First time I heard about Seamus being a watchstander.

[Louis VI the Fat]

OK, so we've all learnt a lesson here: stick to Plan A. If you're a viggie: vig. If you're a protee: protect. If you're other: do other.

24 of us still live. Of which 1 or 2 are baddies, by my reading. I highly recommend we ignore dead guys and their input; understandably they are trying to eke out what "fun" they can. I appreciate that; but in the end: their contributions are moot. Overcome by reality.

22 vs. 2, worst case. Obviously, we can do this. So let's do it.

PM me:

1) your role PM
2) an accounting, night-by-night, of what you have done during this game.

I'll compare that info you provide, with the write-ups of who has died, been attacked, been protected, and so on, and provide an in-thread report.

At this point, if you lie, it will be found out. And die.

If you fail to respond, you automatically become a target. And die.

So, let's get this over with, and walk away as victors.Oh, alright then:


My real role:




Your role is:

The Aquitanian.


When the nightingale sings, a thousand lotusses bloom.
~ Jing Txao Szu

Someone has to keep the ship going while the Captain and his crew run around cluelessly. That someone would be you. As a person of high, noble birth, you expect nothing less than to become captain of this ship. Achieving this is your primary goal. You may do this by any means possible, including putting some patsy in the captain's chair and sabotaging his efforts from within.

There is also an anti-role. The Fleming. This player is out to obstruct you by insults, buffooning around and otherwise making your life misreable. For this insolence he must die. His death is a major objective of your role.

Your goal: Ensure your victory by becoming captain. As you are a natural born officer, you expect to be well-compensated for your work, and thus this position and the accumulation of treasure is your only motivation.

Powers: Unlike most of the lowly Able Seamen aboard, you are not limited in the scope of night actions that are available to you.

- Every night, you may investigate three persons on board the ship.
- You have the power of four able bodied men. Should you attack at night, it will look like a near apocalyptic attack by four strong men on horseback.
- You may not Abandon Ship at any time. You ARE this ship. Others may abandon you, but you don't care since a crew can be reassambled simply by docking at the nearest port and luring the local drunks aboard.

Finally, if you are appointed First Mate or Quartermaster, this lowly position is such an insult to your birth that you must do everything in your power to sabotage the ship and obstruct the voyage. Good luck!

Base gold: 250 Night Actions:

N1 - investigate Sigurd, Rabbit, Grizzly
N2 - investigate Gibson, Scottishranger, KukriKhan
N3 - kill Gibson
N4 - kill Scottishranger
N5 - investigate CountArach, Ricera, Sasaki
N6 - kill CountArach
N7 - find gold treasure

[Yaropolk]

Fine unvote: rr vote: jooray

[Splitpersonality]

Vote: Jooray

[A1_Unit]

Well since Louis has done this:


Your role is:

Able Seaman (townie)

I’m sailing away, set an open course for the virgin sea/I’ve got to be free, free to face the life ahead of me…
~ Styx

Avast, matey! Despite those cursed officers getting all high-and-mighty about their duties, you know that you and your fellow Able Seamen are the backbone of the Presence. After all, it was your hard work that won you the bounty of Charleston, your hard work that keeps the ship in good order, and your hard work that pays for that Captain’s immense salary. This loot you’ve acquired is a huge break, not seen since the days of Morgan, and you’re anxious to get back home and spend it. There’s only one problem: It seems like everyone wants you dead. You’re going to have to fight very hard for this if you ever want to see Nassau alive, and you may even have to… *gasp* use your brains. Don’t panic though, I hear a little rum is good for you mind. Or was that scotch?

Your goals: Unless successfully recruited by either the British Agents or Maven saboteurs, your aim is to eliminate every last threat on board the Presence. In addition, you also wish to accumulate as much treasure as possible. Please check the first post in the Summary thread for exactly how you can boost your treasure total.

Your victory conditions vary, but generally you will score highest if you survive the ordeal, stay on board, and have the most treasure. You will also score well if you survive and stay on board period, accumulate a lot of treasure before dying, or abandon ship with a lot of treasure and the Presence crew ends up losing.

You will not score so well if you die early on, abandon ship with little treasure, or abandon ship and later witness the Presence crew win.

Powers: Each night, you may perform one of the following actions:

- Sleep. This means you will do nothing for the night. However, still sending in the order will net you a small gain in treasure.
- Protect a target with a group of at least three people, including yourself. The chances for a successful protection increase with numbers. All orders must match for a successful protection. You will be awarded the full amount of treasure if the target is still alive at the end of the night, even if he is not attacked.
- Kill a target with a group of at least four people, including yourself. The chances for a successful kill increase with numbers. All orders must match for a successful kill.
- Abandon Ship: Leave the Presence with all of your treasure. Abandoning ship means you depart the game permanently, so choose wisely when you do this. Every night, you will have a random chance of being able to do this successfully.

In addition, you can perform the following actions in the day:

- Vote for who you think should walk the plank.
- In addition to this, you may also try to remove the Captain by voting for a mutiny. The proper way to do this in the thread is Vote: Mutiny. If over 50% of living players vote for a mutiny, the Captain is removed from his position and executed along with whoever has the most votes. You gain a bonus in treasure for a successful mutiny, and only mutineers may participate in the selection for the next Captain.

At any time, you may privately send me a Will detailing who your treasure goes to in the event of your death. You will automatically lose 50 treasure upon dying, but you can dictate who that treasure goes to, if anybody. Wills will only be considered valid if they are sent to me/updated at least three hours prior to your death.

Finally… good luck!

Base gold: 100
Beskar led group:
N1 Protected Beskar
N2 Protected Splitpersonality
N3 Protected Beskar
N4 Protected Splitpersonality

ATPG/CR led group:
N5 Protected Splitpersonality
N6 Protected Splitpersonality

Gold Hunts:
N7 Went Gold Hunting :clown:

[shlin28]

Do we really need to disclose protection targets? They could be pro-towns...

[Louis VI the Fat]

Do we really need to disclose protection targets? They could be pro-towns...For the sensitive information, you can also just PM KukriKhan. Let him sort it out and guide us to victory.

[A Very Super Market]

That role is so out-of-place, what did you even expect when you posted it? Louis is just an investigator, not some supernatural embodiment of the ship itself.

[shlin28]

For the sensitive information, you can also just PM KukriKhan. Let him sort it out and guide us to victory.

Please remind me why Kukri can be trusted with such information. :sweatdrop:

[Subotan]

Please remind me why Kukri can be trusted with such information. :sweatdrop:

He can't. Which is why I'm not giving mine to him.

[Louis VI the Fat]

That role is so out-of-place, what did you even expect when you posted it? Louis is just an investigator, not some supernatural embodiment of the ship itself.I did not take that literally. I think GH meant that I, as natural captain of noble birth, identify myself so much with this voyage that I am not allowed to jump ship.

And it's all real!
I mean, I was tempted to just make some ridiculous stuff up, like 'You are an Italian and thus you can investigate people but not on every fourth night oh and you get really great investigation results too and you don't care about money but you must be first mate and you can kill or protect at night as well'
But I didn't.


I think Kukri made a great offer. Can we trust him? Well I don't know. Let's just PM him our information and see what he makes of it. He's out in the spotlight. If he misuses our trust, we'll know soon enough and then we can always lynch him.

[Joooray]

So, it seems I shall be the victim of a runaway bandwagon. Well, I kill me if you deem it necessary, just rest assured that it shall be another lost lynch for the town.

Also thank you for reacting to my statement. ~:rolleyes:

Fyi:


Your role is:

Able Seaman (townie)

We are all in the same boat in a stormy sea, and we owe each other a terrible loyalty.
~ G.K. Chesterton

Avast, matey! Despite those cursed officers getting all high-and-mighty about their duties, you know that you and your fellow Able Seamen are the backbone of the Presence. After all, it was your hard work that won you the bounty of Charleston, your hard work that keeps the ship in good order, and your hard work that pays for that Captain’s immense salary. This loot you’ve acquired is a huge break, not seen since the days of Morgan, and you’re anxious to get back home and spend it. There’s only one problem: It seems like everyone wants you dead. You’re going to have to fight very hard for this if you ever want to see Nassau alive, and you may even have to… *gasp* use your brains. Don’t panic though, I hear a little rum is good for you mind. Or was that scotch?

Your goals: Unless successfully recruited by either the British Agents or Maven saboteurs, your aim is to eliminate every last threat on board the Presence. In addition, you also wish to accumulate as much treasure as possible. Please check the first post in the Summary thread for exactly how you can boost your treasure total.

Your victory conditions vary, but generally you will score highest if you survive the ordeal, stay on board, and have the most treasure. You will also score well if you survive and stay on board period, accumulate a lot of treasure before dying, or abandon ship with a lot of treasure and the Presence crew ends up losing.

You will not score so well if you die early on, abandon ship with little treasure, or abandon ship and later witness the Presence crew win.

Powers: Each night, you may perform one of the following actions:

- Sleep. This means you will do nothing for the night. However, still sending in the order will net you a small gain in treasure.
- Protect a target with a group of at least three people, including yourself. The chances for a successful protection increase with numbers. All orders must match for a successful protection. You will be awarded the full amount of treasure if the target is still alive at the end of the night, even if he is not attacked.
- Kill a target with a group of at least four people, including yourself. The chances for a successful kill increase with numbers. All orders must match for a successful kill.
- Abandon Ship: Leave the Presence with all of your treasure. Abandoning ship means you depart the game permanently, so choose wisely when you do this. Every night, you will have a random chance of being able to do this successfully.

In addition, you can perform the following actions in the day:

- Vote for who you think should walk the plank.
- In addition to this, you may also try to remove the Captain by voting for a mutiny. The proper way to do this in the thread is Vote: Mutiny. If over 50% of living players vote for a mutiny, the Captain is removed from his position and executed along with whoever has the most votes. You gain a bonus in treasure for a successful mutiny, and only mutineers may participate in the selection for the next Captain.

At any time, you may privately send me a Will detailing who your treasure goes to in the event of your death. You will automatically lose 50 treasure upon dying, but you can dictate who that treasure goes to, if anybody. Wills will only be considered valid if they are sent to me/updated at least three hours prior to your death.

Finally, you are stronger than many men on board and thus you can defend yourself better than a lot of these scurvy landlubbers. Any time a minimum group of players attacks you, you stand a 50% chance of survival. This ability does not expire. Good luck!

Base gold: 100

N1 protection group on TinCow.
N2 protection group on Cultured Drizzt Fan.
N3 protection group on Centurion1.
N4 protection group on Centurion1.
N5 protection group on Centurion1.
N6 protection group on Centurion1.
N7 get my share of the the treasure.

But I guess it is to late now. :shame:

[a completely inoffensive name]

Can the last bad guy make a will giving all his gold to me? I figure I might as well give this a shot. The bad guy doesn't have to PM me to confirm that he did it, but it would be nice if he did.

[Beskar]

And it's all real!
I mean, I was tempted to just make some ridiculous stuff up, like 'You are an Italian and thus you can investigate people but not on every fourth night oh and you get really great investigation results too and you don't care about money but you must be first mate and you can kill or protect at night as well'
But I didn't.

:laugh4::laugh4::laugh4:

[Beskar]

He can't. Which is why I'm not giving mine to him.

He can.

[Joooray]

Vote: RR. For the gold. :pirate:

[shlin28]

He can.

Prove it then... if he does so, he shall have a record of all my actions/whatever he wants.

:yes:

[Beskar]

I think my role was pretty clearly said in the thread. I know who to trust at least.

[Subotan]

It doesn't matter who you trust, you're dead.

[Sigurd]

Base Gold : 250 ? Louis is lying.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Louis is lying.
:laugh4:


I believe that you are Maven. You can join Pervergeen and Pizza in the 'Dead Pirate Misinformation Gallery'. :smash:

[Tratorix]

Hi guyz, Imma Maven, lynch the First Officer!

:laugh4:

[Sigurd]

I was informed at a point just before you traitors lynched me that I was in the lead gold-wise. I had 184 Gold at the time. So.. your 250 gold should have kept you ahead of us by far.

Think about it.... we can only recruit when we have the most Gold. That you had a 150 gold lead on us from the onset would mean we would never been able to recruit. Yet we did, with far less gold than 250.
So ... again Louis is lying.

[Splitpersonality]

I was informed at a point just before you traitors lynched me that I was in the lead gold-wise. I had 184 Gold at the time. So.. your 250 gold should have kept you ahead of us by far.

What night was that?

If you don't mind me asking...

[A Very Super Market]

Louis' entire PM is full of oxen. It's likely he made everything up as a half-joke, so we might as well ignore him. He is an investigator, though.

[GeneralHankerchief]

As I am currently enjoying the comforts of home, I may be a bit late with ending things this round.

Voting may/will be extended until I explicitly say it has been closed in the thread.

[Sigurd]

What night was that?

If you don't mind me asking...
Night 2

[Splitpersonality]

Night 2

Okay, I was just wondering for reference. Thanks.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Vote: Cultured Drizz Fan

[Beskar]

It doesn't matter who you trust, you're dead.

:juggle2:

What have you got to hide, are you the Mafia?

I was a Watchstander, aka the investigator and I know the other pro-town roles and even a few proven innocent townies.

[shlin28]

:juggle2:

What have you got to hide, are you the Mafia?

I was a Watchstander, aka the investigator and I know the other pro-town roles and even a few proven innocent townies.

Then I am happier to reveal to you than to Kukri...

[a completely inoffensive name]

Vote: TinCow

Why? Because this game has been very lame recently. Not enough random accusations since everyone started acting in mafia mop-up mode.

[pevergreen]

Jooray!

Why are you posting the wrong cover PM?

You do know maven got that day 1. :beam:

Prooooves nothing.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Jooray!

Why are you posting the wrong cover PM?

You do know maven got that day 1. :beam:

Prooooves nothing.Is it? I thought it was...Cultured Drizzt Fan who's in possesion of the fake PM we send to the maven?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Voting closed.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Umm, I wouldn't know? I have been innocent the entire game, and helping the town the whole time.

Just so you know I think your Role is a Pile of BS. But I trust CR, so whatever.

I don't see how I can argue against you when your case is just "CDF is guilty" :shrug:

[White_eyes:D]

Showing your "townie" Role PM is a sure fire way your Scum:inquisitive:

I didn't before, I almost was lynched for it. I knew with the recruiting going on, it would just be copied from them. We also need to factor in, that them may have a "cover role" anyway:shrug:

[Askthepizzaguy]

In my opinion, the mafia will have had possession of every role PM. This is a game of conversion, and the watchstander and other PMs have been floated around to untrustworthy types like me.

PS- Time to boil a rabbit.... hehehehee....

[Double A]

Base Gold : 250 ? Louis is lying.

Someone probably wrote him in their will.

[Splitpersonality]

Someone probably wrote him in their will.

At the start of the game? Not likely.

[White_eyes:D]

I spotted a "Not" in Jooray's Role PM:beam:


I’m sailing away, set an open course for the virgin sea/I’ve got to be free, free to face the life ahead of me…
~ Styx


I’m sailing away, set an open course for the virgin sea/I’ve got to be free, free to face the life ahead of me…
~ StyxWe have similar Quotes....but Jooray's is different:inquisitive:

We are all in the same boat in a stormy sea, and we owe each other a terrible loyalty.
~ G.K. Chesterton Unless GH made a mistake...I am willing to bet its a Maven "Cover role":inquisitive:

[miotas]

Bugger, missed the voting by 45min.

[Double A]

At the start of the game? Not likely.

20 players have died. It's quite possible.

[Askthepizzaguy]

At the start of the game, no one was dead. He couldn't have 250 base gold.

We all start with 100 plus recruiting money.

[Double A]

250 base gold?

Ok that's a bit odd... wait didn't he say he's a nobleman?

[Askthepizzaguy]

250 base gold?

Ok that's a bit odd... wait didn't he say he's a nobleman?

Means the Mavens would basically never be able to recruit. :thumbsdown:

I smell the sweet stank of misinformation.

[Splitpersonality]

At the start of the game, no one was dead. He couldn't have 250 base gold.

We all start with 100 plus recruiting money.

Exactly my point.

[Double A]

Means the Mavens would basically never be able to recruit. :thumbsup:

I smell the sweet stank of misinformation.

Fixed for great justice!

Well anyway, that is rather suspicious, unless he loses 20 a night. But that would be too complicated.

[Askthepizzaguy]

The whole PM he posted is silly. Aquitaine is in France and he's French. Also he wouldn't seek the First mate position with that role. And inconsistency: He was very happy with the role he was given, even though he says it would be an insult. And the part about having the strength of four men, obviously a lie. He's just being modest. He could single-handedly pwn every single one of you, until you couldn't walk and you begged God/Allah for forgiveness. Better start wearing a pretty dress, he's coming for you tonight.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I know for a fact that louis was (mostly) speaking the truth...

[Askthepizzaguy]

Well he can prove it by voting for mutiny tomorrow. That will get him the captain's role that he seeks. :2thumbsup:

[Double A]

Yay?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Day 8

Most of the crew of the Presence was in shock all day after the crazy events that had happened overnight, but driven solely through the force of their Captain's will, they still attended to their tasks. Attended to their tasks with vacant, dazed expressions on their faces, but attended to their tasks nonetheless.

Once the record amount of deck swabbing had been completed ("arr," said one old sailor with more than a touch of nostalgia, "I think the only I swabbed more blood was the time back in 'ought three when we fought off four boarding actions one after another. Me boots were dyed red afterwards"), the crewmen proceeded as usual to the vote. They had long since grown to hate and dread this process, as one never knew in which direction popular sentiment would go against on any given day. Nobody ever knew if they were safe.

After the events of the previous night, Captain Crazed Rabbit was in a particularly foul mood, directing his ire at everyone who had forsaken their protection duties to go for the gold sometime over the course of the day. Because of this, quite a few crewmen seemed sheepish about being very vocal or accusatory. However, the officers once again stepped in, with one of the crew pointing out that the only crewman who remained alive on First Mate Louis's list from a few days ago was Joooray.

"Whuh-oh," Joooray muttered to himself as the votes on him steadily piled up after the list was re-revealed and the Captain told everybody to stop voting for his nearest challenger, Reenk Roink. This wasn't looking good for him, and the rest of the day was predictable. The suddenly authority-worshiping crew of the Presence obediently followed orders, leaving him out to dry. As the sun started to set, Joooray knew his fate was sealed.

"All right, lads," Captain Rabbit said sometime later as it was clear that nobody else was going to vote. "It's been a rough day fer all of us, I suspect. Hopefully, it'll only be a rough night fer one o' us, and that only be because he be lookin' fer an island to be marooned on." Everybody chuckled at this, everybody except for Joooray. Nobody bothered looking up at the mast, which was still holding up the ruined Crow's Nest, only barely.

"Right then," Rabbit continued. "Joooray, ye hereby be sentenced to walkin' the plank. Be there anything ye wish to be-"

*SNAP! CRACK!!!*

Finally, everybody looked up. The mast, which had taken a direct cannon hit a day and a half ago thanks to the Four Horsemen, was finally starting to give way. Everybody looked on in horror as dozens of splinters flew down, a rather large one impaling Joooray on the neck.

"Oh... oh God!" somebody moaned, as Joooray, gasping for breath, staggered around the ship. Of course, the splinter happened to pierce his carotid artery. He would be gone now regardless of whether he fell off the ship or not. Meanwhile, pandemonium had taken hold of the crew.

"EVERY ABLE SEAMAN UP THE RIGGING AND TO THE MAST!" Captain Rabbit bellowed, with his officers already rounding up the crew. "TIE OFF THE BREAK WITH ROPE! TIE HER TIGHT, LADS, SHE'S GOT TO LAST US 'TILL WE MAKE PORT IN NASSAU!!!" Everybody was in action at once, running to and fro, climbing, fetching rope, and yelling. Nobody noticed Joooray, still gasping for oxygen, pass out and topple over the deck.

Thirty tense minutes later, and it seemed as if the mast would hold out, Rabbit finally allowed himself a moment to breathe. "Bleedin' Horsemen," he muttered to himself, and retired for the night.

Day 8 tally:

Joooray: 8 (White_eyes, A1, DiY, Subotan, CDF, TinCow, Yaro, Split) :skull:
Reenk Roink: 6 (Joooray, Seamus, Blackadder, Kukri, shlin, Centurion)
Yaropolk: 1 (Reenk)
Cultured Drizzt fan: 1 (Louis)
TinCow: 1 (ACIN)

Abstained: 1 (Crazed Rabbit)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

It is now Night 8. The round will conclude Sunday, October 18th, at 22:00 US Eastern.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Attacked: Centurion1 (n1), LittleGrizzly (n1), taka (n2), Andres (n3), Askthepizzaguy (n4), Beskar (n5), SSNeoperestroika (n5)

Murdered: LittleGrizzly (n1), atheotes (n2), gibsonsg91921 (n2), Tratorix (n3), Iskander 3.1 (n3), Beefy187 (n3), scottishranger (n4), DisgruntledGoat (n4), Andres (n4), Diana Abnoba (n5), pevergren (n5), CountArach (n6), Psychonaut (n7), Beskar (n7), Chaotix (n7), Askthepizzaguy (n7)

Lynched: woad&fangs (d2), Sigurd (d3), Jolt (d4), ricera10 (d5), Sasaki Kojiro (d6), Khazaar (d7), Joooray (d8)

Abandoned Ship: SSNeoperestroika (n7)

Committed suicide: Yaseikhaan (n6)

Removed from play: Xehh II, johnhughthom, YLC

Souls aboard (23):
a completely inoffensive name
A Very Super Market
A1 Unit
Captain Blackadder
Centurion1
Crazed Rabbit
Cultured Drizzt Fan
Death is Yonder
Double A
KukriKhan
Lord Winter
Louis VI the Fat
miotas
Reenk Roink
Seamus Fermanagh
shlin28
slashandburn
spL1tp3r50naL1ty
Subotan
taka
TinCow
White_eyes:D
Yaropolk

[Crazed Rabbit]

Well he can prove it by voting for mutiny tomorrow. That will get him the captain's role that he seeks. :2thumbsup:

No one needs to prove anything to a traitor like yourself, or to any other dead enemies of the Presence lurking about.

CR

[KukriKhan]

Then I am happier to reveal to you than to Kukri...

So do it. I'm wasn't eager to take the role of town-coordinator, I just thought someone should, so we don't unnecessarily kill perfectly good crewmen, and miss bad guys. So I stepped up, since no one else had. If Beskar is a better candidate for town coordinator, send HIM your info. Everybody. Really. I will.

[Louis VI the Fat]

However, the officers once again stepped in, with one of the crew pointing out that the only crewman who remained alive on First Mate Louis's list from a few days ago was Joooray.


Day 8 tally:

Joooray: 8 (White_eyes, A1, DiY, Subotan, CDF, TinCow, Yaro, Split) :skull:
Reenk Roink: 6 (Joooray, Seamus, Blackadder, Kukri, shlin, Centurion)
Yaropolk: 1 (Reenk)
Cultured Drizzt fan: 1 (Louis)
TinCow: 1 (ACIN)Oi! It wasn't my list! I have a different list, and I didn't cast a vote on Joooray. :pirate:

Joooray was the last person on the list of another town group.

[White_eyes:D]

You could get killed because of it though......:juggle2:

Better to wait until tomorrow....if your still alive, I well send you my info...:bow:

But if your going to pull a ATPG and betray that information...."Walking the Plank" well be too good for you:whip:

[Splitpersonality]

I would like to throw my hat into the ring as a trustworthy townie to reveal to as well, I would be more than happy to share the burden, and the danger, I am sure a few people could attest to my trustworthyness.

:bow:

[Double A]

I think we should take a tally of everyone who has a horse on the ship and go from there.

[Centurion1]

we will be keeping it with the capn to be sure, why we would we ever go with split or kukri. no offense mates but you could be converted any day and the mafia would be spending more time to be sure if you were the organizer.

Plus our capn is a little better to defend himself than we simple seamen

[Splitpersonality]

Well I'm sure the captain can speak loads for me, of what I can do.

I'd rather that people reveal to people they're comfortable doing it to, not everyone may trust our captain with their full and unedited role PM at this stage, I'm just saying there are alternatives, but we shall see how things work out tonight before confirming anything :P

[A1_Unit]

Well I've made all my info public and I have nothing to hide.:beam:

[Joooray]

*SNAP! CRACK!!!*

Finally, everybody looked up. The mast, which had taken a direct cannon hit a day and a half ago thanks to the Four Horsemen, was finally starting to give way. Everybody looked on in horror as dozens of splinters flew down, a rather large one impaling Joooray on the neck.

"Oh... oh God!" somebody moaned, as Joooray, gasping for breath, staggered around the ship. Of course, the splinter happened to pierce his carotid artery. He would be gone now regardless of whether he fell off the ship or not. Meanwhile, pandemonium had taken hold of the crew.

"EVERY ABLE SEAMAN UP THE RIGGING AND TO THE MAST!" Captain Rabbit bellowed, with his officers already rounding up the crew. "TIE OFF THE BREAK WITH ROPE! TIE HER TIGHT, LADS, SHE'S GOT TO LAST US 'TILL WE MAKE PORT IN NASSAU!!!" Everybody was in action at once, running to and fro, climbing, fetching rope, and yelling. Nobody noticed Joooray, still gasping for oxygen, pass out and topple over the deck.

Thirty tense minutes later, and it seemed as if the mast would hold out, Rabbit finally allowed himself a moment to breathe. "Bleedin' Horsemen," he muttered to himself, and retired for the night.

Day 8 tally:

Joooray: 8 (White_eyes, A1, DiY, Subotan, CDF, TinCow, Yaro, Split) :skull:
Reenk Roink: 6 (Joooray, Seamus, Blackadder, Kukri, shlin, Centurion)
Yaropolk: 1 (Reenk)
Cultured Drizzt fan: 1 (Louis)
TinCow: 1 (ACIN)

Abstained: 1 (Crazed Rabbit)


Wohoo .. at least I had a fun write up. Thank you, GH. :bow:

Also, does anybody notice how none of the officers who were oh SO convinced of me being scum not voting for me. That's some really smelly fish right there.

As I said, I will be found innocent in 3 days and you guys will have wasted another lynch. Go town! :shame:


I spotted a "Not" in Jooray's Role PM:beam:

We have similar Quotes....but Jooray's is different:inquisitive:
Unless GH made a mistake...I am willing to bet its a Maven "Cover role":inquisitive:

Well, you can still believe that I'm scum all you want. This role pm was send to LG, w&f and me. It is an actually townie pm as you will see in 3 days.

I cannot reveal anything because of being dead now, I guess. But from where I'm standing that ~Styx quote indeed doesn't look too good for you actually. :smash:

[White_eyes:D]

But from where I'm standing that ~Styx quote indeed doesn't look too good for you actually. :smash:
More angry Scum:no:

[Joooray]

More angry Scum:no:

Hey, I'm not saying you are scum, I'm just saying last time I heard about that ~Styx quote it was scum-related. :juggle2:

[pevergreen]

:laugh4:

Oh this is classic.

I guess I'll reveal now.

The quote at the top of your role pm?

Determines how you can (if at all)be converted.

The styx one is maven only.

The terrible loyalty is not at all.

Unsure of the other two.

[Centurion1]

so whats incorruptible than pever. i know do you?

[pevergreen]

Read my post again...

Its ok Cent I already know your true role. :wink:

[Death is yonder]

Well, you can still believe that I'm scum all you want. This role pm was send to LG, w&f and me. It is an actually townie pm as you will see in 3 days.

And how do you know that...?

:inquisitive:

Only 3 people have your role? Interestink...

:inquisitive:

[Joooray]

And how do you know that...?

:inquisitive:

Only 3 people have your role? Interestink...

:inquisitive:

We have been over this. :inquisitive:
GH mistakenly send our townie pm to 4 persons openly, he then said he would not tell if he had rectified the mistake or not. Unfortunately we could not do any good with the situation, because Sasaki decided to make us his arch enemies and killed LG and w&f within no time. :shame:

[Centurion1]

sure jooray....

[taka]

We have been over this. :inquisitive:
GH mistakenly send our townie pm to 4 persons openly, he then said he would not tell if he had rectified the mistake or not. Unfortunately we could not do any good with the situation, because Sasaki decided to make us his arch enemies and killed LG and w&f within no time. :shame:

I confirm to the above, me jooray LG and W&F were originally a protection group until pizza asked to borrow one of ours.

i think the capt'n knows about this as i told him in one of the earlier pms

[Joooray]

sure jooray....

:laugh4:

Fine don't believe me, but that's the way it is and I wasn't aware that it was something I was talking about since it had come up already some time ago and was then already discussed quite in-depth.

And come on, you can't make something like this up. :sweatdrop:
Also finally LG and w&f turn out to be honest able seaman and the only people I have been guilty of associating with were those two. How does that make me scum then?? :dizzy2:

So anyway ... it's a little late to defend myself. The ship wanted me dead and now they have to live with the dire consequences. (one townie dead when it could have been mafia :laugh4: )

[Askthepizzaguy]

Hey Joooray if it's any consolation, I believe you.

[White_eyes:D]

I’m sailing away, set an open course for the virgin sea/I’ve got to be free, free to face the life ahead of me…
~ StyxSeems pretty basic to me...:shrug: No people being depressed like yours...:inquisitive:


We are all in the same boat in a stormy sea, and we owe each other a terrible loyalty.
~ G.K. Chesterton"Terrible loyalty"? I would say your the Maven-convertibles if anything:laugh4:

[A1_Unit]

What do quotes matter when both mafias are almost dead and are not converting? However the person with the rapier ( I think he's the british officer) and the Pirate Tale Killer (Maven, Serial Kiler?:shrug:) seem to be the last threats aboard. But we need to be carefull and not vig kill each other unless we are sure the target is scum.:yes:

[Yaropolk]

Seems pretty basic to me...:shrug: No people being depressed like yours...:inquisitive:

"Terrible loyalty"? I would say your the Maven-convertibles if anything:laugh4:

I'd say quite the opposite:



ter⋅ri⋅ble  /ˈtɛrəbəl/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [ter-uh-buhl] Show IPA
Use terrible in a Sentence
See web results for terrible
See images of terrible
–adjective
1. distressing; severe: a terrible winter.
2. extremely bad; horrible: terrible coffee; a terrible movie.
3. exciting terror, awe, or great fear; dreadful; awful.
4. formidably great: a terrible responsibility.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Also, does anybody notice how none of the officers who were oh SO convinced of me being scum not voting for me. That's some really smelly fish right there.The officers? The officers didn't name you as scum. The Fab Four and Pizza did.

(But I fear my 'I knew Jooray was scum all along but Sasaki would have none of it!!1' was taken more seriously than it was intended. :embarassed:)

Me I went for Reenk because he's talking rubbish. But I decided to give him one more night to prove himself. My vote was on CDF to pressure him. Then the round ended already.



~~-~~-~~-~~:pirate:~~-~~-~~-~~



Hey Joooray if it's any consolation, I believe you.

People remaining from ATPG's original suspect list:

a completely inoffensive name
Joooray
miotas
Subotan
A Very Super Market
:book:

[Askthepizzaguy]

I put Joooray off of my suspect list, if you check. Due to him getting the same townie PM as others who were proven townie. Even edited the post saying something along the lines of "keep forgetting Joooray's alibi".

But no matter. I'm sure there was a reason we lynched him, right?

[Louis VI the Fat]

I'm sure there was a reason we lynched him, right?Bandwagonning, players not sending in their orders so we didn't get our detective results, our focusing in previous rounds on the English first instead of the final Maven, and time constraints after first having to spend all day trying to establish what happened during that messy night.

Such is life. :beam:

[White_eyes:D]

I'd say quite the opposite:

~ The thing I hate about an argument is that it always interrupts a discussion. ~ G. K. ChestertonI don't think you can beat me with this Yaropolk:bounce:

Jooray was scum and I will stick by it till the end of the game....you all know how I guessed split was emergent scum:clown:

[Reenk Roink]

Lynching Joooray was dumb, the only scummy thing he did was vote for me at the end to save himself.

I don't trust the officers aboard this ship whatsoever. CR I have been in contact with a bit more often recently, and he seems more trustworthy (maybe he just does a better job than Louis of acting like a decent and loyal Pirate) but his officers just go forth and run the show flinging poop on others while being coated with the most poop.

You may have gotten lucky to be caught investigating like a good boy on n4 Louis, but I'm watching you... :brood:

My guess is that Yaropolk and Louis are the last two bad guys.

[Subotan]

I put Joooray off of my suspect list, if you check. Due to him getting the same townie PM as others who were proven townie.

Any twit could have posted that, since it was practically public knowledge by the time he had released it.

[White_eyes:D]

I need to admit....I don't trust you Reenk:no:

You are acting WAY to paranoid to be a Pro-town....I could be wrong....but when you played as "The Watcher" you really kicked :daisy:.

I am having a bit of a hard time believing that you don't feel the need to share the results:inquisitive:

[Reenk Roink]

I need to admit....I don't trust you Reenk:no:

You are acting WAY to paranoid to be a Pro-town....I could be wrong....but when you played as "The Watcher" you really kicked :daisy:.

I am having a bit of a hard time believing that you don't feel the need to share the results:inquisitive:

Fillet Royale had an anonymous letter system, you've got to be kidding me if you're going to compare the two situations... :rolleyes: And weren't you there in Prometheus when I shared all the results like a good boy? :rolleyes:

I've shared them with CR and told him NOT to tell his officers. Now if he does, his loss, as he blabbed to me to the whole town in the first place.

I don't follow these leaders because my decisions and ideas are the ones I like the most. :snobby:

[White_eyes:D]

Yeah.....I see your point...:juggle2:

Well its all good then...:yes: But your still too dangerous....look how you 360'ed my wanting you dead...:sweatdrop::laugh4::laugh4:

[Askthepizzaguy]

Any twit could have posted that, since it was practically public knowledge by the time he had released it.

:inquisitive:

No, my friend, I think you misunderstood what I was saying.

As I recall from this very thread, Joooray was CC'ed the same able seaman pm as a few other townies, which was stated by the other townies who had his name up on the CC along with theirs. So the case isn't me being a twit, it's me pointing out that there were other dead now-proven townies who can vouch for him getting their same PM in one volley of PM deliveries. That's all. The only way he's guilty is if he was recruited. Because I highly doubt GH sent 6 mafia PMs and due to the mistake said "ha ha, starting mafia, one of you is no longer mafia. Now forget who your partners were. Forget. For-get...."

Once the mafia have their starting PMs, it's difficult to change this. You'd have to strip all of them of the status of being mafia and start over. No one mentioned this happening, and a townie would have reason to suggest that they were mafia until a host error took that away from them.

So even if joooray were mafia, which I'm not convinced of, he's still not the main target. I'm not saying this to go "ha ha wrong", I'm saying this as a reminder to give it some thought before we vote. As for bandwagonning, I am not sure how you lynch a mafia without several people voting for the correct target, which constitutes a bandwagon.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Lynching Joooray was dumb, the only scummy thing he did was vote for me at the end to save himself.

I don't trust the officers aboard this ship whatsoever. CR I have been in contact with a bit more often recently, and he seems more trustworthy (maybe he just does a better job than Louis of acting like a decent and loyal Pirate) but his officers just go forth and run the show flinging poop on others while being coated with the most poop.

You may have gotten lucky to be caught investigating like a good boy on n4 Louis, but I'm watching you... :brood:

My guess is that Yaropolk and Louis are the last two bad guys.Whatever.

You claim pro-town, you claim investigator, so share your results then with the town roles you've no doubt discovered.
Also, the English are gone. On N4 there were only single killers. So if you 'caught me investigating' (I doubt it) you know it wasn't me so you have your proof that I am not scum.



:playingball:


Reenk: 'Looky! I am an investigator. But I've been protecting the first two two nights!'
Louis: 'Sorry, but the very Watchstander role you claim doesn't allow you to do protections'
Reenk: 'Oh. Oops. Erm...I mean, uh...I did send in two protectiop orders which probably would've failed then!'
Louis: 'GeneralHankerchief's first night result would've told you that your protection failed. So there's no way you would've send in protection orders the second night again'
Reenk: 'Please people! Don't listen to Louis! He is full of poop!'


:inquisitive:


Watchstander: 'Reenk's been caught investigating, but he hasn't shared results with anybody'
Pirate: 'Maven can investigate too. It's in the rules....'
Reenk Roink: 'I'm a Watchstander! I've been protecting and doing investigations twice!'
Pirate: 'A Watchstander? And only two investigations?'
Reenk Roink: 'Oh, sorry. I mean three times!'
Pirate: Trice?'
Reenk Roink: 'Oh sorry. I mean five times!'
Pirate: 'Care to share results then?'
Reenk Roink: 'No! I do not share my results with anyone! And please, nobody trust the officers! They are full of poop!'

[a completely inoffensive name]

I don't know why but I am sticking behind Reenk, maybe its because I am paranoid also and I don't want a fellow cautious person to go needlessly.

[pevergreen]

Seems pretty basic to me...:shrug: No people being depressed like yours...:inquisitive:

"Terrible loyalty"? I would say your the Maven-convertibles if anything:laugh4:

You serious?

Both myself and ATPG had the styx quote.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't why but I am sticking behind Reenk, maybe its because I am paranoid also and I don't want a fellow cautious person to go needlessly.

Regarding Reenk:

He's a known quantity, he can be protected, can be blocked (unwise), can be investigated more. He's not a danger. If he's mafia, he's trapped.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Reenk will have the opportunity to prove himself. But not the opportunity to go plotting and scheming against the town.

Edit: Why am I responding. You are the pro-mafia misinformation camp.:smash:

[Reenk Roink]

Whatever + bad attempt at humor mixed in with worse analysis

On night 4 there were single killers yes. So that's the only thing going for you at the moment. However, this rapier killer just jumped out of nowhere, hmmm. Perhaps a convert after you investigated n4, converted n5 or n6?

Your attempt to make me seem like I'm changing my story is just even worse. Much before you had any clue who I was, and were happily flinging poop at regular Pirates (most likely so you and your partner didn't have to do the kills yourselves), CR got word from me who I was, and I gave him 3 investigations I did.

He then later said it was 2 in the thread which I corrected him.

Then I mulled over just going ahead and giving the 5 remaining investigations I had (a watchstander gets 2 per night he investigates in case you forgot).

So your misconstruing of this whole situation is due either to:

1) a deliberate attempt to mudsling a watchstander so that the town rids themselves of him
2) just not having the analytic capability to do it correctly

Both reasons are grounds for people NOT to listen to you and removal from your position.

[TinCow]

I don't follow these leaders because my decisions and ideas are the ones I like the most. :snobby:

Independent ideas are good. None of us are perfect and multiple minds are far more likely to catch the scum than a single one. However, I do believe that in this case CR and Louis are trustworthy. I'm not sure if you noticed, but I had some problems with 'the management' early on as well. I think my change in attitude should be proof enough that I am no longer suspicious of them.

All considering, I think they're done a pretty good job. The mafia are on their last legs, and that's thanks in large part to them. If you're actually a watchstander, give them a chance, and we can finish this game off soon.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Independent ideas are good. None of us are perfect and multiple minds are far more likely to catch the scum than a single one. However, I do believe that in this case CR and Louis are trustworthy. I'm not sure if you noticed, but I had some problems with 'the management' early on as well. I think my change in attitude should be proof enough that I am no longer suspicious of them.

All considering, I think they're done a pretty good job. The mafia are on their last legs, and that's thanks in large part to them. If you're actually a watchstander, give them a chance, and we can finish this game off soon.

Bull. The only reason we are alive is because of the Four Horsemen. They killed a maven on the first night and killed what looks to be a Brit suicide pact. If it wasn't for those, the enemy would have been much more organized and we would have much less townies by now.

[pevergreen]

Yeah yeah, four horseman, go core their apples elsewhere.

Would people stop putting ATPG in the Maven camp? He was never part of the maven!

You're destroying my credibility as a completely loyal townie as confirmed by the writeup.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Yeah yeah, four horseman, go core their apples elsewhere.

I'm sorry if the truth is not to your liking.

[Reenk Roink]

Reenk, I need you to tell me honestly, if you are mafia or not. I need to know this because what you tell me could determine if you are killed tonight. (And don't assume that if you tell me you are innocent you won't be killed and vice versa.)

Got this PM.

Well guess what, I'm a watchstander, and you can go and kill me for all I care. But I'm sick of the lies from the top, the four horsemen and the Bess killer agents of good just because they killed a few Maven/Brits. HAH! This is all an elaborate conspiracy and they are playing you all like suckers.

P.S: These are the kind of people Louis works with. :thumbsdown:

[Subotan]

So, your reply is basically "I have no proof to back up what I'm saying, but there's a conspiracy out to get me, so you should all believe me"
Right :inquisitive:

[a completely inoffensive name]

Got this PM.

Well guess what, I'm a watchstander, and you can go and kill me for all I care. But I'm sick of the lies from the top, the four horsemen and the Bess killer agents of good just because they killed a few Maven/Brits. HAH! This is all an elaborate conspiracy and they are playing you all like suckers.

P.S: These are the kind of people Louis works with. :thumbsdown:

So much for protecting you from the officers.

[pevergreen]

Well nothing is stopping those four horsemen from winning. Who says that are aligned with the town.

Protecting him? You said you were going to kill him.

[Reenk Roink]

Big deal, I'm dead. First of all, the town could scramble a protection on me, I have had people protecting me before this.

Second if I die, it confirms:

1) There is a conspiracy at the top, or the top doesn't have a clue and is working with killers to kill good guys.

2) The top doesn't care enough to protect me, or even ordered a hit.

The townies eyes will be opened, because I'm a martyr and I will lead the Pirates to the promised land. :2thumbsup:

[Subotan]

Well nothing is stopping those four horsemen from winning. Who says that are aligned with the town.

You have no idea what our alignments are. Stop making your assumptions out to be fact, sympathiser.


Protecting him? You said you were going to kill him.

He is going to end up dead without us protecting him. He made a conscious decision to turn us away.

[Reenk Roink]

He is going to end up dead without us protecting him. He made a conscious decision to turn us away.

What? A guy sent me a suspicious *** PM essentially asking me if I was Mafia. I replied in public because I'm sick of the lies and game that I'm a watchstander.

If you guys wanted to protect me, why wouldn't the PM ask: "Reenk are you really a watchstander? If so we will protect you."

Instead of asking this line:

(And don't assume that if you tell me you are innocent you won't be killed and vice versa.)

[pevergreen]

Oh so you're one of them?

Fair enough.

Please PM the names of the four of you. I will not reveal them to anyone, I'm just going to put the names on a list of mine.

A black list, if you will.


Why do I presume the FH are anti-town? ACIN. Thats why. You're certainly not pro-town.

He may end up dead, frankly I don't care. I tried to work with him and he wouldnt get near me.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Well nothing is stopping those four horsemen from winning. Who says that are aligned with the town.

Protecting him? You said you were going to kill him.


I didn't say I was going to kill him. I didn't realize dead men could make accusations.

My suspicions have been from early on in this game that one of the officers or town leaders is a mafia somehow and has attempted at playing the part of pro town since the beginning.

I believe whoever this is, is the reason why a pro town group (F.H.) who has had as much success at killing mafia is somehow portrayed as enemies.

I said earlier that i sided with Reenk against the accusations and I sent that letter because I believe the mafia infiltrator is playing his game plan of accuse and pick off townies one by one from a position of power unchecked.

I wanted him to admit to me that he was town through and through so I could rally my Tavern friends to protect him and prevent the mafia infiltrator for another day.

[pevergreen]

I can do pretty much whatever I want. :beam:

Except stuff that breaks the rules.

Yes, you've had success. But was it calculated or just blind luck.

You cannot tell me the group of you calculated and proved that a person was maven night 1 (was night 1, wasnt it? someone said that just above) and kill them, beyond doubt.

If you want to him admit, he already has? You're asking him to re-reveal in private?

[a completely inoffensive name]

What? A guy sent me a suspicious *** PM essentially asking me if I was Mafia. I replied in public because I'm sick of the lies and game that I'm a watchstander.

If you guys wanted to protect me, why wouldn't the PM ask: "Reenk are you really a watchstander? If so we will protect you."

Instead of asking this line:

(And don't assume that if you tell me you are innocent you won't be killed and vice versa.)


Because if I said, "tell me if your are mafia or not and I will protect you" then I have laid all my cards out on the table and let myself be susceptible to manipulation and lies from you if you were a mafia.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Oh so you're one of them?

Fair enough.

Please PM the names of the four of you. I will not reveal them to anyone, I'm just going to put the names on a list of mine.

A black list, if you will.


Why do I presume the FH are anti-town? ACIN. Thats why. You're certainly not pro-town.

He may end up dead, frankly I don't care. I tried to work with him and he wouldnt get near me. So :daisy: him.

1. Louis already confirmed I am pro town.

2. I am not a part of the F.H. I guess my friend Subo is but I am simply the only person not willing to buy into the officers portrayal of them.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Let me pull a Reenk and post a conversation I am having with Pever.





Want the game to end a wee bit sooner?

Get louis. You wouldn't have though both officer positions would be maven at the start would you.

:beam:

Louis has protection everywhere. It is impossible to get him.


Less than you'd think.

1 protection foils 1 attack.

He has one (if at all) protection tonight.

That is being targeted. I believe rapier killer. Or storyteller. One of the two. Most likely rapier, they tell me.

Join in against louis and he goes bye-bye, game has one more to kill.

i don't trust you. you have no reason to help me. you accuse me of being in the F.H. (I am not but I guess my buddy Subo is.) your words are wasted on me.

[pevergreen]

Fake some more PM's please.

[a completely inoffensive name]

lol nice try. Took you 18 minutes to come up with that?

[Crazed Rabbit]

:stare:

Do NOT kill Reenk tonight, 'four horsemen'.

There's two options; he is what he say he is and is acting somewhat normally, in which case you've killed a watchstander, or he is bad in which case we can lynch him tomorrow. There is a much better target for tonight.

Do NOT listen to Pevergeren. He is NOT pro-town.

Do not give him any information, either. He is a liar; Louis was investigated by the same watchstander killed by the Maven recently.

CR

[Askthepizzaguy]

:dizzy2:

Serious mode-

Guys, relax. It is just a game. It isn't worth it. :bow:

[pevergreen]

lol nice try. Took you 18 minutes to come up with that?

I'm at work, I have a job.

I just did up invoices in that time. Got to bill customers.



Do NOT listen to Pevergeren. He is NOT pro-town.

its confirmed I'm not anti-town. I don't have an alignment. True Neutral, you may say.

[Crazed Rabbit]

There's a special place in Davy Jones' locker for pirates who are neutral when under attack. :evil:

And yes, I was joking (about spelling your name). I was hoping the 'P' and the 'geren' would make it obvious.

CR

[Louis VI the Fat]

On night 4 there were single killers yes. So that's the only thing going for you at the moment. However, this rapier killer just jumped out of nowhere, hmmm. Perhaps a convert after you investigated n4, converted n5 or n6?Officers can't be converted while in office.

The British are dead. We are looking for a Maven. Louis and Rabbit lynched Sigurd for being a maven. So the officers can not possibly be Maven. The officers are cleared.



Anyway, we are not out to kill you. Just trying to establish your role. Maybe the horsemen can protect you tonight? The Maven are reading this thread in delight, what with the prospect of a possible watchstander and a possible sudden defection of his protection group.



Pervergeen - yes, send the attackers to come after me tonight. :2thumbsup:

[Double A]

.
blah blah blah it's not Pevergreen it's pevergreen

Aside from that, its confirmed I'm not anti-town. I don't have an alignment. True Neutral, you may say.

I'm going to say that I'm not exactly proud of this, but I'd just like to point this out:









Hey duuude.

You interestd in joing the maven?

We need to know how much gold you have.

Also CR's already suspicious of me for dropping last night's protection. :sweatdrop:

Yeah I know that.

I may get back to you

Oh thanks for the bloody encouragement!

:clown:

Uhh you are dead right?


Yeah im dead confirmed townie by writeup.

I'm not sure how the game is going right now. Those 4 horsemen are creepy, so is the Blunderbuss guy. I like living, so... And I'm not sure what that storyteller guy is up to.

And CR probably is having me investigated as we speak.


Is that a bad thing? if so I may be able to divert it.

No idea. But I can't exactly join the Maven, and you haven't even given me a good reason, if I'm unsusceptible to the booty.
[/SPOILER]

[Crazed Rabbit]

Hmm. Pever strives to defend Reenk. And recruit for the Maven. Perhaps Reenk is Maven as well.
:inquisitive:
CR

[Louis VI the Fat]

Double A - that's the scummiest thing I've ever read, and I don't mean the faked pevergeen part.

[Double A]

I admit I was honestly considering it because I never get to be mafia. I'm serious, out of the 20 games I've played I've been mafia 3 times.

But then I looked at the tread and saw how the game was going. If I accepted, why the heck would I have revealed it?

[pevergreen]

And yes, I was joking (about spelling your name). I was hoping the 'P' and the 'geren' would make it obvious.


And yea, as did he read the post, the white hot rage came upon him. And yea, he did not even bother to read the rest of the name, for he knewest that the rage was upon him.

(I didnt even realise you spelt my name wrong :beam:)


As I have explained, I tried to join the maven but didn't. The post-mortem results from GH are always correct. I actually asked him to change it to make me show up as maven but he refused.

Since they wouldn't help me, I aint helping them.

I could end this game right now, reveal the identity of both the storyteller and the rapier killer. But I won't. Because that would be mean. And not fun!

Strive to defend RR?

He's given me nothing. Doesnt respond.

Double A: I just wanted to know how much gold you had. Someone told me it would be worth knowing for my maven friend. (As in may be close)

[Louis VI the Fat]

Double A: I just wanted to know how much gold you had. Someone told me it would be worth knowing for my maven friend. (As in may be close)The maven needed to know if they were in the lead for money so they could start converting. But they have already converted. So they didn't need to know it at the time this conversation was alleged to have taken place. Which means you and Double A's plan to make Double A look non-maven failed.

Apart from that, the entire conversation is non-sensical. The answers don't follow the questions. The bit about 'Also CR is suspicious' was meant to come later. The other bits are mangled up too. The conversation is a forgery. It made me more suspicious of Double A.

fos:
Double A, for original maven
Reenk for convert. His behaviour in the thread changed dramatically since the Maven conversion.

[pevergreen]

OK. Lets put aside discussion:

Louis, can you point me to the part where the Maven recruited someone?

Two conversions, both british. Ricera, Sasaki, Scottish, Khaan and CA. 5 Brits.

3 maven: Sigurd, Gibsong and the last one.

I'm aware maven need to be in the lead. And they are (i believe) i was told to find out how much double A had.

Kill/lynch the original maven, the convert dies. (Same as brits) I was told that by them.

[Louis VI the Fat]

OK. Lets put aside discussionNo.

If it was real, you'd have denied it. If it is fake, you'd try to change the subject when found out.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I just came back from a long train ride and not in the best of moods right now.

Thread temporarily locked until I sort this out. The round has been extended indefinitely.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Thread open, but everybody needs to chill. It's just a game, people. ~:grouphug:

This round has been extended until Monday, October 19th, at 11:00 US Eastern (slightly over 12 hours from now).

[a completely inoffensive name]

This is why we can't have nice things.

[ricera10]

This is why we can't have nice things.
Definitely. :yes:

[Joooray]

Wow, this ship is still worthy of being a pirate ship. Full to the deck with blood thirsty, arguing buccaneers. Well enacted, guys!! :sweatdrop: :laugh4:

Also, thank you, Atpg, for believing me. That is some consolation for this restless soul haunting this ship. :beam:

[Khazaar]

Sigurd: Shhh!
Khazaar: What did you say?
Sigurd: Shhh!
Khazaar: Good plan.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Night 8 has ended, no more orders will be accepted.

Please allow me some time to grab breakfast first before I process orders and do the write-up. :yes:

[TinCow]

Please allow me some time to grab breakfast first before I process orders and do the write-up. :yes:

Breakfast at 11am? You must be in college... :laugh4:

[GeneralHankerchief]

Breakfast at 11am? You must be in college... :laugh4:

I have a class at 9:55 and there's no way I'm getting up that early to grab it before class. :laugh4:

[KukriKhan]

Night 8 has ended, no more orders will be accepted.

Please allow me some time to grab breakfast first before I process orders and do the write-up. :yes:

Pop Tarts?

Bacon and Eggs?

Oatmeal?

[Subotan]

The workload must be pretty intense if you're doing this and college at the same time.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Pancakes, and yeah, my social life is suffering, but it's all good. You don't get the chance to host a Large/Huge game very often. :2thumbsup:

Processing now.

[Beskar]

I love how the Maven - Sigurd, PM'd everyone to vote: Mutiny.

[Askthepizzaguy]

It won't be necessary after tonight. Muhuhuhahahahahahaa!!!!

[A1_Unit]

They forgot me!:bigcry:

[GeneralHankerchief]

Night 8

After taking a night off, the Four Horsemen had saddled up and were ready to ride again. While they had no actual steeds aboard (they had discussed this and were actually thinking of buying horses of their own with the treasure they had accumulated), they had all of the mentality required to take up the job as vigilantes answerable to no one. After all, it was they who had taken down a Maven and at least one British agent. It was they who had possibly ruined the British by killing another one, with the final autopsy investigation due this morning. It was they who had nearly disabled the Presence's mast in a spectacular attack on CountArach. It was they who were taking the ship's destiny into their own hands.

And so they rode.

Their target tonight was Reenk Roink, who they found above deck, softly humming a tune to himself. Drawing their cutlasses, they did not even attempt to stealthily approach him. Reenk, meanwhile, simply looked up, regarding the Horsemen coolly.

"Well," he said, "judging by your numbers and lack of rapier or blunderbuss or stories, it's clear that my vanquishers are going to be the Four Horsemen," and his lack of fear or even anxiety in his voice was what troubled the Horsemen the most. "So what are you going to do? Chase me around the ship, set some more fires, blow a hole through the rudder this time? All very entertaining propositions, but I'm afraid I must decline."

"Actually, we weren't," said the lead Horseman, "this time we were just going to throw you overboard. Plain and simple this time."

"Arr," said Reenk, falling back into his pirate demeanor, "but to do that, laddies, ye'll be needin' all yer Horsemen pals, and I only be countin' three o' ye."

"Wha-?" The Horsemen stopped for a second, looking at each other, counting. A split second after it finally clicked in their brains that one of them was indeed missing, Reenk charged at them, tackling one of them and beginning to gouge his eyes out.

"Ack!" the one on the floor gasped, unsuccessfully trying to pry Reenk's hand off him. "Get me some help, lads, me left eye's almost out!" The two other Horsemen jumped down, trying with all their might to pull Reenk off their buddy. Thirty long seconds later, they were all on the ground, panting from the effort, but Reenk had succeeded. The one Horseman was clutching his now-empty eye socket, moaning in pain.

"Now, lads," Reenk said to the two remaining coherent Horsemen, "we could duel and ye could get more of the same, or ye can help yer friend calm down and find him an eyepatch. It shouldn't be too hard to get one. This is a pirate ship, after all." He grinned and drew his cutlass for the first time. "So, what'll it be?"

After a moment, the two Horsemen cursed at him, helped their friend up, and took him back below deck, trying to pretend they couldn't hear Reenk's soft chuckling as they walked away.


A flash of silver caught Centurion1's eye. Even though the sky was cloudless, it was still night out, which meant the metal in question would have to be exceptionally polished to catch the moonlight. A moment later, Centurion was able to witness that he was right. The object in question was a rapier, moving so fast that it was a blur, yet its beauty still distinguishable in the moonlight. Centurion, who had very good reflexes, had to be as quick as he ever was to take his blade out and parry the furious attacks.

It quickly became clear that Centurion's typical pirate tactics were no match for the work of this blademaster, and he found himself backpedaling much faster than he would have liked. The dueling went on for some time, but eventually Centurion was disarmed and his attacker was about to strike the killing blow.

Suddenly, something caught his attacker's eye to the right. Three figures, blades out, were advancing on their position. The attacker looked at the helpless Centurion, regarded the advancing figures one more time, and then looked at Centurion again, hissing the words "next time" before retreating below deck.


"Lovely night," First Mate Louis VI the Fat said to his Captain, Crazed Rabbit. The two of them were killing time, the Officers' Cabin looking less and less appealing by the night. Instead, they were sitting on the edge of the Presence, their backs facing the water.

"Aye, Louis, that it is," Rabbit said back. "Makes ye truly appreciate the finer things in life, ye know?"

"Indeed," said Louis. "The calm sea, all of the treasure below deck, the promise of what all awaits us back home in Nassau, the thought that we owe our loyalty and fealty to no one but ourselves, that's a comforting and pleasant thought indeed. Sure, Captain, we may be needin' to follow yer word while we're aboard, but that's only temporary and nobody will care once we get back to Nassau. All of us aboard this ship are truly free, and there are precious few folk in the world who can say that. Personally, I'm right glad to be one of 'em."

Rabbit was silent for a long while. Finally, he slowly replied. "It may not be the case in the future, Louis," he said, choosing every word carefully. "Look at us. Our kind is dying out, much as we hate to admit it. The British don't need us anymore, so our years of friendship and business with them has turned to animosity. Likewise with the French. Heck, even our berth tells us something. We used ter have our pick o' the litter, port wherever it was convenient, be it Port Royal or Tortuga or anywhere else so long as they had a friendly governor. But now, all of us are stuck to the one place where the British haven't bothered cracking down on yet. Nassau. It makes for a great party, aye, but it's still a sad state."

Louis nodded. "Times change, mate," he said. "We're trying to fight it off for as long as we can, hold back the good life, but there's no denying it."

"Aye," said Rabbit. "Do you realize that we very well have pulled off the last great raid in the world? The Brits are clamping down everywhere. Once word of this gets back to Mother England, you know we'll pay for it in spades. You can tell the pickings be mighty slim these days when another crew, desperate for payout, tries to take what's rightfully ours. If we ever get back to Nassau alive, we'll be regarded as heroes, sure, but then eventually the money will be gone, and we'll need to set out again."

"And lightning doesn't strike twice in the same place," Louis said.

"Aye, ye said it. There will never be another Charleston," said Rabbit, sighing. "The payouts will be less and less, the opportunities fewer and fewer. And if this cursed voyage be any indication, the few truly free people left in the world will be turnin' on each other, trying to stay afloat. We'll be doin' the Crown's work for them. And our kind will slowly die out, forever replaced by the shackles of bondage."

Louis nodded, looking seriously depressed at the prospect. "Then I suggest we enjoy our time in Nassau more than anybody has ever enjoyed anything."

"Evenin', First Mate," came a voice off to Louis's right. He turned, acknowledging the voice's owner, hoping that he would continue with his business. However, much to the First Mate's chagrin, he did not, instead plopping right beside Louis on the ship's edge.

"You know," said the newcomer, "a night like this reminds me of Francois l'Olonnais. Ye both know who the great l'Olonnais was, right? A pirate in the time of Morgan, some say his greatest rival..."

"Please, sailor, no stories tonight," said Louis, holding his hand out. "The Captain and I be needin' some time to think, and thinking's done best in silence."

"Really?" said the sailor, mildly off put. "That be too bad, matey, fer all that my story does is delay yer own death." In a flash, the newcomer had his cutlass out, slashing directly for Louis's neck. The First Mate was barely able to duck out of the way when Rabbit drew his own Captain's blade out and started to duel Louis's attacker.

"This be an interestin' prospect," said the attacker. "Protectin' yer mate solo? Now, unless ye be a Steward, methinks that really not be workin' out."

"Be silent," Rabbit growled. "Surrender now and I'll kill ye now instead of in front of the crew."

"Okay, fine, I surrender," said the attacker, dropping his cutlass. Using Rabbit's temporary shock wisely, he grabbed Louis and whirled him in front of him before either of the officers knew what was happening. Certainly, Rabbit didn't comprehend it quickly enough, for he finally recovered from his shock to stab the attacker, not registering that Louis was in the way until the blade had pierced his heart.

"Oh... Oh God, Louis..." he muttered, as the soon-to-be-former First Mate had already fallen to his knees. Meanwhile, the attacker had already retreated.

Louis, in shock, stared down at his wound, and then up at his Captain, his eyes glazing over. The First Mate would never enjoy himself in Nassau for possibly the last time, after all.


As dawn broke, Captain Crazed Rabbit ordered, for the first time, a full funeral for the First Mate. There was no chaplain aboard, of course, but it was a worthy ceremony for a lifelong man of the sea, with his body being lovingly lowered into the water to end it all. Afterwards, Rabbit was so distraught that he immediately withdrew into his cabin, leaving Quartermaster TinCow to begin the day's voting and announce the day's autopsy investigations.

"Well lads," he said, "this be a sad day fer all of us, but I do have excellent news. Sasaki Kojiro was at one point a loyal crewmen, but at some time during the voyage got charmed into becomin' traitor and joining the British. Likewise with Yaseikhaan. It's likely that they were both recruited by CountArach, who was as British as they come - he was their Special Officer, their lead man. All of this means that the British presence aboard is likely gone. Take heart while ye vote today."

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

It is now Day 9. The round will end Tuesday, October 20th, at 14:00 US Eastern.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Attacked: Centurion1 (n1, n8), LittleGrizzly (n1), taka (n2), Andres (n3), Askthepizzaguy (n4), Beskar (n5), SSNeoperestroika (n5), Reenk Roink (n8)

Murdered: LittleGrizzly (n1), atheotes (n2), gibsonsg91921 (n2), Tratorix (n3), Iskander 3.1 (n3), Beefy187 (n3), scottishranger (n4), DisgruntledGoat (n4), Andres (n4), Diana Abnoba (n5), pevergreen (n5), CountArach (n6), Psychonaut (n7), Beskar (n7), Chaotix (n7), Askthepizzaguy (n7), Louis VI the Fat (n8)

Lynched: woad&fangs (d2), Sigurd (d3), Jolt (d4), ricera10 (d5), Sasaki Kojiro (d6), Khazaar (d7), Joooray (d8)

Abandoned Ship: SSNeoperestroika (n7)

Committed suicide: Yaseikhaan (n6)

Removed from play: Xehh II, johnhughthom, YLC

Souls aboard (22):
a completely inoffensive name
A Very Super Market
A1 Unit
Captain Blackadder
Centurion1
Crazed Rabbit
Cultured Drizzt Fan
Death is Yonder
Double A
KukriKhan
Lord Winter
miotas
Reenk Roink
Seamus Fermanagh
shlin28
slashandburn
spL1tp3r50naL1ty
Subotan
taka
TinCow
White_eyes:D
Yaropolk

[Subotan]

ATPG, what's with the puple/italic writing?

EDIT:Darn, looks like one of us is half blind :| Also, we decided to, uh, dispatch RR with all four of us. We have the PMs to prove that all four horsemen attacked RR. So what happened to the third?

[Language please - GH]

[TinCow]

Also, we decided to, uh, dispatch RR with all four of us. We have the PMs to prove that all four horsemen attacked RR. So what happened to the third?

I think the answer to that one is pretty obvious. :stare:

[Sasaki Kojiro]

ATPG, what's with the puple/italic writing?

EDIT:Darn, looks like one of us is half blind :| Also, we decided to, uh, dispatch RR with all four of us. We have the PMs to prove that all four horsemen attacked RR. So what happened to the third?

[Language please - GH]

Most likely one of you was roleblocked.

I'm rooting for you by the way, for proving that rogue vigilante groups are the way to go :beam:

[Crazed Rabbit]

Poor Louis. :shame:

Soon, though, I'll get some investigation results that will narrow down the suspects considerably.

CR

[Subotan]

Bah. Serves him right for attempting to blackmail members of his own crew.

[Crazed Rabbit]

Perhaps we should lynch the people who tried to kill a watchstander, hmm?

:stare:

CR

[Louis VI the Fat]

Bah. Serves him right for attempting to blackmail members of his own crew.You've had two days of a chance to complain about it when I was still alive, tough guy. :pirate:

But let's find the maven, instead of rooting for their kills. :whip:

[Subotan]

Despite the fact that you yourself said:

Hmm. Pever strives to defend Reenk. And recruit for the Maven. Perhaps Reenk is Maven as well.
:inquisitive:
CR

We are merely trying to provide a public service, yet you keep on hating on on us. We don't get the recognition, nor the love we deserve.:shame:

EDIT: I did Louis, in a pm to CR. I was merely bringing it to the attention of the wider crew.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Despite the fact that you yourself said:


We are merely trying to provide a public service, yet you keep on hating on on us. We don't get the recognition, nor the love we deserve.:shame:

EDIT: I did Louis, in a pm to CR. I was merely bringing it to the attention of the wider crew.What hating? We are trying to establish who everybody is. Pressure, including blackmail to see if there's a rotten apple in a vig group, is very efficient.

Sasaki had been hiding in a vig group, no?

A vig group is an excellent alibi. Once we know who's been involved on the night of a murder, these perrons are off the hook. Surely you have noticed that I haven't been after any of you four since the situation was resolved after our extensive PMing back and forth? That I even offered to give you the list of suspects last night, so that you four fine gentlemen can take your pick, should you desire more of your 'unconventional nighttime activity' - as was my exact phrase?

[Subotan]

What hating? We are trying to establish who everybody is.

I dunno, but a lynch doesn't sound particularly friendly.


Pressure, including blackmail to see if there's a rotten apple in a vig group, is very efficient.

There are no mafia in our vig group. It's impossible, since we've been acting together since the beginning.


Surely you have noticed that I haven't been after any of you four since the situation was resolved after our extensive PMing back and forth? ?

Yes, we had noticed that, and we appreciate it.


That I even offered to give you the list of suspects last night, so that you four fine gentlemen can take your pick, should you desire more of your 'unconventional nighttime activity' - as was my exact phrase?

Yours and my definitions of "unconventional" are somewhat different.

[Crazed Rabbit]

I dunno, but a lynch doesn't sound particularly friendly.


Eh, you're not going to be lynched. I just wish you not to speak ill of the loyal dead.

And I know which one of you was roleblocked, so your vig group is a quite good alibi.

As I said, soon the suspect list will be narrowed down.

CR

[Sigurd]

Time to end this evil regime...

vote: Mutiny

[Crazed Rabbit]

You're dead, Sigurd. :inquisitive: :laugh4:

And we're so very close to the last mafia member. :evil:

CR

[A1_Unit]

Time to end this evil regime...

vote: Mutiny

Nice try.:laugh4:

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I say we mutiny, get the gold, and select one of the four horseman as the new captain. Surely they have shown themselves to be more deserving than CR, who relies on detective results as an old lady relies on her CRUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUTCH????

Vote:Mutiny

[Crazed Rabbit]

You're dead too, Sasaki, and a British traitor at that.

Funny how the mavens and british want me out of office. :beam:

CR

[Sasaki Kojiro]

You're dead too, Sasaki, and a British traitor at that.

Funny how the mavens and british want me out of office. :beam:

CR

I voted mutiny before I was converted ~;)

And "hid in vig groups" for that matter too...

I also said before the game I would get converted if I was susceptible...the night 2 conversion should have been a big hint that an obvious first round investigation choice had been converted :juggle2:

(notice how the losing team always tells the winning side how they could have done better... :laugh4:


But really CR, you became Pizza 2.0 in this game :no: , why don't you step aside* and let one off the deserving vigilante's have the office?

*or rather, off the side

[Louis VI the Fat]

You're dead too, Sasaki, and a British traitor at that.

Funny how the mavens and british want me out of office. :beam:

CRI guess you must be doing something right. :beam:


*returns to Davy Jones' locker to fight the evil Maven and Brit scum there*



Edit: Sasaki, we were sooo all over the British. Didn't take us all that long to figure out who you guys were. :pirate:

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I guess you must be doing something right. :beam:

Either that or it's reverse psychology ~;)



Edit: Sasaki, we were sooo all over the British. Didn't take us all that long to figure out who you guys were. :pirate:

Now you are claiming credit for the four horseman's good work :no:

[Askthepizzaguy]

Your time is at an end, Crazed Rabbit.

Vote: Mutiny.

Perhaps you didn't know, but the dead, or rather the undead, will be soon taking control of this ship. And it will be renamed The Flying Dutchman.

[Crazed Rabbit]

But really CR, you became Pizza 2.0 in this game :no: , why don't you step aside* and let one off the deserving vigilante's have the office?

*or rather, off the side

Don't be so cruel! :sweatdrop:

I kept ATPG in check; he wanted you killed the instant you weren't cooperating. And if I was ATPG, I would have gone to war with the town vigilantes like he wanted to.

But I didn't, because I'm not him. Instead, I allowed them to operate, only stepping in to prevent them from killing a watchstander.

Oh, and another traitor wants me lynched. You became really suspicious when you tried to talk your way out of being killed after pretending to offer yourself for the lynch so many times, you know ATPG.

CR

[Louis VI the Fat]

Now you are claiming credit for the four horseman's good work :no:Not at all. Honour to whom honour is due. I've even congratulated the four horsemen in the thread for their excellent work.

As to the English...why didn't CA kill on his final night? Because CR had him pin-pointed and role-blocked. Which saved us a townie. Just like the officers had Ricera lynched the day before. It was game over for the English.

But congrats to the horsemen for finding Scottishranger!
And their hit on Gibson on N2 - if deliberate - was great too. They got him in two days, which is even faster than it took Rabbit to out Sigurd. (Although Sigurd hadn't been receiving results and information from us ever since D2)



Now back to sleep in Davy Jones' locker, together with all the other scum. The last Maven is a needle in an ever decreasing heystack. The net is closing in on him fast.

[TinCow]

They got him in two days, which is even faster than it took Rabbit to out Sigurd. (Although Sigurd hadn't been receiving results and information from us ever since D2)

Yes, all hail CR for his stupendous work in catching Sigurd. I'm sure he worked real hard on that one. :stare:

[Subotan]

Eh, you're not going to be lynched. I just wish you not to speak ill of the loyal dead.

I speak what I like about who I like.

Although thanks for not lynching me.


And I know which one of you was roleblocked, so your vig group is a quite good alibi.

As I said, soon the suspect list will be narrowed down.

CR
Oh?I'm guessing AVSM, or ACIN.



As to the English...why didn't CA kill on his final night? Because CR had him pin-pointed and role-blocked. Which saved us a townie. J

Is that true? Because ATPG said that he had no idea that CA was British, so how could he have roleblocked CA?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Don't be so cruel! :sweatdrop:

I kept ATPG in check; he wanted you killed the instant you weren't cooperating. And if I was ATPG, I would have gone to war with the town vigilantes like he wanted to.

But I didn't, because I'm not him.

CR

Pizza 1.2 then :laugh4:


Not at all. Honour to whom honour is due. I've even congratulated the four horsemen in the thread for their excellent work.

As to the English...why didn't CA kill on his final night? Because CR had him pin-pointed and role-blocked. Which saved us a townie. Just like the officers had Ricera lynched the day before. It was game over for the English.

The FH killed CA (and all living converts...) and scottish. Pizza got ricera lynched as I recall...

Why CA didn't kill would be an interesting story, I'll tell you about it sometime :beam:

[Louis VI the Fat]

Meh, let us rather return to finding the last Maven, instead of playing the 'Dead Mafia Game' of changing the subject and burying useful information under a massive post barrage.

[Crazed Rabbit]

Is that true? Because ATPG said that he had no idea that CA was British, so how could he have roleblocked CA?

Well ATPG thought pevergreen was British, so I wouldn't look for information in what he knows. :beam:

And I was the one ordering the roleblocks anyway.

CR

[Chaotix]

Interesting. Sigurd has PM'd all of the dead people and asked them to vote mutiny in hopes that the living will follow along and bandwagon.

It seems he's forgotten that we all know he's mafia scum... or otherwise he thinks we've forgotten that fact.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Seamus staggered up to the heads, fished out his wedding tackle, turned to port and began to pump bilge. As hung-over as he was, it was several seconds before he was aware that the gods of the sea were reminding him to pass water to loo'ard and not to windward.

"Ah, Jaysus, Mary and..."

At this point, soaked from mid-thigh down and recoiling from his own excreta, Seamus stumbled backward landing with his his head on the bulwark behind him and knocking himself unconscious. Twenty minutes later, the quartermaster kicked him awake and ordered him to scrub the heads since he liked that area of the deck so much.

Half an hour -- and 4 or 5 not so gentle heaves -- later, Seamus walked towards the foc'sle hatch.

"Vote: Lord Winter," he said. "Bustard's been too quiet by a half for my liking."

Seamus quickly slid down the ladder to head for his kit and search for the other pair of breeches.

[Subotan]

That is quite a smelly way of telling us that you're voting for Lord Winter.

[shlin28]

Vote: ACIN

[Tratorix]

A mutiny of the dead seems like fun. Vote: Mutiny.

[White_eyes:D]

In addition, at any point in the day phase you may vote to mutiny. You may do this by adding in a Vote: Mutiny in with your normal vote. If over 50% of alive players vote to mutiny, the Captain is lynched along with whoever has the most votes, and instead of proceeding to night, a new Captain selection process follows. If the vote is tied, the status quo remains.
This dead guy mutiny...is starting to confuse me:no:

I hate to ask....but could you all stop?? I understand if it's a Mafia tactic but I don't think you should Bold them like that then...:whip:

[Tratorix]

This dead guy mutiny...is starting to confuse me:no:

I hate to ask....but could you all stop?? I understand if it's a Mafia tactic but I don't think you should Bold them like that then...:whip:

Its symbolic. :rolleyes:

[CountArach]

As to the English...why didn't CA kill on his final night? Because CR had him pin-pointed and role-blocked. Which saved us a townie.
It was also because I couldn't...

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't think you should Bold them like that then...:whip:

That's a fair enough point. I doubt it would actually confuse the game host but if there were living players voting for mutiny it could become a pain in the :wall:

I'll edit mine out as it wasn't a legal vote anyway.

[White_eyes:D]

The dead may post, but not vote/select nor carry out any night actions. Dead players may not reveal their roles publicly or privately and may not reveal their faction or role particulars either. It should be the dead can't post....I can't even tell what is going on anymore....:whip:

[Tratorix]

It should be the dead can't post....I can't even tell what is going on anymore....:whip:

Fine, it's not bolded anymore. Happy?

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Soooo. I guess we don't have anyone to vote for? No cases against the last whatever he is?

I know that I was one of the people investigated last night, PM mix up :laugh4::laugh4: But I am at a loss as to who could be bad.